10 ms·
AMD Introduces New AMD Ryzen Threadripper 7000/Pro 7000 WX
- bfrog 3y ago96 cores? Wild! Can the cores even stay busy and fed with work to do at some point?
- bhouston 3y agoI can feed those cores! PixInsight for astrophotography or CPU-based 3D rendering. And remember that with "hyper-threading" it appears at 192 cores - which is just insane.
- Arnavion 3y agoThat's why they also support all those PCIe lanes.
- undersuit 3y agoAnd 8 channels of DDR5! I wonder if any WRX90 Motherboards will have memory overclocking or if that's going to be limited to the quad channel TRX50 enthusiast boards. AMD seems to allow it, but will there be a market? If the platforms are anything like the desktop topology overclocking the memory increases the L3 cache and CCX<->CCX clock speeds as well. Feed the beast.
- undersuit 3y agoLooks like there are some DDR5 ECC Registered Overclockable(or at least with XMP profiles) DIMMs released already for Intel platforms.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoWaiting for Bruce Dawson aka randomascii's sequel to "24-core CPU and I can't move my mouse", with "96-core CPU and time has been stilled", with event tracing and flame graphs that show which of those cores are slowing down something basic in Windows. It's a bit weird (but cool!) that AMD seems to expect to use this chip on ordinary workstations rather than HPC clusters. Hopefully a few of those workstations are bought by the kernel and application developers (who have reasonably parallel workloads like compiling operating systems), otherwise you're likely to have more than an order of magnitude more cores than the average person designing your operating system. Usually, the problem is the opposite - the devs are on new flagship workstation-class devices, and the users on little edge devices (sometimes still with HDDs instead of SSDs!) have a poor experience, but this is kind of the opposite.
- smolder 3y ago> the devs are on new flagship workstation-class devices, and the users on little edge devices This will continue to be true, I think. The vast majority of people buying threadripper machines at threadripper prices are those with serious work to do on them, like compiling huge codebases, hosting piles of VMs, running simulations, or doing certain creative work. I doubt anyone developing 'serious' software that their customers buy 96 core machines to run wouldn't also run similarly powerful machines. There are some tech fetishists who will buy this premium hardware and underutilize it, but not too many.
- bick_nyers 3y agoDepends on how memory bandwidth constrained you are with eight channels of DDR5. Keep in mind also that the DDR5 on these can also clock higher than EPYC parts, so the gap between Threadripper's 8 channels and EPYC's 12 channels isn't as wide as one may initially think.
- Aurornis 3y agoDepending on the workload, absolutely. The 96 core part has 480MB of cache and 8 channels of DDR5. Compare that to a 7950X (not the X3D model) which has 16 cores, but only 80MB of cache and 2 channels of DDR5. The 96-core part has 6X as many cores, but 4X as much memory bandwidth and 6X as much cache. The interfaces have scaled similarly to the core count. Of course, if your workload isn't really very parallel then you won't see much benefit. Such is life with high core counts.
- MenhirMike 3y agoAlso, enough fast PCIe lanes to have GPUs, NVMe drives, and NICs feed that pipe from the outside.
- rewmie 3y ago> Can the cores even stay busy and fed with work to do at some point? There are still some embarrassingly parallel applications out there that could benefit from this sort of hardware. I'm not sure if it's absolutely necessary to have this number of cores under each desk though. To me this sounds like a luxury/vanity/status symbol.
- saberience 3y agoI'm sort of confused on this one, is this essentially the "home version" of an Epyc? Who is the intended purchaser here? As previously if I wanted to build an AMD workstation at home I would have opted for an Epyc setup.
- beebeepka 3y agoIndeed. Who needs all these price points? Why would anyone buy anything but the most expensive product? Companies are weird.
- rbanffy 3y ago> Why would anyone buy anything but the most expensive product? If I were to build a workstation on it right now, I wouldn't buy the most expensive one. My relatively modest compute needs don't come even close to what that monster is able to do. If you are IO-bound, why spend $3000 more on a CPU if you can spend that in memory, more/faster NVMe or HDDs?
- xxs 3y ago>NVMe You'd be limited by PCIe lanes (and memory bandwidth, 8 channel DDR5) The CPUs feature 128 PCIe lanes, compared to 7950x's 28.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 3y agoIf you need more than 28 PCIe lanes, then you need the big one. In any case, 28 is still a lot of IO. It makes little sense to pay for what you won't need.
- xxs 3y agoworkstation - that would require some external GPU, so 8 or 16 lanes. 4 for chipset/USB. That leaves 8 or 16 pcie lanes for SSD, decent NVMe SSDs are 4 lanes, which means up to 4 fully enabled SSD, it's not much, esp. running RAID.
- Avlin67 3y agoeither way go WRX80 or epyc genoa. it is a half backed bergamo splitted with not all ram channels activated....
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoEpic that the Pro series go all the way down to 12 cores. Still get gobs and gobs of memory and io bandwidth, at a somewhat hopefully more down to earth price.
- craftkiller 3y agoBut still at 350W TDP. I want gobs of ECC memory and PCIe lanes without feeling like I'm driving a hummer every time I power on my desktop.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIs it? I doubt that. Also, I think the key point people really miss is that with modern cores you can just say what you want! I really really enjoyed this article where they scaled a AMD 7840HS laptop core from 51W down to 5W. There looks like perfectly acceptable single core performance even down at 10-15W. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37923741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37923741 This mirrors what Matthew Dillon of DragonflyBSD was finding 6 years ago with a 2700x. You can just drop the cores target power down from 160W to 85W and it still runs amazingly fast and the efficiency numbers go way way up. https://lists.dragonflybsd.org/pipermail/users/2018-September/357883.html https://lists.dragonflybsd.org/pipermail/users/2018-Septembe... People keep being afraid of high power cores & they just don't know any better. The situation has just gotten better and better and easier and easier to dial in an arbitrary desired power level, and you get it. At some bit to multicore performance, but efficiency usually goes way way up.
- craftkiller 3y ago> Is it? I doubt that. The 350W tdp? Its in the article. There's a table of each pro sku and their TDP.
- craftkiller 3y agoIts too late for me to edit my reply so I'm adding another: Just wanted to say that you had a good point about modern cores being configurable (for example, on my laptop I set the EPP 100% towards energy efficiency by default and then when I know I'm going to be running some serious long-running computations I'll run a script to make the EPP favor performance). I'll have to wait for these to be released to see how low their power usage can go considering they might have a high floor since I doubt these were designed for low power usage, but this has at least revived my consideration of these CPUs. That being said, there is one other thing to consider: motherboards. I have a first generation threadripper in my desktop and through a series of dumb moves with very heavy graphics cards, I have broken a number of the PCIe slots. I looked into getting a replacement motherboard since I figured they'd be cheap by now since they're so out of date, but first generation threadripper motherboards are like $700-$1000, while the people who bought AM4 socketed CPUs got multiple generations of CPU upgrades AND their motherboards now cost $100-$200. There are some undeniable advantages to being on their more popular consumer lines instead of the prosumer threadripper.
- earthscienceman 3y agoI have a few questions about computer architecture for you hardware folks. These many core architectures get so complex. I'm a lowly scientist that does some fairly heavy compute in both interpreted languages (python) and compiled languages (c/julia). Two questions: When these 'base clocks' are listed, would a lower core CPU with a higher base clock run more calculations at its max thread count than a higher core cpu? Say 64 threads on a 32 vore 4Ghz CPU vs a 2.5Ghz 96 core monster. For my use case I'm often running a serial computation on a fixed dataset that can be threaded per data point. So if I have 32 data points it's only that parallel. Something between embarrassingly parallel and completely serial. And second. For these massive caches, if I'm doing a massive serial calculation does an individual core get to use the full cache if it's being thrashed? As in, are there cache benefits to running a computation on these huge CPUs vs some overclocked 8 core beast?
- bick_nyers 3y agoAs others have mentioned, it's complicated. This site will be your best friend here: https://openbenchmarking.org/tests https://openbenchmarking.org/tests
- Iulioh 3y agoWellll....it depends ------- When these 'base clocks' are listed, would a lower core CPU with a higher base clock run more calculations at its max thread count than a higher core cpu? Say 64 threads on a 32 vore 4Ghz CPU vs a 2.5Ghz 96 core monster ----- You know that GPUs are just CPUs with a massive core count, right? Like in the 1000s of cores So depends on what calculations you need done, there is no answer. It depends on how the program uses the cores, not even only what calculations you need done
- effie 3y agoGPU cores are not CPUs, otherwise we could run Linux and a shell on them. GPU core is much simpler than a CPU, that's why there can be so many of them on the die.
- jfindley 3y ago
- satvikpendem 3y agoFinally, I've been waiting for a non-Pro Threadripper since the 3000 days. The 64 core 7980X looks like a good deal, a bit higher than the 3990x but still not bad. Gotta see the compile and gaming benchmarks though first. I heard rumors though that the mainline Ryzen will get 32 cores perhaps next year, so we'll have to see how that does.
- bick_nyers 3y agoI would be very surprised if Ryzen goes for 32 cores, 24 is more probable. If they do go for that many cores, it will likely be "Zen 5C" cores, which may or may not be competitive with Threadripper being full Zen 4 cores. Regardless, it's the memory channels and extra PCIE lanes that makes Threadripper shine, oh, and now HEDT gets Registered ECC which is fantastic.
- satvikpendem 3y agoLooks like you're right, likely C cores based on what I've seen as well.
- kllrnohj 3y ago> I would be very surprised if Ryzen goes for 32 cores, 24 is more probable. The rumor is that the CCX is going from 8 to 16 cores, at which point a 24 core ryzen would necessarily be 2 partially-enabled CCXs. That wouldn't make much sense as their high end configuration which so far has always been 2 fully enabled compute chiplets. So if that 16 core CCX change is true then 32 full fat cores for the top end Ryzen is the most likely scenario. There wouldn't really be any reason for AMD to just refuse to put 2 fully enabled dies together, especially since as you noted Threadripper & Epyc already offer more benefits that Ryzen just won't get.
- ksec 3y ago>The 64 core 7980X looks like a good deal, Yes and it is Zen 4 Core, so a lot faster than the 3000 days. My only concern is the Quad Memory Channel. Not sure if the 64 Core will be limited by it. But this is exciting for Desktop Computing.
- dotnet00 3y agoI wish they'd go back to the way they did the original Threadrippers. These absurd prices kinda make them pointless for a large number of people when combined with how AMD has bungled the socket support with Threadripper and how expensive the motherboards are. The lower prices and overlap with the top range of regular Ryzens made threadripper very appealing for applications where you want lots of IO and RAM, but not necessarily a more capable CPU.
- bick_nyers 3y ago7950X3D is $43.75 per core. The 24 core Threadripper part is $62.50 per core. It's certainly a higher price, but imo it's not outrageous for more memory channels, registered ECC, and more PCIE lanes. The motherboards on the other hand...
- dotnet00 3y agoI don't necessarily agree on looking at pricing that way. One reason being that the 24 core part is 8 ccds with 3 cores each, while the 7950x is 2 ccds with 8 cores each, so the threadripper is able to go with much lower quality chips which would have otherwise gone in the bin.
- andrewprock 3y agoWhat do you think the appropriate way of looking at pricing is? Once you get beyond 8 cores, your ability to saturate the CPU comes down to very specific parallelized workflows that can benefit close to linearly from extra cores. If you have that kind of workflow (render farms, encoding, etc) then the marginal cost of a CPU feels relevant. I'm sure there are other workflows, especially in the cloud where you are rending out fractions of a CPU. But for individual professionals, what else besides marginal core cost would you consider?
- bick_nyers 3y agoDon't you incur the cross-CCD latency every time you hit the 3D L3 cache anyways? Still, that's good info., I must have missed that part where they are doing their CCD layout like that.
- tmaly 3y agoTDP of 350W for all of them?
- clircle 3y agoThat’s only 6x more than my 5600x
- tpmx 3y agoYes, that's a bit odd. The 96 core 7995WX: 3.6W/core The 12 core 7945WX: 29.2W/core
- Symmetry 3y agoThe relationship between frequency and power consumption is very far from linear. The 29W core is running at twice the frequency of the 3.6W core.
- tpmx 3y agoGood catch. I hadn't seen such extreme differences before within the same product series. Base frequency: 7995WX: 2.5 GHz 7945WX: 4.7 GHz
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anticensor 3y agoYou should deduct ~60W baseline I/O die power consumption (~40W for 12 and 16 core Threadrippers), which gives: 96-core: 2.5W/core + 60W I/O-die 12-core: 21.7W/core + 40W I/O-die Lower TDP settings are still available. With PBO, you might be able to extract more juice out of stock power levels.
- heelix 3y agoThat was probably the most welcome bit of news. I've got a water loop on my older threadrippers that can handle that ballpark. After the 5xxx became unobtainium for us who build their own system, I've got a 7950x that won't even turn on the fans that is waiting for something newer than what I got on the workstation front.
- mastax 3y agoAccording to the Anandtech coverage[0], both WRX90 and TRX50 have some sort of off-cpu chipset, unlike the EPYC platform. However there's basically no information about what's on the chipset. I suppose it must not be very exciting, then. Just a bunch of USB controllers, probably. It may even be the same die as the desktop Ryzen chipset. [0]: https://www.anandtech.com/show/21092/amd-unveils-ryzen-threadripper-7000-family-zen-4-for-workstations-and-hedt https://www.anandtech.com/show/21092/amd-unveils-ryzen-threa...
- Racing0461 3y agoIs it like the old threadripper cpu where it can take ecc ram but doesn’t actually do the error correcting?
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYou'll have to wait for the reviews to confirm, but I believe it's highly unlikely that the ECC will be non-functional. These require RDIMM's, and it's hard to even buy RDIMM's without ECC. So if everybody who is testing it has ECC in their test machine, many of them will explicitly test ECC and it will be noticed. Also, ECC works fine on the EPYC chips these are variants of.
- p_l 3y agoAMD always included the logic for ECC, sometimes the issue was with motherboards lacking the traces or simply not initializing the controller for ECC.
- idkyall 3y agoVery excited for access to more RAM in a consumer form factor - by comparison, the most RAM you can get on a DDR5 motherboard is 128GB(actually, there may be 48 GB modules as well, so maybe 192), but at that capacity you're not getting anywhere near the rated speeds. The listed 1TB of capacity sounds super roomy by comparison
- jadbox 3y agoWhat are ye using all that ram for? -curious stranger
- itsboring 3y agoIsn’t it obvious? More browser tabs.
- taskforcegemini 3y agoIt can't be for tabs in chrome, that browser can't even use all 64gb I offer it ("putting tabs to sleep" is disabled on purpose as I need the tabs to stay active)
- nottorp 3y agoYou just don't have enough tabs open.
- taskforcegemini 3y agoI do, but they crash for memory insufficiency reasons while half of the RAM is still free. it's a bug, other people have commented on the issue with no solution so far. some suspect hardware acceleration to be a culprit, but I ruled that out. what I meant to convey in the first place: it doesn't matter how much hardware you throw at an issue if the software can't use it
- ghthor 3y agoSwitching to Firefox and using tree style tabs will help increase your total open tab count.
- pella 3y agoNo CXL :-( "AMD also disabled CXL connectivity, as it doesn’t feel there is a need for that capability with workstation/HEDT platforms." https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-announces-threadripper-hedt-and-pro-7000-wx-series-processors-96-cores-and-192-threads-for-desktops-and-workstations https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-announces-threadripper...
- p_l 3y agomeanwhile CXL with compatible GPUs would greatly help for working with GPU compute...
- wmf 3y agoIs CXL even real? I haven't seen a single CXL card for sale.
- pella 3y ago1.) (10.17.2023) https://www.eetimes.com/cxl-gets-off-the-drawing-board/ https://www.eetimes.com/cxl-gets-off-the-drawing-board/ "However, CXL has suffered from a “chicken and egg” problem, according to Srinivas. Last year, there was a great deal of interest from hyperscalers and integrators, but there were no CXL devices ready.. Now that products are sampling, he said, they can work on applications and see benefits. “Now we are seeing practical implementation and how CXL technology can really help provide that additional memory capacity and bandwidth.” ... "CXL 2.0 platforms likely for 2024" 2.) ( 23 hours ago ) "Even a laptop can run RAM externally thanks to a little-known tech called CXL — but it’s not for sale to mere mortals who only want 1TB of RAM" https://www.techradar.com/pro/even-a-laptop-can-run-ram-externally-thanks-to-a-little-known-tech-called-cxl-but-its-not-for-sale-to-mere-mortals-who-only-want-1tb-of-ram https://www.techradar.com/pro/even-a-laptop-can-run-ram-exte...
- wmf 3y ago1. Didn't the cards sample years ago? 2. Fake news. No laptops support CXL.
- Bluescreenbuddy 3y agoI thought they killed off non-pro TR? Guess they changed their mind
- iopq 3y agoBecause at the time of release of 5000 series, they couldn't get all this silicon to make SKUs at every price point, so they tried to sell at the highest price point. Now that they are not selling much of anything, they will try to get their profits at the HEDT market
- tiffanyh 3y agoServer chips These chips are great. You get a lot of cores, without having to compromise on frequency (you get high frequency as well). I wish cloud / dedicated server providers sold these chips. Because most workloads need higher frequency than more cores. And you get the best of both with these.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey pretty much have this, e.g. EPYC 9274F has a 4.05GHz base clock. Threadripper with the same number of cores is 4.2GHz, which is less than 4% faster (for a >9% higher TDP). Threadripper has a significantly higher boost clock, but that only counts when you're not using all the threads, so you only care about this in a workstation running mixed workloads. In a data center you don't use a high core count processor for a single-thread performance-sensitive workload, you put it on something with fewer cores like a Ryzen 7700X because it has a higher boost clock than any Threadripper while costing less and using less power.
- tiffanyh 3y agoAre threadripper just the rejected high frequency “F” Epyc chips?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe CCDs might be the same but several of the Threadripper models have to be "perfect", e.g. the 7975WX has 32 cores from 4 CCDs: https://www.anandtech.com/show/21092/amd-unveils-ryzen-threadripper-7000-family-zen-4-for-workstations-and-hedt https://www.anandtech.com/show/21092/amd-unveils-ryzen-threa... EPYC 9334 has the same config, but it's clocked lower and has a correspondingly lower TDP. Whereas the 7965WX has 24 cores from 4 CCDs, so the 7965WX is presumably made of CCDs where 2 of the 8 cores were defective, i.e. it's a 7975WX made of "defective" CCDs. But so is the EPYC 9254. Or they could have used the same four "defective" CCDs to make a pair of the 12-core Ryzen 9 7900, or four of the Ryzen 5 7600. The EPYC "F" processors are apparently made entirely of "defective" CCDs, presumably because it gives them more L3 cache per core and helps with heat dissipation by spreading the heat load across more CCDs for the same number of cores.
- _chu1 3y agoLooking forward to AMD releasing some more budget oriented options for AM5, currently it's a very expensive platform. I really wanna see how these take on Intel, and if they steamroll them the way they did when they Threadrippers first came out.
- CobaltFire 3y agoSomething to note about the Threadripper Pro CPUs in the previous generations that may apply here: The 12 and 16 core variants only had the ability to saturate the IO die with enough data to fully utilize 4 channels of RAM due to fewer CCDs being populated. I would bet that will be the case here as well. So those bottom CPUs will be just the budget IO monsters, and be no better than the non-Pro (for RAM bandwidth) even in the Pro boards. The one caveat is that they probably won’t have the speed penalty with 8 RDIMMs that the others probably will.
- 0dayz 3y agoGenuinely curious, what is the point today of high end cpus if even traditional cpu intensive has moved over to at least partial utilizing the gpu?
- LTL_FTC 3y agoThere are still processes that benefit greatly from cpu advances. Something like compiling code, for instance. But even if this were the case, high end cpus like these can now be used with several gpus where a lesser cpu might be able to only feed n-1 gpus. Density is pretty important in data centers and elsewhere. Think ML researcher with 4 big gpus in their desktop
- 0dayz 3y agoThat's fair enough, but for more traditional work environments like blender or Adobe suite gpus will be a bigger factor or?
- icegreentea2 3y agoThere are lots of random bits which are still CPU bound. https://www.pugetsystems.com/solutions/ https://www.pugetsystems.com/solutions/ - can you click through to workflows to specific programs and then look up Hardware Recommendations to get a run down. While Blender itself is a mostly GPU bound situation, a lot of other media creation software is more mixed. * Photoshop: mostly still limited to 8 cores (some filters being GPU enabled) * Premiere: GPU used only to handle specific effects (so it depends on your mix of effects) * AfterEffects: mostly CPU bound
- avipars 3y agoI hope they can keep the same motherboard/platform for at least another generation.