2 ms·
I like to ask a different question. Imagine an arbitrarily advanced alien civilization. How close to earth must they get before they can detect life. Of cour
by bluGill 3y ago
I like to ask a different question. Imagine an arbitrarily advanced alien civilization. How close to earth must they get before they can detect life. Of course we know a few hundred million light years are needed before there was life at all on earth, but could you detect it? Does intelligent life help or not (the first radio transmission was in the 1880s, so 140 light years - but could you detect those transmissions that far out)?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kjkjadksj 3y agoI would think that a truly advanced civilization wouldn’t even need to leave their system to find life in the universe. They could just develop a model of how life should emerge and use imagery to identify targets that are most likely to have life. Maybe this model is occasionally validated with a remote operated or autonomous probe.
- bluGill 3y agoThe speed of light is too slow: remotely operated probes are not possible. Autonomous probes are, but good luck building something that survived for the millions of years needed to get anywhere interesting, and good luck having your civilization still existing - by the time the signal returns.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIf these organisms live for orders of magnitude longer than humans, maybe this isn’t so large of an issue as it is to us with our own frame of reference.
- giantrobot 3y agoDetecting life on Earth could be done with a telescope able to take spectra of Earth from the aliens' home system. They could look at Earth compared to the Sun and other planets in the system and see Earth has a bunch of biosignatures that would be broken down by the Sun's UV radiation if not constantly regenerated. One or two markers would be inconclusive but a bunch of different ones would give a high probability of life existing here. It's why the "Dark Forest" concept is fundamentally silly. There's no hiding Earth's biosignatures. If the arbitrarily advanced aliens have a long enough measurement baseline and are within 150 or so light years they could also see the technosignatures of the Industrial Revolution with different air pollutants. If they're within about 60-70 light years they'd start seeing evidence of radioactive isotopes from above ground nuclear testing.
- bluGill 3y agoThe nearest star is ~4 light years, and it is of a type that we think unlikely to have life. Even at 150 light years there isn't a whole lot out there, though I guess it is no longer in the impossible realm, it also isn't really enough stars to think of the Fermi paradox applying yet.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoWe send humans to live in orbit where there wouldn’t normally be conditions fit for life thanks to our technology. I don’t think habitability precludes life from being there, especially if it emerged elsewhere and this is more of an outpost or research station akin to the ISS or antarctic stations of our own. Perhaps there are interesting things there in uninhabited systems, or they make a ripe environment for certain experiments or work that is unfit to perform so close to a habitable system.