3 ms·
"Will want to" yes. But it was not being offered until after that extensive union activism despite decades of demands. To the point that people died for it. May
by vidarh 3y ago
"Will want to" yes. But it was not being offered until after that extensive union activism despite decades of demands. To the point that people died for it. May 1st is the international day for labour demonstrations because of the US union fight for the 8 hour day. The demand long preceded a rise in income allowing people to risk walking over it, or be able to afford to offer to take less pay for less work.
It took decades from the demand was there until it became normalised to offer it, with concession after concession won as direct and explicit outcomes of industrial action.
That good conditions are offered far more easily when a working population is in a financial position to walk if it's not offered is entirely unsurprising and irrelevant. That you can't possibly win the same level of outcomes when the financial position of employers doesn't allow it is also entirely unsurprising and irrelevant.
Nobody expects magic. Nor does anyone suggest that there aren't other factors also at play.
- eru 3y agoDifferent income levels between countries already suffice to explain most of the variation we see in things like actual provided worker safety etc. History of union activism is an explanatory variable that doesn't add much to the mix, and if anything is rather contradictory and noisy in the end.
- vidarh 3y agoGiven we can look back at history and see direct causal links between industrial action and subsequent improvements, there is no way to take this seriously. I have no doubt you're right that it correlates neatly with different income levels, but I find it comical that you think that addresses the issue. I also note that you claimed working hours as a normal good whose demand would rise with income but ignored the point that the demand far preceded the economic ability to bargain for it with money, and that the demand was not constrained by lack of money. The notion that it fits your description at all is bizarre. EDIT: I'll also note that after having had time to skim the article you linked, it does not appear to even attempt to make an argument aligned with yours. The author very specifically points out significant confounding factors, such as whether or not unions resistance in the specific given conditions affected productivity negatively or hindered productivity improvements. A union certainly can make a wrong tradeoff - Indian unions prioritised keeping the intensity of the work down, at the cost of reducing their then-future ability to demand higher incomes. But they were only able to have that negative effect on future wages because their activism had a substantial effect on working conditions and by extension productivity. That their goal was short sighted does not change that if anything it is a demonstration of the substantial impact unions do have. That there is a risk that a too successful union can end up having an adverse effect by accident is nothing new either - it's if anything one of the historical conflicts within the labour movement in terms of outlook on the approach between seeing it as about conditions at individual workplaces or tied to local concerns vs. inherently a political and society-wide and international concern.
- eru 3y ago> I also note that you claimed working hours as a normal good whose demand would rise with income [...] No, leisure is the normal good. And so is safe food and clean air etc. > Given we can look back at history and see direct causal links [...] How do 'see' direct causal links? Just because people work to achieve X, and then X happens, is not a direct causal link. Eg praying for winter to be over, doesn't mean that there is a direct causal link with spring coming eventually. And fans cheering for their sports team to win, don't have much of an influence on whether their team actually wins. Or to give an example from history: the assassination of Franz Ferdinand is often seen as the event that triggered the Great War; but few people assign it much importance as an underlying cause. > I have no doubt you're right that it correlates neatly with different income levels, but I find it comical that you think that addresses the issue. If income levels explain all the variation between countries, and levels of union activism are just noise, I am not sure why you need to appeal to union activism as a cause? It's like looking at the correlation between taking antibiotics and recovery from infection, but then adding fervent prayer as a causal explanation for some reason. The tide eventually receded from King Canute, but that's not because of anything he did. EDIT: I mostly agree with your edit. A parasite should be careful not to kill the host.
- vidarh 3y ago> No, leisure is the normal good. And so is safe food and clean air etc. You got what I meant unless you're being obtuse. The point remains that the demand preceded the financial ability to bargain for it. It was independent of income. > How do 'see' direct causal links? By looking at when employers offered concessions in order to end strikes etc. Now you are being obtuse. Go back and look at newspaper archives from major labour conflicts and the concessions negotiated with the union actions as the direct and immediate reason cited by employers themselves, even at times after having spent fortunes on people like Pinkerton to try to intimidate and harm workers to get them back to work first. > If income levels explain all the variation between countries, and levels of union activism are just noise, I am not sure why you need to appeal to union activism as a cause? I've seen no evidence that they explain all the variation. I've agreed they likely correlate with much of it. Now consider that income-differences do not just magically spring into existence either, and while there are certainly multiple factors again we have extensive examples of direct cause and effect in terms of negotiation and subsequent agreements. > A parasite should be careful not to kill the host. When you describe workers as parasites, that is utterly vile and explains a lot. And so we are done here.