4 ms·
> Right of computer owner to access public network resources This misunderstanding is the basis of your entire argument: YouTube is not a public resource. It’s
by acdha 3y ago
> Right of computer owner to access public network resources
This misunderstanding is the basis of your entire argument: YouTube is not a public resource. It’s a private company providing access to mostly private content in exchange for payment under certain terms.
Currently they have the right to deny access as desired and even to pursue legal charges against people who don’t follow their terms. The only way to change the situation is to change the law, such as what some countries have done to limit the amount of tracking they’re allowed to perform. Client portability would be an interesting but challenging argument to make since they would have raise not only the past estimates of revenue lost due to unauthorized redistribution but now would almost certainly make the argument that creators need to be protected against unauthorized AI usage, too. I’d like to be proven pessimistic but it seems unlikely that we’re going to see much political will for IP reform with relatively little public demand.
- primordz 3y ago> in exchange for payment under certain terms. What terms? I can go to youtube.com right now without an account, without accepting any agreement or contract, click on a video and it will send data to my computer. How I process that data on my computer is entirely up to me and not anyone else.
- acdha 3y agoYour use of YouTube is contingent on the terms of service offered: https://www.youtube.com/t/terms https://www.youtube.com/t/terms It’s true that you aren’t required to create an account but also true that you have no standing to complain if they start blocking access when they detect that you aren’t following their terms. It’s private property so it’s their rules.
- josephcsible 3y agoBy reading this comment, you agree to my Terms of Service. My Terms of Service are that you must send me $100.
- Qwertious 3y agoOh, fuck. Where do I send the $100?
- acdha 3y agoOkay, now try to construct something which is actually a valid comparison: If you don’t respond to this comment politely, I won’t reply. Nobody is saying YouTube can arbitrarily bill you - only that they’re entirely within their rights to stop giving you free things if you don’t follow their terms of service for use of their private property.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BeetleB 3y agoIs there any example of a court case where they ruled that users are bound to those types of terms when they didn't explicitly opt in? Can I really set up a blog, put an obscure Terms of Service link somewhere, and legally obligate anyone who reads a single blog post to follow those terms - even if they never clicked the link? I somewhat doubt it.
- acdha 3y agoThere have been a number of cases holding that it’s not criminal as long as you aren’t knowingly impacting service to others (e.g. Oracle v. Rimini). Similarly, I can’t put in a “you owe me one million dollars” clause and expect to collect unless I can prove that you knew about it and agreed. That’s not what’s being argued here, though: YouTube isn’t taking people to court, they’re just enforcing their terms better. Some people don’t like that and are trying to invent some legal right to continue accessing that content, but that simply doesn’t exist.
- b112 3y agoYes, but google doesn't have to send you anything. EG, they can decide not to, if you aren't looking at ads, or in their workflow, or using their app, and those may be their terms.
- primordz 3y agoSure, but as long as they offer public access to their data I will keep consuming it the way I want to, without any ethical, moral or legal issues.
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago> YouTube is not a public response > providing access to mostly private content in exchange for payment under certain terms. Confused frown. That doesn't match any description I've previously come across about what YouTube is. I thought YouTube content was pretty much entirely 'public'. If they removed their website and access to the content was limited only to those who paid a monthly subscription via an app then that'd be slightly different. But then they'd lose all the foot traffic.
- acdha 3y agoPrivate doesn’t have to mean “locked down to subscribers” - only that the owner has no obligation to give you access except on the terms they picked. In this case, it means “available with ads”. They’ve made the decision that more people watch ads than buy video, which has clearly worked well for them but also means that they don’t have other content available when the creators don’t like that (for example, movies generally aren’t available without an additional payment).
- spuz 3y agoIt's not public in that you must enter a legal agreement before you can access any of its data. That's what the terms of service are when you first load up the website. The TOS will specify terms under which they are free to withdraw your access.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoThere's a TOS? Since when? Do I need to click OK to agree to it before I can watch any videos? Do I need to do this each time I load up the website? I don't think I've ever seen a TOS for YT (although I must admit I'm very good at not actively being and to remember actions that have become habitual).
- spuz 3y agoHere's the YouTube TOS. I believe they ask you to agree to it along with the cookie policy banner that shows up when you don't have cookies stored: https://www.youtube.com/t/terms https://www.youtube.com/t/terms Edit: actually you're right they don't explicitly ask you to agree to the TOS, but the TOS contains this paragraph. > If you do not understand the Agreement, or do not accept any part of it, then you may not use the Service So I guess the agreement is implicit rather than explicit.