5 ms·
There's probably a performance component as well. If you're high performing, can pick whatever job they want, and therefore get paid well above your peers, why
by gruez 3y ago
There's probably a performance component as well. If you're high performing, can pick whatever job they want, and therefore get paid well above your peers, why would want to join a union?
- watwut 3y agoI have to say, this claim goes against what I have seen in real life. As in, people active in unions or other activism are not lesser performers.
- paulcole 3y agoBecause one day you won’t be high performing and you’d like to have some protection for your job? Among many other reasons…
- filoleg 3y agoIs this a direct admission that unions are for protecting low-performers? Because if yes, that’s not a good look for them at all and is kind of a perfect ammo for the anti-union side.
- slikrick 3y agoit's directly saying that unions protect against anti-worker bullshit corporate speak. which you seem to eat up and want to spit right back at people
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoNo. Unions are for protecting employees against abusive employers. Your highest performing state is temporary. There will be times where you’ll have off days. You will deal with death in the family. You will be eventually injured. If you aren’t already disabled, you will eventually be (this is just old age). You may become a parent. You might immigrate and come under restrictive visa. You’re a human being with fluctuating states, same as everyone else, and an abusive employer shouldn’t get to power trip over you just because they don’t think it’s legitimate enough for them or something. So yes, there’s a lot of reasons why a “high performer” might want to be in a union. There’s a lot of life shit we all go through. Edited to add: this is not the mention your employer might just pull some crap like nepotizing a promotion over you, where a union would come in handy handy!
- gruez 3y agoIs it "abusive" for employers to fire/not pay you if you're away for weeks, or underperforming for months? The terms of the exchange is your time for money. The company isn't a charity. Even if you think there should be a social safety net for these types of circumstances, it makes little sense for employers to provide it. For one, it has the usual problems of tying important services to employment, similar to how healthcare is in the US. It also puts an undue burden on small businesses. You run a 10 person startup and one of your employees got a long term disability? Congratulations, you have to now find a replacement AND continue paying them. Large companies have law of large numbers on their side, but as an unlucky small business that's 10% of your payroll. >Edited to add: this is not the mention your employer might just pull some crap like nepotizing a promotion over you, where a union would come in handy handy! 1. has there been a good track record of unions being able to successfully prevent cases like these? 2. Given the level of corruption associated with unions, at least in the US, you're just replacing one problem with another.
- josefx 3y ago> The terms of the exchange is your time for money. So the contract only covers time? Not actual work, but only time? Do I get to spend the time how I want as long as there is a paper trail that it was your time I just wasted? > The company isn't a charity. Yet both are legal and social constructs and not something you can make up on the fly to fit your personal preferences. > it makes little sense for employers to provide it. I have been worked to exhaustion for one employer. You don't get to reap the profits and socialize the costs, that only incentivizes more abuse. > You run a 10 person startup and one of your employees got a long term disability? So if that person was you would you fire yourself and move onto the street in front of your former business?
- jacobr1 3y agoThis is why we need to both good private (insurance) and public (social benefit) safety net programs in place. In the case of a small startup, long term disability insurance should cover the living costs of that disability. Yes, that person should be let go, even a founder, if they are unable to perform their duties. But they shouldn't be kicked the street, and the company also shouldn't be on the hook for their care. Either through premiums or taxes, this situation should be accounted for ahead of time. Employment shouldn't be a lifetime obligation of a company.
- paulcole 3y agoUnions are a protection for both high performers and low performers. I don't think they should offer protection for non-performers – outside of situations where a life event has mad a performer a non-performer for some reasonable amount of time.
- chefandy 3y agoAdmission? Like the commenter is some kind of representative? And while unions aren't homogenous, they generally don't protect incompetence. I've known people in unions that got fired for poor performance, generally. But if I was a cook and cut off a finger while making some company profitable, my performance would certainly suffer while it was healing, and lots of companies world very much rather stop paying me. So in that case yes, I very much hope that a union would protect people from that performance-related loss of employment.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> And while unions aren't homogenous, they generally don't protect incompetence They tend to insist on due process for adverse actions, and management tend to hold out the idea that being able to dismiss arbitrarily without evidence or process is essential to efficiently dealing with incompetence.
- chefandy 3y agoYour assertion tends to rely on your anecdata which tends to not be any more useful than anybody else's. I've known a huge number of people in various unions and this simply does not reflect any reality I've experienced in 25 years of work experience.
- gosub100 3y agoI've known people who managed union employees. While being walked out (fired) for bad performance, they learned the magic words "I have a drug problem". Automatically reverses firing, employee goes to some (company paid rehab) for 1-3 months, gets their job back. They just use this as an option to keep their job, they dont even care. Every "compassionate" benefit you offer will be equally exploited by losers. It seems to me a zero-sum game.
- chefandy 3y agoThe exceptional number of people I've known in Unions for decades are mostly career professionals with good professional ethics. Your anecdata vs mine. I hear garbage like that from anti-union people but have never seen that in reality. Is it a union for bank robbers?
- gruez 3y agoRegardless of whether as a high performer, joining a union is actually better for you in the long term, the fact that there's a plausible case against it makes it more likely that pro union employees will be disproportionately affected. Not everyone is 100% bought into unions so I'd expect these factors to play a significant role
- sickcodebruh 3y agoThis was so much more than a job to many of them, just like Bandcamp is more than an e-commerce platform. Bandcamp employed a lot of people who had been there for 5+ years and contributed heavily to its role as cornerstone and defender of independent music. To them, it was as much an extension of their identities as it was a job, and they saw protecting Bandcamp as being equal to protecting independent music. The union came about after they were sold to Epic in an effort to protect not only themselves but also the company and everything it did and represented. Clearly, they were right to be distrustful.
- ludston 3y agoNot every talented person is motivated by greed for personal wealth and status. Actually most aren't.
- gruez 3y ago>Not every talented person is motivated by greed for personal wealth and status. What I said doesn't require everyone to be "motivated by greed for personal wealth and status". The effect will still be present even if only a fraction of people behave that way. >Actually most aren't. Source?
- skeeter2020 3y agoForget about money - do you know a lot of talented people who are happy working with people who don't share the same motivations?
- ludston 3y agoOf course? The most famously talented people their lives teaching, mentoring and otherwise trying to lift up those around them. Could any person be an effective leader if they didn't enjoy the challenge of working with people with different values and motivations to themselves? I've certainly never seen one.
- banannaise 3y agoBecause unions protect everyone in ways that don't directly relate to pay scale. They help defend against abusive time-off, on-call, or surveillance practices, advocate for pro-worker policies like parental, bereavement, and sick leave, help prevent employees from being fired for using these benefits...
- MrPatan 3y agoThe scarcity of your skillset will protect you. Nothing else can.
- beedeebeedee 3y agoThat's a bleak perspective that is not borne out by the facts. The greatest source of protection for any individual is the group.
- noelherrick 3y agoWhy do some of the most highly-paid people (actors) join a union and join the picket line? Even if you are high performing, joining up with other workers increases your bargaining position. Why did Steve Jobs join up with Adobe to stop poaching when they were highly sought after work places? Because even if you're a behemoth, you can be stronger in a union.
- gruez 3y ago>Why do some of the most highly-paid people (actors) join a union and join the picket line? Even if you are high performing, joining up with other workers increases your bargaining position. Perhaps, but there's also a real chance that the union structure you end up with ends up being net negative for top earners. If you're in the top 10%, what makes you think the bottom 90% won't vote for policies that end up redistributing your wages to them? Also as I said in my other comment[1], whether this is actually true is irrelevant. All that matters is that it sounds plausible and some fraction of people believe it. Perception is reality in this case. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37942073 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37942073
- ImPostingOnHN 3y ago> If you're in the top 10%, what makes you think the bottom 90% won't vote for policies that end up redistributing your wages to them? We already have the bottom 10% (executives) doing that. We would need evidence to be convinced that your scenario would plausibly happen if workers had more power and executives less.
- skeeter2020 3y agoWeird that you conflate a union with an oligopoly; historically they've been the polar opposite answer to each other.
- milesvp 3y agoI will share an anecdote. A friend of mine, his dad owned a construction company. I was talking to him at a party and made a comment that was fairly anti union thinking he’d agree with the sentiment. His response was he loved unions because they gave him access to the best workers. He had 2 unions represented in his company, and his experience was that union workers were objectively better than non union workers. This surprised me because I couldn’t fathom a world where a capitalist would prefer to have unions in his company. As to why a talented free agent would want to join a union. It seems to me that in an industry with strong union presence then union is obvious to join. It provides so many protections and adds leverage to intangibles that even high earning individuals can’t negotiate for.
- JohnFen 3y agoBecause union representation isn't just about pay?
- gruez 3y agoThose ultimately convert to pay. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compensating_differential#Employment_Benefits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compensating_differential#Empl...
- JohnFen 3y agoSome of the most important things unions negotiate for aren't about pay and benefits. They negotiate things like working conditions, handle disputes, and the like. Those things are usually much more important than pay and benefits, and when union negotiations stall, it's more usually about that sort of thing than about money. I hate to bring up the old example, but it's used because it nicely illustrates the value of unions for everybody -- not just the union members. Things like having a 40 hour workweek and weekends only happened because of unions.
- dumpsterlid 3y ago[dead]