6 ms·
There is- or has been- something very strange going on lately. At the height of the GeekList mini-controversy last week the HN thread discussing it[1], which wa
by untog 15y ago
There is- or has been- something very strange going on lately. At the height of the GeekList mini-controversy last week the HN thread discussing it[1], which was in third place on the front page, was flagged and killed. The second discussion that was created[2] was also killed. Then I posted a blog entry[3] which also got to the front page, then was also flagged and killed. At that point I just gave up, because what can you do? It seems like the flagging mechanism is far too powerful- just a few reports and the entry gets shunted back seven pages. A few more and it's gone entirely.
It's worrying for two reasons: one, that original Geeklist discussion had some great points being made, and a lot of users were obviously engaging with it before a minority decided to dispose of it. Two, there's a clear minority on here that would like to see discussions about sexism in tech removed from HN.
[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3739913 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3739913
[2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3740378 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3740378
[3] http://blog.untogether.co.uk/post/19740556298/why-are-posts-about-the-geeklist-controversy-being http://blog.untogether.co.uk/post/19740556298/why-are-posts-...
- gravitronic 15y agoMaybe it's due to the lack of a "downvote" button for submissions?
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoI've noticed that there's a new kind of "political correctness" which, quite paradoxically, maintains that complaints about sexist and racist behavior cannot even be discussed (on the grounds that political correctness is somehow more abhorrent than the behavior that is being critiqued)
- tjic 15y ago> (on the grounds that political correctness is somehow more abhorrent than the behavior that is being critiqued) Or perhaps PC stuff is not so much abhorrent as deeply deeply BORING and un-related to what we want to read here at HN?
- pyre 15y agoIt affects our industry and a number of people care about such issues. Would you say that SOPA articles should be killed because politics are boring (or a waste of time)?
- Karunamon 15y agoAfter the first one? Yes. This is the reason I unfollowed r/technology over on Reddit, it's the same stuff (ACTA and SOPA and PIPA! Oh my!) day in, and day out. I appreciate being informed about badly written laws that could impact the internet and its users. What I don't appreciate is echo-chamber hand-wringing over how horrible a certain law is, day in, and day out. Yeah, I agree with the folks saying the laws are crap, but there's not going to be any productive discussion there - just a group bitchfest, which while cathartic, gets precisely nothing done. Put another way, it gets boring after the third time or so.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoI would guess that any given technology-related topic is deeply deeply boring to a significant slice of the HN readership but we don't flag them just because cloud computing or database design is not a personal interest. We know that if it's a subject we find boring we can just not read it. It's the "sexism in technology" posts that are reflexively flagged and to me that suggests something more than boredom is at work, perhaps an unease with the whole topic. As if certain people can't even stand the idea being discussed anywhere around them.
- DanBC 15y agoThere have been plenty of sexism in technology posts recently, many of which were not flagged and got many up votes and spent some time on the first page. But something with a stupid subject line ('OH HAI SEXISM' or whatever it was) is going to be flagged very quickly by lots of people. Especially if there have been lots of sexism in tech threads recently, especially if there have been threads about the same company recently. By "boring" people don't mean "not interesting to me"[1] they mean "unlikely to generate useful or interesting discussion". People tend to know exactly what they think about some subjects (Abortion, circumcision, "middle east problem", etc.). Thus, discussions about those subjects tend to have people talking at each other, not listening to each other, not sharing information. There are many places to have those discussions. It's nice that HN is free of that kind of discussion.
- Tichy 15y agoIt's just that the guidelines for posting to HN state that politics are off topic: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html If you can present a discussion about sexist and racist behavior that "satisfies intellectual curiosity", you might have a winner.
- GiraffeNecktie 15y ago"Politics" is not "political correctness". Don't let the similarity in words confuse. Sexism in technology has nothing to do with politics (or only in the most broad sense of the word, in which case everything is "political")
- Tichy 15y agoIn my opinion it is essentially a political issue. Isn't all politics essential debate about what is right and wrong. Is it right if farmers get subsidies? Is it right to enforce trade embargoes? And so on. Some issues might seem to us to be so clear cut that it seems obvious what is right, but judging by the discussions, not everybody agrees.
- mkr-hn 15y agoIt doesn't state that politics are off topic. It states that most stories about politics are off topic. Two very different things. edit: For example, Language Log will often go into detail on campaign trail gaffes from a linguistic perspective. That's in the realm of politics, but I think you'd agree it fits on HN. http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?cat=16 http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?cat=16
- MichaelApproved 15y ago"It seems like the flagging mechanism is far too powerful- just a few reports and the entry gets shunted back seven pages" What makes you think it was just a few and not much more? Is it speculation or have you seen the code that handles flagging?
- untog 15y agoIt's incredibly difficult to make any kind of meaningful analysis, you're right. Perhaps I was giving the HN community too much credit by suggesting that only a minority would be misusing the flag button.
- DanBC 15y agoWhy do you assume misuse of the flag button? There was more than one thread dedicated to Geeklist. There really wasn't any need for more.
- mindslight 15y agoI presume those articles were killed due to not wanting to feed the attention troll. Killing content-free controversy is a good feature of the non-democratic moderation - yellow journalism is designed to draw users in and make them passionately care about superficialities. Preventing further comments on a deadened article does really suck, but given the development status of the server, thats the breaks (btw, is HN actually still running on mzscheme-372, or is there a better implementation of Arc these days?). I've had showdead on for a while, and the sheer majority of dead comments are spam, one-liners, and duplicates (when you submit the same comment twice, the second one is automatically deadened). Occasionally I will see someone who's been hellbanned for a few marginal comments and it's clear that they're still trying to contribute - those are the real travesties.
- untog 15y agoThen perhaps submissions need downvote buttons- because what you are describing is not what the "flag" button is for. I don't like the idea that a group of users are deciding what is "superficial" for me- if I'd arrived on HN an hour later than I did, I would never have seen the GeekList post and been able to make up my own mind.
- mikecane 15y agoAFAIK, Flag is for spam or something that is soooo OT that it should have been submitted to Reddit because it doesn't fit here from any intellectual or technical point of view (say, general politics). In all my time, I've used Flag maybe once -- and it was for spam. Using it as an Editor for something that is otherwise of interest is abuse, in my own opinion.
- mindslight 15y agoActually that's precisely what flagging is for - getting a human moderator to look at the story and decide whether it is worthwhile. Information transmission and copying are easy, filtering and management are hard. There are a billion things going on in the world right now. What interesting stories didn't get HN exposure because someone else seized the moment for 15 minutes of twitter-fame?
- Tichy 15y agoIf you think about it, the relationship of the GeekList incident to HN was pure coincidence. Some company had a video with a scantily clad girl in it. That's the content of that news item. Would you have considered it related to HN if the company would have been making beer, or hovers, or cars, or whatever? The only assumed relationship was that the company carried the word "geek" in it's name. It's 2012, so I wouldn't even assume that every HN reader is automatically a geek anymore - in fact, does geek even still have much of a meaning? But anyway, the point is: that story really was not HN material at all. The policies for HN clearly state to refrain from political discussions.
- kylemaxwell 15y agoDisagree, because the context and discussion very much related to people working in various subsets of tech industries. The problem of sexism in, say, IT services varies tremendously from that in, say, advertising.
- Tichy 15y agoThat's just a claim. Funny that it is triggered by a sexist ad. How would an advertising agency have dealt with the issue?
- DanBC 15y agoI agree that there were too many Geeklist articles, and that these ones deserved to be killed. But the fact that Geeklist is a tech company is a distraction. The real issue is how to deal with customers - even shouty sweary customers. "Don't get baited by your customers; especially over Twitter" is about the only useful thing coming from that thread. (Anything else, such as "don't use semi-naked women in advertising" is too political (ie, unlikely to lead to any useful interesting discussion) or too obvious to mention.) The ban on political articles on HN is needed. When I first started here I thought it'd be great to see the comments to political threads. Surely HN would be a place where people could put aside partisan politics and give thoughtful reasoned responses, backed by evidence, leading to rational discussion. Unfortunately not. Political threads pretty quickly collapse into bad-natured bickering.