4 ms·
I can sympathize with the general notion that more encryption is better, even if I wouldn't go to the extreme of declaring it a duty. But the author just comple
by crazygringo 3y ago
I can sympathize with the general notion that more encryption is better, even if I wouldn't go to the extreme of declaring it a duty. But the author just completely lost me at:
> We should all use PGP, SSL or equivalent tools; VPNs, Tor and/or SSH tunnelling; IPFS, or other distributed file systems — and ditch proprietary OS's in favour of Linux or truly free Android distros... Those tools and techniques should cease to be arcane nice-to-haves for nerds: we must get more non-technical people onboard.
This is so unrealistic and impractical as a moral "duty" for "all", it undercuts my ability to take the rest of the piece seriously. It's not any kind of seriously considered ethical analysis, weighing the pros and cons of what's actually best or most effective in the real world -- it's a pipe dream.
- Citizen_Lame 3y agoI don't see it as unrealistic, as for your comprehension ability, that's debatable. For this to work on everything, it needs to be hardware implemented (security chip/SOC), to avoid taxing the CPU and rest of the system. Software engineering has been lax for so long, but paradigm is changing and it should be security first.
- high_5 3y agoIt's not unrealistic in technological but sociological terms.
- rakoo 3y agoThat's not unrealistic then, it's just a lack of will.
- nemo 3y agoNo, it's simply unrealistic. Effort is besides the point.
- high_5 3y agoMostly not a lack of will but much more local and urgent priorities than figuring out SSH and PGP, like jobs and chores for example.
- rakoo 3y agoAs I said in another comment, it's not about everyone installing ssh and pgp and configuring them and learning how to use them, it's about us in the tech community to provide tools so easy to use you don't even know you're using state-of-the-art privacy tools. Like what Signal has done, and now it is expected that any messenger at least positions themselves on the end-to-end-encryption. Or like what Deltachat is doing with automatically configuring PGP such that users don't ever need to read those 3 dreaded letters.
- high_5 3y agoBeen there, done that. It's already hard to scale those two apps beyond your immediate circles and people won't just stop using WhatsApp or Viber or whatnot. But then try to convince your friends that they have to convince their friends. Friendships are not a pyramid scheme.
- alexvitkov 3y agoYes, most of these tools are a pain in the ass to use, so people can't be bothered. The only universally used tech on this list is SSL, because end users don't need to "install SSL and learn to use it" - we had to put in the work to upgrade or shitty servers, and they get the benefits. Time had proven that the "don't you care about your privacy" argument doesn't work, so it's up to us to make the privacy-respecting tools better than the alternatives
- rakoo 3y agoThat's exactly my point. I'm not deluded to the point I expect people to read up and install all these tools; it's our job to make these tools so ubiquitous that it doesn't take any effort to effectively use them.
- Citizen_Lame 3y agoExpect people to install those tools in unrealistic. But companies can implement all the features in the end product (web browser, email client, IM client etc.).
- anonym29 3y agoExtremely generous take on human intelligence. If you're of above average intelligence, remember that you're likely biased to assume the average person is more intelligent than they actually are.
- rakoo 3y agoAs I said in another comment, I'm not expecting everyone to actually learn and install those tools, I want all the people who can use them and modify them build on top and provide tools that spread the use of these technologies. I don't expect everyone to configure tor hidden services, but if we can make it so that most traffic goes through tor, because the clients and the servers use it by default, then that will be a nice step. The Tor Browser makes using tor way simpler, if that could be used and advertised as a default browser, that would be great. To me, the sociological aspect is in the way we act together as a society, helping others do what we think is good, providing support. Not simply how one is expected to somehow learn and do everything out of nowhere.
- anonym29 3y agoI like the concept, but I think the problem here is that governments have the means and resources to go after folks building and distributing browsers, apps, etc. The decentralized nature of the technologies mentioned contributes substantially to their resilience. Re-centralizing them opens new avenues of attack and new targets to silence and corrupt for the state.
- baal80spam 3y agoHe said unrealistic, not impossible.
- PeterisP 3y agoFor human-related endeavors, motivation of the stakeholders is the key part that determines whether something is realistic or not. All kinds of technical difficulties can be fixed with effort and talent of a few people, but if something requires will of the masses and there's a lack of will, that thing is simply not going to happen no matter what you do - because there's no "just" with respect to lack of will, that's lack of something necessary that you can't easily create.
- rakoo 3y agoSee my other replies: it's not about the will of the masses, it's about our collective will of us, the tech people, to build the tools that make using these technologies ubiquitous. We've been fixated on our own problems ("what is the best framework for building a blog ?") instead of acting with everyone else to build what we collectively want. It's our responsibility to be of use to the society, not just to us.
- PeterisP 3y agoIMHO in this respect we already have built 'what we collectively want', however, the limiting factor is a lack of will to use or prefer privacy-preserving solutions. The society has voted with its attention and wallets, and it doesn't want what the tech people think is good for society. You can't build a technical solution to a social problem - well, you can, but it won't get used and so it won't solve anything.
- gaoshan 3y ago"as for your comprehension ability, that's debatable" This comes across as rude, especially in response to someone that did not themselves say anything warranting a rude response. You can disagree and make your point without doing this. I'm pointing it out because you genuinely may not be aware and I want to give the benefit of doubt (something I myself too often do not do online).
- Citizen_Lame 3y agoThank you for your concern, it was purposefully rude.
- globular-toast 3y agoWhat's unrealistic about it? I've been doing it for more then a decade.
- nemo 3y agoWhat's unrealistic about it? "We should all."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anonym29 3y agoYou have an extremely generous and optimistic view of the cognitive capital of the average person.
- madmads 3y agoThat's probably the most self-aggrandizing interpretation. Could it be that other people have other priorities or interests rather than spending their time figuring out how to obtain digital privacy without compromising in the areas they care about? No surely it's their low "cognitive capital" /s
- anonym29 3y agoYou are very fortunate to never had the displeasure of having to interact with profoundly stupid people. Not ignorant, not uneducated, but genuinely stupid and slow people. E.g., People for whom significant, immediate, unexpected mechanical feedback in operating something simple, like window blinds, wouldn't cause them to consider whether they might be doing something wrong, and instead continue operariting the blinds in the wrong direction until they snap and break, genuinely being unaware that they were doing it wrong. People who are genuinely lacking the common sense you'd expect a human to have, not even with any cognitive disability or learning disorder of any kind - just genuinely stupid but otherwise ordinary people.
- 3y ago
- jasonlotito 3y ago> it undercuts my ability to take the rest of the piece seriously at all. This lack of ability to be able to control your emotions undercuts my ability to take the rest of the comment seriously at all. It's not any kind of seriously considered rational comment, weighing the pros and cons of the thoughts presented -- it's bad commentary.
- judge2020 3y agoLiving in a pipe dream where you think people want to be educated about maximizing their freedom, at the expense of their time or convenience, is delusional. That's why the rest of the piece is basically irrelevant, if it only works when everyone or the majority follow through with this plan.
- schnubbidubb 3y ago"Those tools and techniques should cease to be arcane nice-to-haves for nerds: we must get more non-technical people onboard" is key here, I would say. If those tools cease to require arcance incantations and work seamlessly like every other thing everyone else is already using, then I don't think it's unrealistic at all.
- bonton89 3y agoI feel like the "all" in this passage is everyone who is capable, not the population in general. The population in general is the second phase, but they need a beachhead to be established to help them. First the capable group needs to stop hiding behind the excuse that the incapable group can't do what they can but won't.
- defend 3y agoIt's only impractical if you actually require end users to understand and apply all of these technologies. It's a lot more tractable if they're abstracted away. The fact is that developers very (very) rarely have to interface directly with TLS or the Signal protocol, yet billions of non-technical users implicitly use them in our browsers and via Signal or WhatsApp. In my view, the challenge in the adoption of secure/private-by-design tech is the simplicity and usability of the interfaces and the capabilities these tools provide. We need secure tools to compete on capability in order to garner mass usage. Without (significant) feature superiority there's little reason for users to make the switch. I'm actively trying to solve some of these problems at Backbone [0]; aiming to build a usable, secure experience for end users and a simple, robust end-to-end-encryption interface for developers. [0] https://backbone.dev/ https://backbone.dev/
- iggldiggl 3y ago> Without (significant) feature superiority Problem is – if you can't trust any server, end-to-end encryption naturally often leads to feature inferiority in the context of multi-device usage.
- diego_sandoval 3y agoThe fact that it's unrealistic doesn't mean that we shouldn't try to achieve it. And the first step towards achieving something big is to state it as a goal when it's still unrealistic. At some point, going to the moon was unrealistic. Right now, ending wars is unrealistic, but it's also absolutely necessary.
- signatureMove 3y agoIf you instantly switched over the average person and took away their Windows/Mac, they would be lost and would constantly get bit by the cons of those technologies. Ever had to teach someone something simple in Excel? Imagine how teaching them SSH would go. However, that doesn't mean it can't be a gradual process that takes years or generations even.
- ckyngcybra 3y ago[dead]