2 ms·
I think most employees (and perhaps many managers) fail to understand the purpose of a reference check. It is _not_ to find out whether the employee will be an
by ghshephard 15y ago
I think most employees (and perhaps many managers) fail to understand the purpose of a reference check. It is _not_ to find out whether the employee will be any good - that can only be determined by observing the employee in your new workplace for some probationary period.
The hiring decision is traditionally made on the strength of a hiring-manager's conviction and only the hiring manager - the interview pool can inform, but never make a decision. I've seen many situations in which the entire interview group said no to an individual who was hired, and became a star player. I've also seen scenarios where everyone said yes, and the employee was terminated for non performance within a year.
The interview is just a numbskull filter - you usually can't identify great people, but usually (particularly for technical positions) - you can eliminate the people who don't know anything.
So, what then, is the purpose of the "Reference Check" - it's to determine if this employee you are hiring burned down, assaulted, or otherwise was convicted of some horrible crime at a previous company. In general, with larger corporations, all you'll ever get out of them was "He was an employee from XXX to YYY in the position of ZZZ" - but, if he was terminated for killing a coworker, you might discover he was terminated for cause. (unclear whether they'll tell you _what_ cause, but do you really need to know?)
I've done over a 100 reference checks for employees - and, over time, I've realized that's all I'll ever get. And, when an employee does not give you _any_ prior bosses (particularly if they've had a lot of them) - that's a warning sign as well, that you are allowed to discriminate on in at least California.