3 ms·
I'm generally supportive of RedHat, and think they do pretty well by the open-source community. But I don't agree with the latter part of your comment on princi
by _delirium 15y ago
I'm generally supportive of RedHat, and think they do pretty well by the open-source community. But I don't agree with the latter part of your comment on principle: not everything that is legal is a good idea or something we should cheer. I think there is a general ethical requirement to give something back to people who got you where you are, even if you aren't legally obligated to do so. (And RedHat does in fact do so.)
Things actually work better in the case where there's an ethical but not legally codified understanding, imo, enforced informally through community pressure rather than lawsuits. If you try to add it into legal obligations, complex licenses start piling up; the old BSD advertising clause, for example, was an attempt to turn the ethical principle of "you should prominently acknowledge the work you built on" into a legally enforceable license, which in retrospect most people agree was misguided. But you should still prominently acknowledge the work you built on, anyway, and it's fair to call people out on it if they aren't giving sufficient credit. You can't sue people who don't give sufficient credit (past the bare minimum copyright statement), but you can criticize them and apply community pressure.