2 ms·
> Someone writing words in a prompt and a photographer setting up a photoshoot are completely different! Different enough that we can easily draw a line between
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
> Someone writing words in a prompt and a photographer setting up a photoshoot are completely different! Different enough that we can easily draw a line between these activities.
That's why I didn't write "a photographer setting up a photoshoot"; I specifically wrote "a photographer who shoots a couple dozen photos on the go". Perhaps I should've written "a person owning a DSLR" or "amateur instagrammer" instead.
Point is, when discussing copyright both in general, and wrt. generative AI in particular, people tend to bucket together casual, amateur and professional photographers, making it seem that the former do the same kind of creative work as the latter. But that's not true, and not fair - there isn't much more effort or creativity going into casual photography, than there is into iterating a stable diffusion prompt until one finds something they like. Professional photographers have their generative-AI-user counterpart, but in form of an artist or graphic designer using AI-assist tools as part of their overall workflow.