4 ms·
Wireless is a trap (2020)
- umeshunni 3y agoI followed his advice during the pandemic and switched to wired ethernet and a wired mic and headphones. When I speak on Zoom calls, people often comment on Zoom calls how good the audio quality is. The only thing I miss is the ability to walk around taking calls.
- jonathanlydall 3y agoThey were quite pricey, but I’ve been very happy with my Steel Series Wireless Arctic Pro headset which I got a couple of years back. It uses a base station, but runs a proprietary wireless protocol which can do very high quality bidirectional voice. Comes with two batteries, one can charge in the base station while you’re using the other. I swap it each morning and lasts the day fine. I also chose it based on its aesthetic choice of not looking garish like just about every other gaming brand headset. They can also be used over Bluetooth too, but will be lower voice quality in such cases.
- umeshunni 3y agoI got the Philips open side headphones he recommended in his blog post and they have worked well for me. The only downside is they are gigantic and people also comment on my head size to headphone size ratio.
- the_pwner224 3y agoTry the Antlion Audio Modmic Wireless. It's a wireless boom mic that magnetically attaches to your regular (wireless/Bluetooth) headphones. (There's a small magnet that you permanently adhere onto the side of your headphones, the modmic connects to that) From some YouTube comparison videos I found before purchasing, the quality of the modmic/wireless is vastly superior to the builtin mic on most headsets - even the more expensive business/conference and gaming headsets. It's not quite as good as a standalone desk mic, but it's not too far off. Plus if you already have a nice set of headphones that you like - I have a set of Bose noise cancelling ones - you can keep using those; you don't need to sacrifice incoming audio quality by moving to a headset. The only downside is the battery life is ~12 hours. As an IC who doesn't have tons of meetings, I only need to charge it every 2-4 weeks. But if you're a manager that may be more annoying. Tip: Use a hair dryer to heat up the adhesive on the magnet before you stick it onto your headphones. Otherwise it might fall off later.
- umeshunni 3y agoSince I missed the link, here's his blog post about how to improve video calls: https://www.benkuhn.net/vc/ https://www.benkuhn.net/vc/
- zzo38computer 3y agoEven before reading this, I also preferred wired connections for many reasons, including the ones listed here as well as that a wired connection can be connected to a specific port (although it is still a problem with USB; I think that USB has many problems too even though it is wired).
- blt 3y agoThe one I really don't understand is wireless keyboards and mice for desktops. Sure, let's add a battery, some unreliability, and clutter up the radio spectrum for two objects that never move relative to one another.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoI could never go back to a wired mouse at this point. The difference in drag/weight is so noticable when I forget to charge the mouse and have to use it plugged in mid-day.
- dale_glass 3y agoWireless mice are fine. The ones that aren't stupidly designed like Apple's have the connector on the front, so when plugged in it's just like a wired mouse. I find it's nice not to have that wire on my desktop, it would keep bumping on other stuff I like to have close.
- adrian_b 3y agoIt is possible to avoid wires for the graphic pointer, without requiring batteries or wireless connections, by replacing the mouse with a stylus and a graphic tablet (configured in the "relative" mode). This substitution has the additional benefits that a stylus is much more comfortable, faster and more precise than a mouse.
- babypuncher 3y agonot very good for games though, and i think comfort might be debatable/user preference
- Novosell 3y agoPlaying PC games with a stylus would be an interesting experience.
- omginternets 3y agoI'm the other way around: these things actually move around on my desk, so if there's anything I want to cable-cut, it's those. Wifi on the other hand...
- mvdtnz 3y agoAlso add keyboard and mouse. Although the wireless ones are pretty reliable, if you're shopping to a budget you will get much better equipment if you go for wired versions.
- culebron21 3y agoTotally agree. Moreover, every bluetooth connection is a pain in the neck with the logic, which device auto-connects to which -- every time it's different: when the loud speaker is turned on, the phone sees it in the active list, but may pick it automatically or may not! It's completely random. Sometimes it takes 2 attempts, enabling/disabling bluetooth and turning the device off && on to make them connect. Laptop may steal-connect headphones from the mobile, if it knows them. I guess there's been some logic written for managing these auto-connects, but it's now a complete mess. Had to install a special audio system in ubuntu to work with Bluetooth headset with microphone -- it took years for it to appear, apparently. It does work -- although you have to go down some menus to turn mic on, and with the last update you can't switch back to hi-quality playing without mic -- it just stops working at all. But the biggest disappointment was that the old Logitech H600 headset now stops working in a minute or two after connecting! This is modern software. Instead of a mechanism that turns, clicks and snaps, it's just a contraption that may work sometimes or may not. Johnathan Blow is absolutely right in his observations. PS. Despite that, I should say wireless USB-dongle-mouse works fine for me.
- sandinmyjoints 3y agoAre there any plans for a Bluetooth successor that would be, in a word, better?
- j16sdiz 3y agoBluetooth keep getting better in each version. If you want something new ( and no backward compatibility burdens), there are none
- throw_5152 3y agoYeah, I wire everything too. A couple of years ago I happened to mention to a non-technical person (I think HR) that I don't use Wifi. The person replied inquisitively, "Then how do you get internet?" Some people don't realize there's another option.
- tkfu 3y agoOne brand new wifi gotcha I just learned about, specific to 5GHz wifi: in the EU, that frequency band is used by other things, including radar for air traffic control and emergency services aircraft. The solution we decided on for that was to mandate that all 5GHz wifi devices stop broadcasting for a period of 1-10 minutes whenever a "privileged user" demands it. I discovered this only when I moved to a place that has a higher-than-usual incidence of helicopters flying by and my wifi would randomly disconnect. I eventually solved it by finding the channel within the 5GHz frequency band that was least used by privileged users in my area, and now I only have a drop about once a month. But it used to be 3 or 4 times a day.
- tpolzer 3y agoUnless your 5 GHz spectrum is crowded by other WiFi, you really want to be on channel 36, because that way you do not have DFS at all, see the table on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_WLAN_channels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_WLAN_channels
- jstanley 3y agoThe most annoying wireless drawback is devices that won't work while charging. My MPOW wireless headphones are great, but when I plug them in to charge they can't play sound. Why!? It would be so much more convenient if they degraded to "being wired" while charging, instead of degrading to being totally unusable.
- mackrevinack 3y agoanother plus for using a bluetooth reciever. something like the fiio btr3. it still works while charging and can be used with any headphones or earbuds. it will hopefully last me longer too since i probably have more chance of replacing the battery compared to the types that are in headphones
- durandal1 3y agoI'm happily wireless for all my non-work activities. My work station however, is all wired. A couple of distractions per week is a couple of distractions too much.
- ghusto 3y agoYup. I now have a pair of 8 euro earphones I carry around in my bag for calls. They work the instant they're plugged in, there's no "can you hear me" bollocks, no lag, sync issues, and the sound quality is miles better than anything Bluetooth could muster. Wireless headphones are inferior to wired headphones in every way that matters. Wireless mice — good ones — are worth the hassle. Mostly because they seem to just work for the most part.
- skydhash 3y agoWireless headphones are very good for their particular use case—not being tethered to a device. If your phone or a DAP, wired can work fine. But it can be an issue if you're listening from a laptop or a desktop and you need to move. I have a pair of wireless earbuds and a pair of wireless headphones that I use only when I want this convenience. But for meetings, I always use my wired headphones. Voice over bluetooth is always atrocious when using the microphone.
- ghusto 3y ago> Wireless headphones are very good for their particular use case—not being tethered to a device But that's an end-result, not a use-case, no? I can think of only one situation where the faff of wireless headphones could be justified (though not for me), and that's exercise. Personally, I'll take the slight annoyance of cables getting in the way, but I can understand not everyone would. Wireless headphones are a pet-peeve of mine, ever since Apple set the world off getting rid of the high-quality 3.5mm jack. It's sadly disappearing fast, and nobody notices the abysmal sound quality demotion, because they're mostly listening to poor quality streaming services anyway :(
- vel0city 3y agoNo, its a use case and a huge feature. During the work day my wireless headphones are pretty much always on. I'm able to get up from my desk and stretch, get something from across the office, go to the kitchen and make lunch, go check the mail, do pretty much anything around the house without needing to take them off. Having the headphones not physically tethered to the device is the point. I don't have to literally disconnect from whatever media I was consuming or conversation I was having just because I stood up from my desk. And then I also don't have a cable flopping around while I'm at my desk. I don't have a cable to get tangled up. I'm not limited to whatever length of cable I need to connect properly, the headphones work anywhere in the room. I charge the headphones overnight at my desk every few days, so charge levels are never really a concern. I'd use wireless headphones exclusively on my gaming PC if it wasn't for the latency and HSP using a lousy codec. Newer Bluetooth standards will solve that HSP quality problem and really reduce the latency concerns. Its a massive pain having to deal with my wired headphones on my gaming PC compared to my experience on my work setup or personal laptop with my bluetooth headphones. And as for out and about, my bone conduction wireless headphones are leagues more convenient than any wired headphones. Not quite as high of quality, but for the convenience and non-isolation properties they're excellent for just out and about ambient music. I also wear them when gaming on the couch with my laptop while watching a show with my wife while she knits. I can hear the game just fine, I can hear the show, and can carry a conversation with my wife without wires all over the place on my lap and couch.
- ydnaclementine 3y agoThis is the only thing I fight about when moving into a new apartment with my gf. I encourage you to decorate however you want, but please give me ethernet access
- twobitshifter 3y agoi’ve heard people heaping praise on Apple earpods for having the best microphone for calls. I wondered if this is just that they are the only wired microphone people have ever used or if there is actually any difference there?
- xboxnolifes 3y agoThe only explanation I can think of is they are comparing them to other ear buds. It would be easy to be the best ear bud mic when they are universally bad.
- massysett 3y agoThe article mentions how Wi-Fi polling hinders performance. I had this problem but didn’t want to run a wire. Various software solutions worked only sporadically. So for quite awhile my solution was a WiFi range extender. It had an Ethernet port. So I disabled the range extender features and plugged my computer into the extender, which then connected wirelessly to the router. This worked quite well and was inexpensive - maybe the wifi extender was $35. It was of course astoundingly and infuriatingly janky to do this - connect a wire to a completely superfluous radio just to dodge an idiotic software problem. But it worked, so I should just regard it as a clever hack. Eventually though I got a MoCA adapter and ran a cheap Cat 6 cable to it, which has even higher speeds and is less janky, though I do have to snake the wire around the room. But after tacking it to the baseboard it’s barely visible. I own my house so I could run Ethernet through the walls but this MoCA gets me 95% of the way there so I doubt I’ll ever bother.
- mackrevinack 3y agowhen i was younger we made good use of those headphone splitters to share music on the bus home from school or wherever. how long has bluetooth been a thing now and it still doesnt have that feature? i use bluetooth headphones here and there but i would never consider it to be a replacement to analog
- LTL_FTC 3y agoI guess it depends on the phone but iPhones allow users to share their music with a buddy. Note it does require use of their headphones: https://support.apple.com/guide/airpods/share-audio-on-iphone-or-ipad-dev3786f35c8/web https://support.apple.com/guide/airpods/share-audio-on-iphon...
- MisterTea 3y ago> I used zip ties to keep all the cables in a single bundle, and coiled excess length in a loop behind my monitor. I much prefer using double sided velcro strap that can be easily removed and reused. It comes in a roll so you can cut it as long as you want. I mostly dislike using zip ties unless it's close to permanent or a quick fix. > To route the power strip’s cable cleanly, I attached a cable raceway to the back of one leg. Consider using wire duct (sometimes called Panduit, a brand of wire duct) to manage cables by mounting a length to the underside of your desk. The fingers allow you to break out wire and cables anywhere along the length then tuck the slack inside and snap the cover on. You don't even need to tie up the slack though it helps. Used all the time in industrial machinery control cabinets.