3 ms·
See my reply to one of the pre-existing comments [0]: it's not Google that is the primary source of these ideas about AGPL, it's the companies who chose AGPL wi
by lolinder 3y ago
See my reply to one of the pre-existing comments [0]: it's not Google that is the primary source of these ideas about AGPL, it's the companies who chose AGPL with the intention of choosing a license that is completely and totally viral, even over network calls. Companies like iText [1] want their customers to believe that AGPL means that there's no way to use the free version without open-sourcing your entire software stack.
Whether or not that's true, it's reasonable for Google to warn against using an untested license that has vendors using it who specifically argue that it is completely and totally viral. Interpreting that caution as a psy-op is a bit far fetched.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37904285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37904285
[1] https://itextpdf.com/how-buy/AGPLv3-license https://itextpdf.com/how-buy/AGPLv3-license
- PeterisP 3y agoThe way I see it, it looks like iText is simply lying on their page about at least some of the restrictions of AGPL.
- lolinder 3y agoI'm inclined to agree. And I'm more inclined to believe that they and companies like them are responsible for false narratives surrounding AGPL than I am to believe that it's a long con by the cloud providers to get more free work for their cloud services. Vendors of AGPL software have a much more concrete and proximate motivation for exaggerating the effects of AGPL than the cloud providers do.
- matrss 3y agoGoogle could do something good and test the license. They have the resources to fight it out.