4 ms·
Full federation would be nice, but just using alternative, smaller platforms makes a huge difference in reducing YouTube's stranglehold. About half the people I
by lolinder 3y ago
Full federation would be nice, but just using alternative, smaller platforms makes a huge difference in reducing YouTube's stranglehold. About half the people I follow are on Nebula, which is a surprisingly solid platform that provides a lot of good redundancy for educational YouTubers.
As an added bonus, creators remove sponsorships from Nebula videos, so unlike YouTube Premium it really is completely ad free.
- grepfru_it 3y ago>but just using alternative, smaller platforms makes a huge difference this does not scale. bandwidth costs will crush small platforms and they will eventually be absorbed into bigger ones.. the only exit is closure (especially from a rouge patent troll or DMCA lawsuit) or buyout. see justin.tv as an example edit: all costs will crush you. you need a mod team to prevent runaway piracy and child porn. you need a security team to prevent attacks. you need a network team to try to minimize bandwidth loss. video delivery is not a cheap game, so i'm not really sure how free platforms will survive
- lolinder 3y agoDoes everything need to scale? I personally quite enjoyed the web back in the day where most communities were running on tiny boxes managed by a single hobbyist. > you need a mod team to prevent runaway piracy and child porn. Nebula doesn't because it's an invite-only platform. The creators are all part of an old-school social network and can vouch for each other. > video delivery is not a cheap game, so i'm not really sure how free platforms will survive So don't be a free platform! Nebula is doing just fine at serving me and many like me. Most of the creators I follow make a solid living on Patreon, with Nebula and YouTube ads just layered on top. The idea that every app must be free and must scale to ~every human being on the planet is killing the internet.
- ardfard 3y ago> Does everything need to scale? I personally quite enjoyed the web back in the day where most communities were running on tiny boxes managed by a single hobbyist. It's just not only matter of scale. I follow content creator that posted some of his content on his personal website. but man, the user experience is night and day compared to youtube. loading video is slow, cant fast-forward before hit buffering, also no content discovery either. Paying for Youtube premium is no-brainer because i just get more value of it compared to even Netflix.
- lolinder 3y agoScale isn't a binary switch—Nebula's UX is very comparable to YouTube's, better in some ways. There's a space in the middle—between one guy's personal site and Google—where the platform has enough resources to get a decent experience.
- judge2020 3y agoEveryone who is actually mad about the ad blocking is either a teenager (with no money) or won't pay for YT Premium anyways, regardless of how much value they get out of it. Why would these people pay for a Nebula/Curiosity Stream subscription?
- lolinder 3y agoHi! I block YouTube ads and will stop watching YouTube if they disable ad blockers, but I am currently paying for Nebula. AMA.
- judge2020 3y agoWhy watch YouTube with an ad blocker if you understand that those who make videos, and the one that hosts the video, require payment in exchange for access to the content?
- distract8901 3y agoFor any number of reasons, I'm not willing to put up with Google's advertising or business practices. I also don't want to give google any money because a) they really don't need it and b) google only gives a fraction of the ad revinue to creators. Why use YouTube then? There really isn't much of an option. Some creators I subscribe to don't post anywhere else. Some do post on peertube or LBRY, so I'll watch there if available. I view it the same way I view piracy. I'd be willing to pay for more media if it were available, from a company that won't spy on me, without DRM, and my money went to the people that made the thing instead of some rent seeking business sitting between me and them. I don't have a problem paying for stuff, I have a problem with paying Google specifically. And ultimately my use of ad blockers accounts for an infinitesimal fraction of a percent of any one creator's ad revinue. It costs Google a lot of money to serve the video, and the creator earns only very slightly less. If there's a sponsored segment (as there always is these days), that more than makes up for the disparity. It hurts Google and is virtually unnoticeable to the creator. Sounds good to me.
- 3y ago