3 ms·
Rape is the headline-grabbing problem, but the real problem is a far more mundane loss of privacy. Do you really want everybody in all your social circles to kn
by jerf 15y ago
Rape is the headline-grabbing problem, but the real problem is a far more mundane loss of privacy. Do you really want everybody in all your social circles to know exactly where you're partying Friday nights, and exactly whose house you actually ended up sleeping at? Or if you have no problem with that, insert your choice of thing you don't really care to broadcast to everybody.
A nontrivial part of the reason why I have no interest in being on facebook is the amount of my family that is on it. And I'm not even doing or saying anything that my family will particularly find outrageous like some people, I wouldn't be leaking a sexual preference or something I don't want to reveal to them at this time. I simply don't care to run my every opinion, location, preference, and activity past them, and then have to hear about their opinions about it.
To be clear, I'm 33 and have long since stopped caring about their opinions... but I still don't want to listen to them, either. I'm very closely related to some people in my family whom I can't really get away from who are virtually incapable of having a thought without saying it out loud. YMMV. And I am by far not a pathological example... I'm doing this more out of my personal convenience than anything else, there's nothing that I feel I have to hide. What of those that do?
And if you're really having a hard time imagining what that sort of thing may be... this very post is an example. The person I'm referring to will never find it here. Ever. I can speak freely here, at least as long as I don't name names which I wouldn't anyhow. I'm not in a hurry to live in world where that goes away. Online balkanization isn't all bad. It isn't even mostly bad.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bradleyland 15y agoSo what is your proposed solution? I already don't post anything online that I don't consider public, just like I don't discuss in a restaurant something I wouldn't want overheard. I have an entirely different privacy threshold than you do. Would any proposed solution respect the fact that I might choose to share more (or less)? For me, the solution seems pretty straight forward. If you desire privacy, don't share.
- jerf 15y ago"So what is your proposed solution?" My real proposed solution? Wait for Facebook to collapse under its own weight like all previous attempts to massively centralize the web under one roof have failed, then wait for the more decentralized solutions to pop up and potentially join many of them for my various personae, each of which possibly with its own thresholds for sharing and different communities in them. The human instinct that the answer to every problem is centralization is a leftover vestige of our tribal past that is particularly maladaptive in the 21st century, though I'll admit to being impressed how far along that road Facebook has gotten. It's only a matter of time; the contradictions between Facebook's desires and the user's desires are only going to grow.