6 ms·
The most insane "robocall mitigation plans" that telcos filed with the FCC
- jruohonen 3y ago"FCC received blank pages, a Windows Printer Test, and an 'indiscernible object'." I reckon spammers were not pleased.
- lathiat 3y agoHere in Australia I noticed the iOS “report spam” button on an SMS now says it sends a copy to my carrier (Telstra). They really need the same button for phone calls. Then they could react in realtime to investigate.
- eli 3y agoI think most providers have a shortcode you can "forward" spam texts too. Based on my experience with T-Mobile the reports just go in a circular file. The same number could keep sending the same message and it isn't blocked by the carrier.
- superq 3y ago(circular file = trash can, for those not familiar with the idiom.)
- cryptonector 3y agoI've news for you. They're never going to investigate, let alone in real time.
- jjoonathan 3y ago> It isn't clear why it took the FCC roughly 20 months to move from the initial warnings to cutting the companies off I'd like to know too. I am sure that spammers will try every delay tactic in the book, and while I am glad to hear that a deadline is approaching I am not pleased to learn that they were able to buy 20 months of time over the last deadline with a low-effort windows print test page. At this rate, actual lawyer tactics will buy them 20 years of delays for them and spam for us.
- Maken 3y agoI'm not sure they are even trying to buy time. Some of those appear like the people in charge did not even understand what they were being asked for.
- jjoonathan 3y agoPlaying Dumb is the easiest and oldest strategy in the book. Most kids figure it out before they learn to speak. I am sure that a few of them are genuinely clueless, but at some point we have to cut them off to get their attention and I don't see how 20 months will help over 2, not when the ask is "make a plan."
- elil17 3y agoFrom the article: "Finally, he noted that the FCC might have been hesitant to take an action that could harm customers. "One reason to be hesitant is that it's not just the bad actor network that gets cut off," Feld said. "Any innocent customers get cut off. This really goes against the entire mindset of the FCC. Generally, the FCC is about making sure that networks stay operational and that calls go through."
- jjoonathan 3y agoA network drowning in spam is not operational. Drawing out the timeline doesn't help.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> network drowning in spam is not operational The present telco network is very much operational. We don’t need an extremist response to spam from the FCC that causes making a phone call to acquire ‘aml attributes.
- rblatz 3y agoIt’s to the point people don’t answer their phones due to the massive amount of spam calls. The network is losing relevance due to the lack of regulation.
- plagiarist 3y agoI can fix this overnight: make a five-digit number anyone can text that grants them a small one-time payment from the last caller, with the telco covering any payments they cannot collect.
- coldpie 3y agoMe too: make receiving international-sourced calls opt-in. Done.
- the8472 3y agohave another one: replace short phone numbers with ipv6 addresses. prefix owned by telco, customers can generate random suffixes. hand out random numbers every time you need to provide a number and delete them if you no longer need to receive calls from the other end. The contact you gave to the shipping company for your new washing machine? doesn't need to exist longer than a few weeks. The numbers can be passed around as QR codes or generated by an app to be pasted into forms.
- JohnFen 3y agoWouldn't making phone numbers so long be a problem? It would be a problem for me.
- the8472 3y agoDepends on your processes. Digital ones should handle them fine. In person you could use those good old business cards (each card now with its own number!). Over a phone call... well, the other side should already have that number on the phone and can save it.
- JohnFen 3y agoI was thinking in terms of remembering and manually dialing them. Perhaps I'm the only person left who still does that, though.
- 3y ago
- tivert 3y ago> Humbolt VoIP: "The robocall mitigation plan attached to its certification was a .PNG file depicting an indiscernible object." I'm pretty sure that's a photo of the lid of someone's chest freezer.
- marcus0x62 3y agoOr a piece of leather. I have a leather chair that looks practically identical to the photo.
- paulgb 3y agoSome of these sound like they may have received correspondence and scraped an attachment from the message, but the attachment was actually just from the email signature of the correspondent and was not intended to be their submission: > contained only the company's business address > a signature page on company letterhead with no substantive content or context > a .PNG file that depicted a corporate icon > contained only a signature
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoRobocalls would be easy enough to fix, and could be fixed by Apple and Google in cooperation. They could release, with every phone, tightly integrated software that allowed me to spawn off my own robot answerer. I might have to spend 20 minutes setting it up (or maybe not, with the latest in AI voice imitation), so that it could reasonably pretend to be me and keep the caller on the phone as long as possible. If every single iPhone user, for instance, wasted 10-30 minutes of time for robocallers, stringing them along, the economics of the robocalling fall apart. If Android also does the same thing, then even more so. That "industry" would self-destruct within months. Whether the carriers would allow this though, when they stand to lose so much business, that's another story.
- pxeboot 3y agoIt's not exactly what you described, but Pixel phones have something similar and it has stopped almost all spam calls for me [1]. [1] https://support.google.com/phoneapp/answer/9118387?hl=en https://support.google.com/phoneapp/answer/9118387?hl=en
- HumblyTossed 3y agoHow about just not allowing phone numbers to be spoofed in the first place? That would mitigate nearly ALL robocalls.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoThis has been a problem far longer than cell phones or spoofed numbers. I don't want to have to individually block every one of the 8000 numbers some scam telemarketer paid to have allocated. I don't think your plan mitigates any robocalls, it just forces them to (slightly) change tactics.
- at_a_remove 3y ago/me leans up against Chesterson's Fence. I reckon it would be beneficial to discover why such a thing was allowed in the first place, and for what it is commonly used aside from robocalls.
- tlogan 3y agoTechnical question: is there a way to detect on iPhone with AT&T that incoming call or sms is from phone number that is verified - in other words comply with STIR/SHAKEN protocol. Is there a way to do that?
- JohnFen 3y agoIf there is, I have no idea what it would be. I have not noticed any difference with anything since STIR/SHAKEN became a thing. I suspect that it's just not implemented in my area yet.
- zht 3y agoThere’s should be a check mark beside the caller ID name
- tlogan 3y agoHmm I do not see them (at least on IPhone). I’m still getting so many obviously spoofed calls. I guess all these protocols or FCC rules are worth shit because they do not care. Sure they will block canabis delivery notifications I get every two month but not scam call which get like 40 per month.
- karaterobot 3y agoWhy is the FCC not just telling these companies what their robocall mitigation procedures should be, and how they are going to be measured and enforced? I understand that it would be more nimble to let well-meaning companies come up with scrappy solutions. Based on the lengthy timeline, I don't believe nimbleness is what they're going for, and based on these obviously bogus submissions, I'm not convinced the companies are well-meaning. Given this, maybe a firmer hand would be more effective.
- abduhl 3y agoPermitting companies to come up with their own plan means that they can be hit later if the plan is insufficient. A company that implements a government solution exactly has no liability - they’ve complied with the law. A company whose policy is deficient (because it didn’t meet the law’s mandate) or who didn’t follow their own policy may have liability.
- jfim 3y agoThey already have asked them to implement STIR/SHAKEN, but you're right that those submissions are clearly bogus.
- clubm8 3y ago[flagged]
- JohnMakin 3y agoWatch out, we got a badass over here
- kstrauser 3y agoFirst off, have a cold drink and take a few deep breaths. Second, my phone speaker only gets so loud. You could hold your phone up to a train whistle, but I’m still going to hear a tinny toot on this end. That’s like sending someone a photo of the sun to blind them.
- h2odragon 3y agoBest robocall mitigation: give up your phone. Did you know that people lived before phones? It's still possible!
- shuntress 3y agoThe phone is extremely useful for many important things. I would much rather live in a world where where _real_ messages dominate our channels of communication. A world where I can contact people "out of the blue" without suspicion of scam or fraud.
- bovermyer 3y agoThat's like saying that the best way to ensure a computer is not accessed by bad actors is to drop Tsar Bomba on it. Yes, it achieves the desired outcome, but it has rather adverse side effects.
- tehitype 3y agoI've recieved a lot of forex related telemarketing calls the past two years (not robo, but imagine it will also hit EU eventually) because I was silly enough to input my actual number at some platform 5+ years back. I've tried several approaches reasoning with those individuals, mostly using the logic that I will NEVER buy anything from them because im simply not interested in the topic, but also a few using foul language. Always same result: more bullshit politely accompanied by "sir". More recently I've recieved a lot of calls from regular people "calling me back". I reached out to my provider a few times, especially about the spoofing, but they claim theres nothing they can do, which I highly doubt. I was a bit inspired by Cory Doctorow's "Red team blues" wherein the protagonist carries a burner, but has her main number behind an Asterisk server forwarding allowlisted numbers to the active burner. Anyone know of anything like this? Ideally very DIY and FLOSS? I imagine you could do some cool stuff with Whisper and LLMs, either wasting their time (like lennytroll mentioned elsewhere), but even better some autonomous bastion asking the caller to explain their reason for calling and letting the owner validate the answer through speech-to-text in an app, then decide wether to let it through or to "let me tell you in great detail about my grandchilds vacation to Mauritius"-land. It's a weird opposite world we live in where companies hide behind endless teleprompts, but citizens have no such shield
- ironlake 3y agoI have started answering the phone with, "Thanks for calling the Labor Organizing Hotline, how can we help you unionize your workplace today?" The hope is that it results in some self-reflection for the caller, though it hasn't reduced the number of calls.
- tehitype 3y agoI had a very long chat with one of the telemarketers once, trying my best to be very empathic and appealing to her humananity. I eventually hung up feeling defeated since she did an amazing job always defaulting to her agenda, and not giving in to my hippy svada in a very polite manner. I'd be curious to hear how your approach works out. Ultimate best scenario would be to get completely removed from their lists - but I've almost given up hope on talking sense, and my provider, leaving Fire versus Fire.