5 ms·
What pmarca is ignoring is that most people won't even try to come up with ideas by themselves. It's pretty tough to spend hours by yourself brainstorming on o
by staunch 19y ago
What pmarca is ignoring is that most people won't even try to come up with ideas by themselves. It's pretty tough to spend hours by yourself brainstorming on one topic. When you have someone (even a manikin) as resistance it can really draw out your best ideas. Nothing makes me come up with a clever idea quicker than someone suggesting that there's no solution to a problem. The real world difference between brainstorming as a group and as an individual might be the difference between some and zero.
What these groups of co-founders do together is more complicated than just sitting down and trying to think of ideas. I suspect the most productive setup is a kind of together-alone-together sandwich. Together you talk about some hard problem, probably getting nowhere. Then, the next morning, one of you has an idea in the shower about how to solve it. He runs eagerly to to tell the others, and together they work out the kinks. -- Ideas for Startups
- natrius 19y ago"What pmarca is ignoring is that most people won't even try to come up with ideas by themselves." All you have to do is tell each other that you're going to meet to discuss the ideas that you've thought up in three hours. The social disincentive of looking pretty lame if you show up with nothing is enough to get people to do it. He's not saying a group of one is better, but the combined individual efforts of a group are greater than when they all think about things together.
- staunch 19y agoIn my experience most people would show up with some basic ideas and then rely on the group interaction to draw out the rest. The test and the results are flawed because they don't match the real world at all. Of course you don't do just one or the other because the together/alone pattern repeats itself and there's an opportunity to present new ideas each time the group meets. I think pmarca's point was that group brainstorming isn't a valuable thing to do. That's not true from my experience. I am a huge fan of avoiding feel-good wishy-washy brainstorming though.