5 ms·
I agree but the root cause isn't Google, it's advertising in all its forms, Google's ads just happen to be the most profitable ones. Kill advertising and the we
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
I agree but the root cause isn't Google, it's advertising in all its forms, Google's ads just happen to be the most profitable ones. Kill advertising and the web will be fixed automatically and permanently. Using uBlock Origin is everyone's duty towards a better web. It should come pre-installed in Firefox.
- firtoz 3y agoYou may be interested in trying Brave. Though that's using chromium and therefore connected to Google, kind of? Would be curious to hear the community's thoughts on this tbh.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI use both Brave and Firefox on mobile. I'm using Brave right now.
- _lvbh 3y agoIf it wasn’t for all the crypto bloat, Brave would be nice to use. Every time I install it, I got to spend a few minutes toggling all the settings and disabling everything. I use Librewolf not because of the fingerprinting stuff but because it just has sane defaults.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoCromite is the bee's knees on Android and Windows. I don't like/trust Brave for a number of reasons, and not just the crypto thing. Hijacking innocuous ads is another big one.
- aktenlage 3y agoBecause chrome-based Browsers are used by the large majority of web users, Google can (and does) easily change the web experience for its own profit, by adding, removing, or changing the functionality in chrome. Having the majority of users gives Google this power. As long as you use a chrome based browser, you are still part of that.
- mycologos 3y ago> Kill advertising and the web will be fixed automatically and permanently Is the implicit logic here "kill advertising and the web will be like what it was before widespread advertising: mostly for and by nerds"?
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThe implicit logic is to have a web for people who actually have something to say, not something to sell. If we end up with a small web by and for nerds, I'm okay with that too. Better to have that than this endless flood of negative value ad-funded SEO spam websites we have today.
- beej71 3y agoYes! Not just computer nerds, but nerds of all kinds. I want to read things by recipe nerds, not people trying to make money on ads. I want to read about cars from car nerds and home repair from home repair nerds and writing from writing nerds. I want to read things from people who share them for the pure joy of sharing them.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoCompletely agree.
- mycologos 3y agoI want that too! But things need to be easy to use if we want to hear from the people who are just X nerds and not X nerds and computer nerds. I think that's something ads enabled, because it made it valuable to just have a lot of people show up, which paid for all the work that went into making showing up easy.
- beej71 3y agoI think this should be a paid site that hosts, i.e. the nerds should pay a small amount per month to cover the ad-free hosting, like $5. Demand could drive that price down quite a bit.
- y42 3y agoWhile I agree on on "it isn't Google", I totally disagree on "it's advertising". No, that is too easy. There is a good reason to sell ads on your website to finance your project. This is totally okay. I'm happy to "consume" ads to finance a news site for example. I would even share some personal data to help the website to target the ads. Why not? Why should I rather give away "real money"? You cannot demand free stuff without giving something back. I mean, you can, maybe. But not every consumer can. And ads or online marketing in general, offers a good option to consume stuff that costs money. The problem is that the whole system somehow perverted over the time, because everyone was trying to make money. The advertising system got sick and everything around polluted. And the real root cause is... et voila, applause, applause... some capitalistic process or at least the current human economic behavior. The internet offers good ways to earn money, so people will exploit this feature.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> Why not? Because my attention belongs to me. It's not yours to sell to the highest advertising bidder. It's not currency to pay for services with. You're not entitled to it no matter how much free stuff you send me. My attention is part of my cognitive functions and it is literally inalienable. If you try to take it as payment by advertising to me, it will be self defense when I stop you. > Why should I rather give away "real money"? You shouldn't. That's why I block ads unconditionally. I know there's absolutely no reason for you or anyone else to leave money on the table by not advertising to people. I also know that paying you not to advertise to me just drives the value of my attention up and makes you want to advertise to me more. There's absolutely no situation in which advertisers would not want to advertise to me. The only possible course of action is to unconditionally and preemptively block them all. > You cannot demand free stuff without giving something back. Who's "demanding" anything? You're the one sending people free stuff while hoping they'll look at the ads. There's any number of things they could do, including discarding your ads. You're the one taking on that risk. When it inevitably doesn't work out, it's on you. Don't give away free stuff if you want people to pay for stuff. Have your server return HTTP 402 Payment Required instead of a free webpage. > The advertising system got sick and everything around polluted. No, advertising is inherently sick and unethical. Why would you ever listen to anyone trying to sell you anything? They have every incentive in the world to lie to you, manipulate you, overstate the pros and hide the cons. Anything an advertiser says should be doubted based purely on the unresolvable and inherent conflicts of interest associated with them. Advertising should be literally illegal. It's nothing but noise, audiovisual pollution. There are cities in my country that banned it and the results were great, I want to figure out how to propose similar laws in my own city.