6 ms·

Honestly one of the best mecha anime ever, right up there with Neon Genesis and Gundam. Maybe even better in some regards.

FuriouslyAdrift 3y ago
Iron Blood Orphans is probably the most 'realistic' in the genre. Defenitely the best gundam combat. Warning: it's rough and not a happy series.
- yterdy 3y ago
  >Iron Blood Orphans is probably the most 'realistic' in the genre. Save Barbatos' waist circumference. /s Joking aside, while it still succumbs to a lot of genre and franchise cliches, I have to agree that it did a lot of things more maturely than preceding series. The ending is one of the most refreshingly grounded in the franchise (which is probably why so many fans hate it).
- NickC25 3y ago
  none of the best Gundam series are particularly happy. The original MSG starts off with a blunt and incredibly depressing scene.
  - Namidairo 3y ago
    Operation British in MSG started a strange trend where Australia gets left with large crater marks in basically every Gundam timeline, and many non-Gundam properties.
    - NickC25 3y ago
      The whole colony drop scene in MSG just terrified me as a kid. It was the first time I saw large scale human-on-human violence expressed in such a medium, and I was not ready for it. Then I realized "oh, this is a metaphor for the US nuking Japan".
Propelloni 3y ago
For me, Patlabor 1 and 2 are thrillers who happen to have mechas in them. Despite the name and the prominent role of the Labor Patrol department the movie is about the police work done by the Patlabor police force or the counter-terror unit in part 2. As a thriller you know who the baddie is from early on. The conclusion is not therefore not the unveiling of the culprit as it would be in a crime movie, but the neutralization of the well-known culprit, quite often by force (why is that?) Here you see mechas battling it out against a fortress, but it could just as well be a SWAT team storming an appartment block and it would be entertaining all the same. I would place it under "color" and I agree, it can make all the difference ;)
- PaulHoule 3y ago
  Right, Patlabor is strong even without the mechas. Something I find amusing about the series is almost half the time they are dealing with ghosts instead of criminals. (Thus Patlabor is much about the uncompleted legacy of the past as it is about the problem of the near future.) Ghosts and ghost stories are huge theme in anime that you might miss because the portrayal of ghosts in anime and western culture are very similar qualitatively, but quantitatively I think they turn up a lot more. It's much like the way religious professionals turn up more in anime than they do in comparable western media. (e.g. "Cherry" the Priest is a major character in Urusei Yatsura in fact he and his niece Sakura were developed before Lum and Ataru were)

FuriouslyAdrift 3y ago

Iron Blood Orphans is probably the most 'realistic' in the genre. Defenitely the best gundam combat. Warning: it's rough and not a happy series.

yterdy 3y ago
>Iron Blood Orphans is probably the most 'realistic' in the genre. Save Barbatos' waist circumference. /s Joking aside, while it still succumbs to a lot of genre and franchise cliches, I have to agree that it did a lot of things more maturely than preceding series. The ending is one of the most refreshingly grounded in the franchise (which is probably why so many fans hate it).
NickC25 3y ago
none of the best Gundam series are particularly happy. The original MSG starts off with a blunt and incredibly depressing scene.
- Namidairo 3y ago
  Operation British in MSG started a strange trend where Australia gets left with large crater marks in basically every Gundam timeline, and many non-Gundam properties.
  - NickC25 3y ago
    The whole colony drop scene in MSG just terrified me as a kid. It was the first time I saw large scale human-on-human violence expressed in such a medium, and I was not ready for it. Then I realized "oh, this is a metaphor for the US nuking Japan".

Propelloni 3y ago

For me, Patlabor 1 and 2 are thrillers who happen to have mechas in them. Despite the name and the prominent role of the Labor Patrol department the movie is about the police work done by the Patlabor police force or the counter-terror unit in part 2. As a thriller you know who the baddie is from early on. The conclusion is not therefore not the unveiling of the culprit as it would be in a crime movie, but the neutralization of the well-known culprit, quite often by force (why is that?) Here you see mechas battling it out against a fortress, but it could just as well be a SWAT team storming an appartment block and it would be entertaining all the same. I would place it under "color" and I agree, it can make all the difference ;)

PaulHoule 3y ago
Right, Patlabor is strong even without the mechas. Something I find amusing about the series is almost half the time they are dealing with ghosts instead of criminals. (Thus Patlabor is much about the uncompleted legacy of the past as it is about the problem of the near future.) Ghosts and ghost stories are huge theme in anime that you might miss because the portrayal of ghosts in anime and western culture are very similar qualitatively, but quantitatively I think they turn up a lot more. It's much like the way religious professionals turn up more in anime than they do in comparable western media. (e.g. "Cherry" the Priest is a major character in Urusei Yatsura in fact he and his niece Sakura were developed before Lum and Ataru were)