3 ms·
> Yes, but, the way their antilag works is identical to a cheat - it's actually hooking/detouring the game's own functions, which any anticheat will see as an o
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Yes, but, the way their antilag works is identical to a cheat - it's actually hooking/detouring the game's own functions, which any anticheat will see as an obvious hack.
Which is to say that their anticheat system is defective because the method it uses has false positives -- as exemplified by this case, which is not an attempt to cheat.
- bragr 3y ago>their anticheat system is defective Is it? The ToS explicitly says that you will be banned if you inject any code into the game or otherwise modify it, and this injects code into the game resulting in bans. To me it seems more like a business choice to not differentiate between harmless mods and cheats rather than a technical issue with the system.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe ToS saying you will be banned even if you don't cheat doesn't make the thing a cheat. You can try to disclaim the harms from your defective anticheat system but that's certainly not the same thing as there not being any.
- filterfiber 3y agoThe anticheat isn't defective here. It's like running across the DMZ. Your intentions don't matter - ALL anticheat will ban you on sight. You MUST collaborate with the developers to not get banned. This is widely known. It is expected that _any_ software that does this will be banned, that's how anticheat works. They can't tell what your intentions are and they don't need to. If AMD worked with valve they wouldn't have to cross the DMZ at all, instead the engine would call the amd driver without any modifications at all.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The anticheat isn't defective here. It's claiming someone cheated when that person did not cheat. > It's like running across the DMZ. It's like installing land mines in a residential neighborhood and then blaming the residents for stepping on one. It's not even reasonable if you warn them. > They can't tell what your intentions are and they don't need to. They kind of do need to though, because otherwise they punish the innocent. Which is bad. Regardless of whether or not they threaten you with it ahead of time. > If AMD worked with valve they wouldn't have to cross the DMZ at all, instead the engine would call the amd driver without any modifications at all. How is that supposed to work with existing games? There are games where the developers no longer even exist but people still play them.
- filterfiber 3y ago> It's like installing land mines in a residential neighborhood and then blaming the residents for stepping on one. It's not even reasonable if you warn them. No this is seriously a DMZ. I cannot stress this enough. Seriously any game with anticheat this is an automatic ban. This is not something unexpected whatsoever, this is what anticheat does. Try this exact same stunt with R6, battlefield, OW, gta, valorant, whatever and you'll get banned almost instantly unless you work with the game developers. It is very literally anti-cheats job to lay down land mines. > How is that supposed to work with existing games? There are games where the developers no longer even exist but people still play them. If there's no anti-cheat there's no problem. If there is anticheat then expect a ban if you try. Anticheat is not mod friendly. You cannot go around modifying the game all you want in online games with anticheat. > It's claiming someone cheated when that person did not cheat. This is correct however Anticheat doesn't allow _any_ modifications to the main game code. Seriously test any anticheat in any online game and this will be a ban. There's very, very, very few exceptions ever made to this.
- filterfiber 3y ago> Which is to say that their anticheat system is defective because the method it uses has false positives -- as exemplified by this case, which is not an attempt to cheat. This is not a false positive. What AMD did is identical to what cheats do. You cannot modify the game logic without disabling the anticheat period. Depending on how AMD did it, VAC may not have any idea _what_ modified the game, just that it was modified in an unintended way. It's not the anti-cheat's job to decide "oh they hijacked the game engine but they're good guys so its okay". I cannot stress enough that what they did is IDENTICAL to how cheats work, they just happened to be one of the few with innocent intentions which is irrelevant - nobody may tresspass the game logic. Generally you cannot do this at all - AMD likely won't be whitelisted - valve will add support in-engine instead.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoJust because the anti-lag system works in a way that cheats do doesn't mean the anti-cheat flagging isn't a false positive. The anti-lag system is not a cheat. The anti-cheat system thinks it is. By definition, it's a false positive.
- filterfiber 3y ago> The anti-lag system is not a cheat. The anti-cheat system thinks it is. By definition, it's a false positive. Yes but this is not a false positive you fix. This is a DMZ - you do not cross it no matter what your intentions are. The resolution here will be valve adding in-engine support, and AMD won't modify the game at all. There is no anti-cheat that will let you cross this DMZ, it's what they do. (technically you could whitelist them but then the drivers become an attack vector). This is widely known, without collaborating with valve, this is like looking at a mousetrap and knowingly stepping on it barefoot.