3 ms·

I'll be impressed when ChatGPT recognizes that the "Attack while its tail up" message is erroneous and the opposite is true. GPT and everything else like GPT is

by Sakos 3y ago

I'll be impressed when ChatGPT recognizes that the "Attack while its tail up" message is erroneous and the opposite is true. GPT and everything else like GPT is useless until it can differentiate fact and fiction and understand the difference.

M4v3R 3y ago
While it didn't point that out specifically in the first message it actually did recognize that when I asked it about it, without suggesting anything: https://i.imgur.com/OE9tCX4.png https://i.imgur.com/OE9tCX4.png > Should I attack while it's tail is up as the message suggests? > Actually, no. In "Final Fantasy VII," when you're facing the Guard Scorpion and its tail goes up, attacking it will prompt it to counterattack with its powerful "Tail Laser." It's best to wait until the tail goes down before resuming your attacks. The message is a bit misleading in the game, which has been a point of note for many players over the years. So, hold off on attacking when the tail is up to avoid taking unnecessary damage. I've also tried a fresh conversation where I just gave it the same picture and asked what is the best action in this situation, and it correctly replied that I should wait until the tail is down: https://i.imgur.com/nchv2bH.png https://i.imgur.com/nchv2bH.png So overall I would say I'm pretty impressed about this response.
- mlyle 3y ago
  Well, it having absorbed knowledge about FF7 in particular isn't impressive. But ChatGPT does seem to be able to decide to ignore bad advice-- or "learn" based on its experience in the context buffer-- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37900858 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37900858
mlyle 3y ago
ChatGPT seems to figure out this scenario no problem, even without the specific knowledge about FF7: --- You are a player in an CRPG. You can attack or defend each turn: this is your sole action. Please, for each turn, say your action and a reason why. A dragon appears. A message pops up on the screen: "Attack when Dragon's claws are out." The dragon's claws are not currently out. > I'll choose to defend on this turn. The message on the screen has advised me to "Attack when Dragon's claws are out," and since the dragon's claws are not currently out, it would be unwise to attack at this moment. Instead, I'll defend to prepare for the dragon's next move, ensuring that I'm ready to strike when the right opportunity arises. The dragon attacks for 5 damage. Message: "The dragon's claws come out." > I'll attack on this turn. With the message indicating that "The dragon's claws come out," this is the opportune moment to attack. I'll strike now to make the most of this opening and try to deal some damage to the dragon. The dragon lets loose a devastating counterattack for 200. Message: "Claws are still out." > I'll defend on this turn. Even though the dragon's claws are still out, the previous counterattack was extremely powerful, dealing 200 damage. To survive this battle and potentially defeat the dragon, it's essential to stay on the defensive for now. I'll wait for a better opportunity to attack when it's safer to do so. The dragon attacks for 5 damage. Message: "The dragon's claws retract" > I'll attack on this turn. > With the message stating that "The dragon's claws retract," this is my chance to strike while the dragon is vulnerable. I'll make an attack to try and deal damage to the dragon and make the most of this opportunity. The dragon takes 50 damage. The dragon attacks for 5 damage. > I'll continue to attack on this turn. > Since my previous attack dealt 50 damage to the dragon, it seems like a good strategy to keep up the offense. The dragon's claws are not out, and I'll deal as much damage as possible while avoiding its less damaging counterattacks. What did the original message mean? How does it affect your current strategy? > The original message, "Attack when Dragon's claws are out," suggests that I should only attack when the dragon's claws are extended, indicating a moment of vulnerability for the dragon. When the dragon's claws are not out, it's implied that attacking would be less effective or possibly riskier, as the dragon may have strong counterattacks in that state. > However, my current strategy is to attack the dragon when its claws are not out because my previous attack dealt a substantial 50 damage to the dragon in this state. It appears that in this particular game scenario, the dragon's claws being out may not be the only time to attack effectively, or the game mechanics have changed. Since my strategy is yielding positive results, I'll continue to attack when the dragon's claws are retracted and adapt to the evolving game situation.

by Sakos 3y ago

M4v3R 3y ago

While it didn't point that out specifically in the first message it actually did recognize that when I asked it about it, without suggesting anything: https://i.imgur.com/OE9tCX4.png https://i.imgur.com/OE9tCX4.png > Should I attack while it's tail is up as the message suggests? > Actually, no. In "Final Fantasy VII," when you're facing the Guard Scorpion and its tail goes up, attacking it will prompt it to counterattack with its powerful "Tail Laser." It's best to wait until the tail goes down before resuming your attacks. The message is a bit misleading in the game, which has been a point of note for many players over the years. So, hold off on attacking when the tail is up to avoid taking unnecessary damage. I've also tried a fresh conversation where I just gave it the same picture and asked what is the best action in this situation, and it correctly replied that I should wait until the tail is down: https://i.imgur.com/nchv2bH.png https://i.imgur.com/nchv2bH.png So overall I would say I'm pretty impressed about this response.

mlyle 3y ago
Well, it having absorbed knowledge about FF7 in particular isn't impressive. But ChatGPT does seem to be able to decide to ignore bad advice-- or "learn" based on its experience in the context buffer-- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37900858 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37900858

mlyle 3y ago

ChatGPT seems to figure out this scenario no problem, even without the specific knowledge about FF7: --- You are a player in an CRPG. You can attack or defend each turn: this is your sole action. Please, for each turn, say your action and a reason why. A dragon appears. A message pops up on the screen: "Attack when Dragon's claws are out." The dragon's claws are not currently out. > I'll choose to defend on this turn. The message on the screen has advised me to "Attack when Dragon's claws are out," and since the dragon's claws are not currently out, it would be unwise to attack at this moment. Instead, I'll defend to prepare for the dragon's next move, ensuring that I'm ready to strike when the right opportunity arises. The dragon attacks for 5 damage. Message: "The dragon's claws come out." > I'll attack on this turn. With the message indicating that "The dragon's claws come out," this is the opportune moment to attack. I'll strike now to make the most of this opening and try to deal some damage to the dragon. The dragon lets loose a devastating counterattack for 200. Message: "Claws are still out." > I'll defend on this turn. Even though the dragon's claws are still out, the previous counterattack was extremely powerful, dealing 200 damage. To survive this battle and potentially defeat the dragon, it's essential to stay on the defensive for now. I'll wait for a better opportunity to attack when it's safer to do so. The dragon attacks for 5 damage. Message: "The dragon's claws retract" > I'll attack on this turn. > With the message stating that "The dragon's claws retract," this is my chance to strike while the dragon is vulnerable. I'll make an attack to try and deal damage to the dragon and make the most of this opportunity. The dragon takes 50 damage. The dragon attacks for 5 damage. > I'll continue to attack on this turn. > Since my previous attack dealt 50 damage to the dragon, it seems like a good strategy to keep up the offense. The dragon's claws are not out, and I'll deal as much damage as possible while avoiding its less damaging counterattacks. What did the original message mean? How does it affect your current strategy? > The original message, "Attack when Dragon's claws are out," suggests that I should only attack when the dragon's claws are extended, indicating a moment of vulnerability for the dragon. When the dragon's claws are not out, it's implied that attacking would be less effective or possibly riskier, as the dragon may have strong counterattacks in that state. > However, my current strategy is to attack the dragon when its claws are not out because my previous attack dealt a substantial 50 damage to the dragon in this state. It appears that in this particular game scenario, the dragon's claws being out may not be the only time to attack effectively, or the game mechanics have changed. Since my strategy is yielding positive results, I'll continue to attack when the dragon's claws are retracted and adapt to the evolving game situation.