3 ms·
> For example, "free of charge" is "besplatno". However, the first syllable is actually "bez-", with /z/ devoiced to /s/ by the last consonant of the cluster.
by cyberax 3y ago
> For example, "free of charge" is "besplatno". However, the first syllable is actually "bez-", with /z/ devoiced to /s/ by the last consonant of the cluster.
Why is that bad? Other Slavic languages also use the same approach. Consonant clusters usually sound a bit indistinct, so you have to make a choice which pronunciation you want to standardize for writing.
I'm a native Slavic speaker, and I know a bit of Serbian, and "besplatno" _does_ sound more closer to "s" to me.
> However, it comes from a general pronunciation pattern for consonant clusters, something that could be defined outside of the actual spelling. Why obscure the internal structure of a word like that?
To stay closer to phonetic accuracy. It's a trade-off. If you are a native speaker, you learn the spoken language first, so spelling being close to the actual phonetic pronunciation helps to learn writing.
- acadapter 3y ago>I'm a native Slavic speaker, and I know a bit of Serbian, and "besplatno" _does_ sound more closer to "s" to me. Yes, it should be an /s/ for sure, but the spelling doesn't need to represent the /s/ sound in this case. The /s/ sound could be spelled "z" here, and be represented by a rule that says "the voicedness of a consonant cluster is determined by its last consonant". Serbo-Croatian phonetic spelling is like hardcoding stuff that shouldn't be hardcoded. And it focuses on the wrong stuff - why aren't there any accent markings in everyday writing?
- cyberax 3y ago> Serbo-Croatian phonetic spelling is like hardcoding stuff that shouldn't be hardcoded. Why? I don't get it. It's a very nice feature of Slavic writing: it's phonetic (at least in one direction). And it makes it MUCH easier for native speakers to learn compared to more 'hieroglyphic' languages. > And it focuses on the wrong stuff - why aren't there any accent markings in everyday writing? Because the stress pattern can usually be deduced, if you are a native speaker. So accent markers are really needed for exceptions or for non-native speakers.
- acadapter 3y agoThe accent pattern is not always obvious, such as "grad" (city or hailstone), or some of the feminine nom.sg/gen.pl nouns And if we take another language's historic spelling as an example: Polish "rz" makes stuff easier for speakers of other Slavic languages, instead of spelling out the ż or sz sound verbatim.