3 ms·
For the purposes of tracking direct man-made pollution ignoring wildfires and other “acts of God” is the way to go. You get absurd data otherwise - none of the
by bombcar 3y ago
For the purposes of tracking direct man-made pollution ignoring wildfires and other “acts of God” is the way to go. You get absurd data otherwise - none of the EPA’s tools “work” against wildfire pollution so it makes sense to factor that out.
However, later misuse of the data for other purposes may cause issues - if you were very sensitive to pollution you’d want to know where the wildfire areas are and avoid them, and the EPA data doesn’t show that.
- master-lincoln 3y agoIs there any evidence most wild fires are not direct consequence of human action? This "act of good" argument seems disingenuous as even if no direct human action caused the fire, there is evidence that human actions caused general higher risks for wild fires in certain areas.
- bombcar 3y agoSomething can be the consequences of human action and still not under the purview of the particular agency. The EPA could likely require changes to certain things that might mitigate some possible causes of wildfires (like building clearances, smokestack spark arrestors, etc) - but other cases of "human caused" including direct arson aren't under it's jurisdiction. The problem comes when there's stuff that falls through the cracks as it is under nobody's jurisdiction.
- bluGill 3y agoForesters have been complaining for years that they are not allowed to manage forests the way they should be. Every time they try to start a fire to burn of underbrush someone goes to court to get an injunction against it.
- mrpopo 3y ago> none of the EPA’s tools “work” against wildfire pollution so it makes sense to factor that out. Factor that out for part of the analysis on one hand, and include it and add some new tools to the EPA on the other. Wildfires are made worse by bad forest management and climate change, and the USA isn't a small player in the field. Claiming that it can't have an impact is preposterous.