4 ms·
Meh, this does the rounds every so often, but the fact remains that auto* work a lot better than everything that's supposed to replace them, especially if your
by lmm 3y ago
Meh, this does the rounds every so often, but the fact remains that auto* work a lot better than everything that's supposed to replace them, especially if your system is even slightly obscure. Want to build a unix program under SUA? If it uses autoconf, you're fine, just push the button and it works; at worst if the release is older than your OS then you may have to replace two files, a standard and well-known procedure. Want to build varnish under SUA? Lol, good luck.
The problem of duplicated dependencies in linux comes from doing too little splitting of packages, not too much. You get a lot less of this on a platform like nodejs where people properly split up functions into much smaller libraries, because the dependency management is much more effective. (Of course people on HN moan more when you do that, for no discernible reason, as if having 1000 dependencies is somehow morally inferior to having 10).
Ultimately a certain amount of duplication is necessary and healthy. There is a nugget of real criticism to be found here - the "Bazaar" nature of open-source OSes makes it very difficult to deprecate and remove anything, where a more centrally-managed system is able to make decisions like "we'll stop using or supporting Perl from 2020" and enforce them. But "herp derp 122 packages herp derp 22 tests" is not what we should be focusing on.
- oblio 3y agoSUA?
- oblio 3y ago> Of course people on HN moan more when you do that, for no discernible reason, as if having 1000 dependencies is somehow morally inferior to having 10 It's not morally wrong, it's wrong for auditing and general change management. Too many suppliers of small dependencies you have to check. This is important for larger companies or for mission critical software in sensitive domains.
- cpach 3y agoAs someone who is an outsider to Node/Javascript, I’m not convinced that NPM has found the sweet spot of package granularity…