3 ms·
Maybe it's a dumb question, but how do we know these biomarkers weren't from eating fish that are the seaweed? If the biomarkers are able to remain detectable
by crazygringo 3y ago
Maybe it's a dumb question, but how do we know these biomarkers weren't from eating fish that are the seaweed?
If the biomarkers are able to remain detectable for thousands of years without breaking down, perhaps they're also able to accumulate in fish?
I don't know anything about it so my idea is probably wrong, but I'm surprised the article doesn't mention it since it seems like an obvious thing to wonder.
- dboreham 3y agoDo fish eat seaweed?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- steve_adams_86 3y agoSeveral do, both fresh and salt water. Goldfish are a well-known plant-eating fish. You can’t keep them in aquaria with certain plants because they’ll nibble them relentlessly.
- pvaldes 3y agoThere are a few coastal fishes In Europe with a diet of mostly seaweed. They are very common but often discarded because their taste is awful and they don't preserve well. People that eats them assures first to remove most of the blood. The taste depends a lot of the type of seaweed.
- undersuit 3y agoI think they kind of cover that: > They found the chemical biomarkers of seaweed and aquatic plants in 26 samples, which suggests that early humans were eating—or, at the very least, chewing—these bounties from the sea Like, yeah maybe the fish they were eating was covered with seaweed, but unless they were popping the stomach/intestines into their mouth... for the parasite load(?), the seaweed in the fish is digested. This isn't Carbon-14 dating, they identified families of plants on the the ancient teeth, not digested plant matter.
- crazygringo 3y agoThere are plenty of compounds that aren't broken down by digestion. Salmon flesh is pink because of the astaxanthin in its natural diet, for example. And the article doesn't make any mention of which specific biomarkers they chose or whether they're affected by digestion. They're obviously pretty hardy compounds to begin with if they're not broken down by saliva to begin with, or thousands of years of natural decay. And it does seem kind of akin to carbon-14 dating. It's not like they found actual recognizable pieces of the plants in between their teeth or anything.
- undersuit 3y agoDon't worry: >Aquatic ecosystems are complex with some isotopic variability even within the same species of seaweed, freshwater algae, and freshwater aquatic plants (macrophytes), making use of this C&N isotopic data to detect these resources somewhat challenging, certainly where it represents <20% of the diet. Moreover, while stable isotopic analysis remains valuable in providing a broad view of major foods consumed, this is dependent on the dietary protein intake, with seaweeds lower in protein compared to meat or fish, and can therefore be overlooked due to equifinality, where other foods can, in combination, be used to explain the stable isotopic data observed, sometimes in contradiction to other archaeological evidence available. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41671-2#Sec8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41671-2#Sec8