3 ms·
The biggest counter-incentive for realtors is that they make more money on volume than added-value-over-replacement. Both sides are incentivized to move each h
by ethbr1 3y ago
The biggest counter-incentive for realtors is that they make more money on volume than added-value-over-replacement.
Both sides are incentivized to move each house ASAP, rather than for the best price, as they make 3% of any marginal price difference, but 3% of the total price of an additional sale.
Consequently, you're really only getting value from a realtor if "getting the deal done ASAP" is your priority.
- jncfhnb 3y agoPerhaps this perspective varies depending on the market but I don’t really expect the agent to do any negotiating on the price? So long as they’re not actively working with the other side to abuse an elevator or something, I think it’s fine. I just want them to help me get the house. Or sell the house. Do I think that’s worth 3% if my home value? Probably not. It’s strange there’s not flat fee agents.
- bunchman 3y ago[dead]
- runako 3y ago> It’s strange there’s not flat fee agents. Essentially the cartel prevents this. If you started a flat-fee agency, you would not be allowed access to MLS listings to show your buyers. Homes you represented to sell would not be allowed into MLS, and Realtors would not bring buyers to your home (because you're not prepared to give them 3% of the deal). This is not an accident of the free market.
- calmworm 3y agoThis is either ignorant nonsense or an outright lie. There absolutely are flat-fee agents and there is no “cartel” or anything preventing any agent or brokerage from charging anything they wish.
- ethbr1 3y ago> there is no “cartel” or anything preventing any agent or brokerage from charging anything they wish. Redfin literally just removed itself from the NAR for that reason (and also alleged sexual harassment in the organization). https://www.redfin.com/news/redfin-is-leaving-nar/ https://www.redfin.com/news/redfin-is-leaving-nar/ >> In the many marketplaces governed by its policies, NAR still blocks sellers from listing homes that don’t pay a commission to the buyer’s agent, and it blocks websites like Redfin.com from showing for-sale-by-owner listings alongside agent-listed homes. >> In about half the U.S., including in cities like Charlotte, Dallas, Houston, Las Vegas, Long Island, Minneapolis, Nashville, Phoenix and Salt Lake City, we can’t quit NAR individually or en masse, because NAR membership is required for agents to access listing databases, lockboxes, and industry-standard contracts. It’s impossible to be an agent if you can’t see which homes are for sale, or unlock the door to those homes, or even write an offer. The DoJ also alleged exactly that in 2019. https://www.justice.gov/media/1105806/dl?inline https://www.justice.gov/media/1105806/dl?inline >> These NAR rules, policies, and practices include: (a) prohibiting NAR-affiliated multiple-listing services (“MLSs”) from disclosing to prospective buyers the amount of commission that the buyer broker will earn if the buyer purchases a home listed on the MLS; (b) allowing buyer brokers to misrepresent to buyers that a buyer broker’s services are free; (c) enabling buyer brokers to filter MLS listings based on the level of buyer broker commissions offered and to exclude homes with lower commissions from consideration by potential home buyers; and (d) limiting access to the lockboxes that provide licensed brokers with physical access to a home that is for sale to only brokers who are members of a NAR-affiliated MLS And then there was People v. National Association of Realtors, 1981 https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/120/459.html https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/1... >> The original three-count complaint alleged: (1) unlawful restrictions of trade under the Cartwright Act through certain restrictive regulations of the multiple listing service (MLS) operated by SDBR, including the fact only board members were entitled to access to that necessary service; (2) restraint of trade because of commission rate price fixing; [...] >> On the first cause of action the court found a group boycott and issued an injunction guaranteeing access, on conditions, to the residential portion of the MLS to all licensed brokers and their salespersons without regard to SDBR membership. The court found no such boycott as to the MLS investment property portion. All other MLS operating rules were found to be reasonable, including a requirement excluding all listings except exclusive-right-to-sell agreements. >> [On the second] Based in part on [expert witness] testimony, the trial court found the standard rates prevailing over a long period of time to be evidence of collusive price setting or other artificial influence. It also found four activities attributable to SDBR policies which are useful to maintain such uniformity: publishing and distributing sample literature using 6 percent and 50/50 split as examples; requiring the listing commission to be included in the published MLS, thus aiding those who would bring pressure to bear on price cutters; entertaining complaints against undercutters through its ethics or arbitration machinery brought by persons motivated by the undercutter's deviation from the usual 6 percent rate and 50/50 commission split, and continuing the foregoing practices even after it ceased publicly recommending adherence to the standard rate it had developed and maintained for many years. Each of the above findings is supported by substantial evidence.
- voisin 3y agoIt would be nice if it was a sliding scale that decreased as the value went up. It is essentially no more work to transact an $800k house than a $400k house yet the commission doubles.
- joshstrange 3y ago> The biggest counter-incentive for realtors is that they make more money on volume than added-value-over-replacement. Only if you don't care about your reputation or repeat/referral business (which is the lifeblood of a successful realtor)