3 ms·
I think we see eye-to eye on a couple things, and disagree on others. I agree most people's core values only shift slowly over time. However, most topics of di
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I think we see eye-to eye on a couple things, and disagree on others.
I agree most people's core values only shift slowly over time. However, most topics of discussion or debate are not about core values themselves. they are about loosely related topics bound by layers of assumptions and beliefs. This is where information sharing is important, and fundamental to learning.
I don't know that anyone can find truth without a process of learning.
On the other-hand, I don't see collective decision making and persuasion as a route to truth or learning at all.
I agree that rationalist oversimplify, and think that is basically because they already hold utilitarianism as a fundamental axiom. That said, I think the objective of being "less wrong" is a pretty good one.
I'm not sure what humanity is left with if we give up on truth or accuracy a mutual objective of discussion.
- dullcrisp 3y agoI apologize for getting slightly mystical here, but I think of humanity as a vast consciousness, learning and growing and reasoning and evolving. We’re tiny aspects of that consciousness. We observe, develop ideas, bounce them off each other, deliberate, and eventually some take hold and spread, changing how mankind collectively sees the world. It’s not enough to just share information with each other, and lately the internet has made that increasingly less necessary. We need to test our ideas, subject them to collective scrutiny, and try to spread or adapt them in response to those of others. There aren’t always great forums to do that in, but I think it’s worthwhile in principle.