3 ms·
A straw man is a distorted or mischaracterized recapitulation of another person's argument. This distorted argument can then more easily be attacked. It's a ver
by fdschoeneman 3y ago
A straw man is a distorted or mischaracterized recapitulation of another person's argument. This distorted argument can then more easily be attacked. It's a very common way for politicians, ideologues, and other dumb people to argue.
Sometimes, fair or unfair, a straw man argument can even be effective at winning over a crowd.
In this case the writer is distorting what Andreesson wrote in order to attack it. Here's an example:
"...it’s part of a broader movement that seeks to take all the guardrails off of technological development and push forward with “progress,” whatever the cost may be."
One thing I can say with almost 100% certainty - even though I have not read the manifesto -- is that Andreesson would never make such a stupid argument. Only an idiot would make such a dumb and absolutist argument, and only a politician or other dishonest person would try to assign such a dumb argument to her ideological opponent.
I've no doubt that readers of gizmodo, big government socialists, and many of their fellow travelers found this piece and it's writer to be a fresh new voice for the deep state and managerial classes. But I'm underwhelmed.
- chaps 3y agoHow can you call it a strawman if you haven't read the manifesto that the supposed strawman is for? Doesn't that make anything you say about the manifesto an accidental strawman because your, apparently intentional, lack of reading distorts your own arguments in order to convince others? Or at least make it indistinguishable from a strawman? Just go read the damn thing, friend. Sheesh.
- fdschoeneman 3y agoI don't know you and I'm not your friend. I have since read the manifesto and while it was always obvious even without reading the manifesto that the author of this piece distorted it, I can now say for sure that he distorted it. It's a straw man.
- chaps 3y agoThanks for reading it, friend. Love and kisses, and I hope your family is doing well in these hard times. <3