10 ms·
On the Experience of Being Poor-Ish, for People Who Aren't
- 6510 3y agoThis was the best part. > it’s hard to wake up the next day and go “well, I’m sure that’s all in the past - let’s learn Java!”. Had I written something like this (it wouldn't be addressed at "rich" people) it would be entirely about this part of the game mechanic. (The author has kids, it makes the challenge even harder but is a fine excuse to proudly work yourself to death.) There are many gradients between throwing in the towel and uhh.. attacking the lion with your bare hands. When you've given up nothing is possible anymore. It's a horrific thing to see from up close. You don't even have to be actually poor for it. The opposite is also true, if you have the will, energy and motivation all you really need is a pair of pants. I've seen and done things that might blow your mind. Each hack gives a new surge of motivation.
- whatever1 3y agoBeing poor is devastating for personal development, and ultimately a huge hurdle towards achieving happiness. It is as bad as being ill/disabled.
- toenail 3y ago> It is as bad as being ill/disabled. No it is not, and I say that as somebody who lived below the poverty line for several years. Yes, it is devastating, but unless you live in some shithole country without any government help, it can be overcome. Disability and sickness (assuming chronic) can't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sublinear 3y agoI agree and I grew up very broke for much longer than that. Did I have to recover from and undo a lot of bullshit? Of course! The unfortunate part is how many people have the attitude of leaning on an external source of inspiration and always making excuses. I'm not saying it's easy, but there are too many for whom it never clicks that whatever circumstances they were born, this is their only shot at life, fair or not. Personal responsibility and constitution is far more powerful than the supposed forces at work making "free will an illusion". Give me a fucking break. Goddamn so many people on here need to grow the fuck up! How much worse it must have been for so many not so long ago.
- jddj 3y agoYour final paragraph is in conflict with the last sentence of your third paragraph. I think for all of these things to be congruent you need to be implying some kind of moral or personal weakness which doesn't come from the environment which occurs more frequently in poorer circumstances, which doesn't seem as likely as the causality being the other way around. Feel like I also need to qualify this with the obligatory I grew up poor and am not anymore and I think...
- sublinear 3y agoNah
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoI suspect that for whatever reason (genetics, or the particulars of the trauma they grew up with), it’s much easier for some to overcome their environmental disadvantages than others. They then assume that if they did it, everybody who doesn’t just has some moral failing. Probably some version of the typical-mind fallacy.
- jddj 3y agoAbsolutely. Also the law of large numbers. And despite the downvotes I don't want to take that away from OP, definitely what they did was difficult, commendable etc. Edit: removing a further unnecessary elaboration here because it feels like I'm just piling on. Initially the reception to my earlier comment skewed quite negative but it seems to have leveled out.
- sublinear 3y agoI'll bite. You're completely ignoring the effects of claims such as yours being a convenient excuse for those with low self esteem as well as poverty culture in general. You can make all the observations you want but correlation is still not causation. Your original comment before your edit made claims of someone in a given environment having certain behaviors while someone in a different environment not having those behaviors. I'm saying those behaviors are not caused by a mere "environment", but systemic and wholly caused by the broader culture we all live in and the opinions espoused by those who control it. Poor people are definitely attuned to that and mostly because they're vulnerable and living in a social desert. They don't know better beyond what's fed to them by the media and bad interpretations of "science" on social media and anywhere there are comments such as these. They spend so much of their time searching for and grasping at whatever seems relevant to their situation and overthink what they believe is beyond their horizons. The poor are still often ignored and excluded especially by those who think they're being inclusive.
- braelen7 3y ago[flagged]
- jl6 3y ago> And while the first apartment I showed you was in a relatively nice, livable part of town this one is in a more gun-fire prone area ominously referred to by locals as “the triangle”. Phoenix’s mostly gravel-and-concrete landscaping style cleans up nice (note the still-wet recently hosed concrete), but make no mistake: this isn’t the kind of apartment complex where hypodermic needles are exclusively owned by diabetics. This is the worst part. Being financially poor automatically lumps you in with the “morally poor”, which is devastating to empathy levels.
- hikingsimulator 3y agoDon't worry, the "morally poor" also exist in rich(er) circles. Wealth just buys the sheep's clothing.
- jl6 3y agoThe point is that a major barrier to a more charitable mindset is the association between low income and low morals. The usually-unspoken sentiment goes: “I’m not giving them anything, it will only be wasted on drugs and crime.” As the article points out, there is a huge and literal gap in the market for low-cost housing that adequately protects low-income households from drugs and crime, and from the association with drugs and crime. Those things aren’t a necessary consequence of poverty, and yet if your income is low, you have no choice but to live amongst them. The article uses the phrase “the murder-iest part of town”. Why do there have to be such places? Low income becomes associated with low morals, and the hearts of the rich harden: “I don’t want to give money to people in the murder-iest part of town”. The #1 thing we could do to address the hardship of poverty is to break the forced association between low income and low morals. And yes of course low morals exist in all strata of society, but their effect is particularly pernicious amongst the poor because the poor can’t afford to disassociate themselves from them.
- hermitcrab 3y agoThe film "Trading places" comes to mind. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0086465/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0086465/
- Jensson 3y agoSo the problem is that car dependence, zoning laws and lack of public healthcare means you have a lot of very expensive items that you can't do anything about without massively impacting your quality of life. So it is mostly an American problem, you can fix all of those via laws, many other countries has. In Europe housing scales down well, you can always pay less by living smaller or a bit further out from the city, you don't need a car and you don't need to pay that much for healthcare. Poor people still has it worse, but at least they have plenty of options.
- kozzz 3y agoGood luck living in rural Poland (anywhere outside 3 major cities) without a car. Same goes for most European countries
- smokel 3y agoIf you'd be slightly more precise in your wording, you'd see that the overloaded use of the word "you" results in some problems here. If by "you", you mean a poor individual living in the United States, then I guess your reasoning is absurd, because one individual cannot change the laws. If by "you", you mean all individuals lumped together as the people making up the United States, then the argument makes slightly more sense, but then still, they can't, because they can't seem to agree on how to divide all wealth properly. So, no, "you" cannot fix this via laws. You can hope for it to be fixed, you can lobby for it to be fixed, you can pray for it, even go to war for it, but I don't think it's as easy as you make it seem. Moving to Europe might be an option, but even that is not an option for most people outside of Europe, mostly thanks to the laws that "we" put in place to stay rich.
- Jensson 3y ago> by "you", you mean a poor individual living in the United States That is a very uncharitable interpretation, not sure why you would read it like that. "You" can refer to governments or countries in general and not just individuals. And that was the entire argument of your post, please don't make strawmans like that.
- smokel 3y agoI'd be interested to hear from some of the more well-off people here: what would be a good approach to bridge the gap between the poor and the rich? Someone in this thread proposed changing the law, which seems to be a bit hard. The 80,000 hours crew suggests that a privileged individual must change society by their own ideas, which seems a bit risky (and using big money to do so seems debatable at best). Some Christians try to help a few poor people in their vicinity, often without regard for the bigger picture, which might be valid, but that possibly requires some deity to believe in. What do you people typically do to help?
- Jensson 3y ago> Someone in this thread proposed changing the law, which seems to be a bit hard There isn't much else you can do though. More fundamentally, the reason the laws doesn't adapt to the poor here is the implementation of democracy, if politicians has to cater to poor people or get voted out then you start to see more laws and regulations to support this group.
- sublinear 3y ago> what would be a good approach to bridge the gap between the poor and the rich? I may be speaking out of turn as I am not "rich", but I have known a few people who would be considered the "part of the 1%". Let them develop communication skills with people that are their intellectual, but not necessarily social, peers. Broad social appeal is where the opportunities are. Take poor people out of their element and be accepting of their awkwardness. Question their assumptions in a non-threatening environment and let them grow. Let them mix with people who are not so easily offended, nor unhappy. Many of the rich aren't so different and think about the same topics all the time, yet often just have a different and more constructive perspective.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 3y agoFrom my continental European perspective, talking about the US-centric variation of the problem described in the article (the problem certainly exists everywhere, but it comes in surprisingly different shapes): I don't think it's possible, not without dismantling the ideological base of that "American dream" which claims that everybody can make it. That's super nice and positive on the bright side, but unfortunately it's impossible to separate from its implication "everybody who did not make it has nobody to blame but themselves". On the other hand, even within that framework, I think that the American mindset could be better, ask more "whom did you trick to get that success", ask a little more how a fortune was made instead of blindly celebrating each and every success until proven guilty of breaking the law. But this has very little to do with what the article is about, perhaps a tiny connection could be constructed with the housing chapter but even that would be a rather weak link.
- happytiger 3y agoA ~25 thousand dollar soft shell tent with no bathroom. Ok. I’m sure there’s a market for this but there are much better alternatives that have lower or equivalent cost.
- sethammons 3y agoWrong thread
- red_admiral 3y agoBut strangely appropriate!
- happytiger 3y agoHa! Truth. But how odd. I’m not at all sure how that happened. :(
- happytiger 3y agoYeah, I messed up somehow. But it is such social commentary. 25k tents being deployed around national parks targeting wealthy travelers so people can get rich is such a social commentary when we have (officially) 582,000 Americans homeless and nobody seems to be “able to find a solution” — it seems oddly prescient.
- swe_dima 3y agoI am extremely grateful to my parents who made me feel "well off" despite growing up in the 90' Russia. Only when I got older I found out that often times they didn't have enough money to buy food. Explains the constant soup from potatoes :-) Good education can do wonders for you though, in my personal experience. Both me and many of my friends went to one of the best schools in the city by the virtue of living next to it. We started learning programming at 12 yo. Now most of my peers who studied there, both from poor and rich families, live abroad having managed to get jobs at good companies.
- 4death4 3y agoThis was a pretty engaging read. I don’t want to knock this person’s experience, but 30K for a family of four is just… not a lot. Which was the point of the article of course, but, it seems possible to earn more. That’s less than $15 an hour of full time work. Does his wife work? If not, why? Of course, there are families who need to scrape by on 30K out of necessity, even in expensive metro areas like NYC, so again, not discounting that. But I’m curious about how this individual person, who is clearly articulate and well spoken, with a wife that is presumably the same given the company she keeps, can only manage $15 an hour between him and his wife.
- sethammons 3y agoThey have two kids. Day care costs ~$800/mo per kid, so that ain't happening. Without a friend or family network, childcare is a juggling act. Maybe they opted for one to stay home. Maybe one can wait tables at night at less than $8/hr and pray for tips. A second car is likely needed. My wife and I did this. Quick kid hand off as I walked in the door and she walked out (or I could pick up kids from her work if I was late). We saw each other for under 10 minutes a day.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoIt is really easy to get stuck in retail or foodservice, and these jobs aren't known for paying a lot. Children need childcare. This has a major impact on your finances if you are poor. You might need to have a reduced availability and might not find full time - or any - work because of it. If your child is prone to being sick and you make less money, it becomes easier to lose your job when you have to stay home with them. And childcare is expensive: I've known plenty of folks that stayed home or have worked little simply because they didn't actually make money by working, once they factored in child care and transportation costs. And that's not even getting into something mentioned in the article: Sometimes, when you make more, you are actually worse off. People refuse full time hours, raises, and promotions because the increased pay won't cover the government help they'll lose, let alone make them better off. Being articulate and well spoken doesn't really grant you anything when you are working bad jobs (and many 'decent), depending on the job. I worked a couple of days in a food factory back in the late 90's. It was barely over minimum wage. Being articulate didn't matter: You just needed to do the work fast enough and follow the health guidelines fast enough. Oh, and work mandatory OT on short notice.
- 16b03ef75 3y ago> But “just the skill without an associated degree” means this is a slog Deeply intimate with this one. I live in an area completely dependent on defense contracting. I dropped out of my degree program years ago, but have an aerospace engineer friend who I handle software for if a project requires it. Had the experience of running some flight tests this summer; the dinner conversation with the outside client, other consultants about who I am and what I do is soul crushing. Yeah, I took a week off my landscaping job to do this, will go right back to working it when your project is done.
- notimer 3y agoWhy can’t you continue your degree program or transfer the existing credits if this is a bottleneck?
- CraigJPerry 3y agoThere's a social science experiment where some folks are asked a question along the lines of "could you land a jumbo jet airplane while an experienced pilot talks you through the process via the radio?" If they ask 100 folks, they'll get something like 101 responses of "HELL YEAH!" but then when they pop people in a simulator to try it, no-one makes it out alive. I've often wondered if i could make it out alive if i had to start over from scratch. Keeping the life skills and knowledge i have today, but with one exception - NOT being allowed to rely solely on my programming or sysadmin skills because that feels like cheating by making it too easy to succeed. So a job or entrepreneurial venture, in a different field, starting from nothing and build up. Could i make it out alive? My answer is always yes. Like i have zero doubt. The only ways i can doubt myself in this thought experiment are if i do something really extreme like start off in a remote African village or imagine starting with a disability of some sort. In those cases, i can see a possibility of failure but in just about any other starting scenario, i jump straight to seeing how i would deal with the obvious problems that would happen along the way like having my stuff repeatedly stolen / trashed, being dragged into fights etc. etc. Can't shake this niggling feeling that it's hubris. Am i Mr 102 full of smiles who high 5's everyone as he triumphantly strides out of that simulator? Or am i just on the wrong side of Dunning Kruger?
- Jensson 3y ago> Could i make it out alive? If you mean literally, absolutely yes. Even Palestine has a life expectancy of 73 years, unless you start doing heavy crime or are very unlucky you will survive until you get old.
- CraigJPerry 3y agoI think it has to be your own interpretation of alive. If you're starting today surrounded by a loving family, in good health, enjoying relative comfort but you end the thought experiment as a comfortably solvent 80 year old in an apartment but with no friends or family, does that count as making it out alive? That has to be for you to decide.
- 3y ago
- mpitt 3y ago(2021)
- zubairq 3y agoGreat article! Having been poor for most of my life (means living month to month for over a decade) I often hear people who have access to money , wealth, or resources say that “money doesn’t matter”. Always makes me laugh.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoOr to paraphrase a pretty well known Twitter post, money won't buy you happiness, but it's more comfortable to cry in a Mercedes.
- hermitcrab 3y agoThe person that wrote this article is a good writer. I wonder he couldn't use this skill to get a better paying job? Maybe as a technical writer? There are loads of software and hardware products that need documentation, but programmers and engineers generally hate writing documentation and aren't good at it. And many people who can write have no technical chops. Maybe it is something he could start doing 'on the side' if he has the spare capacity? Perhaps some on HN could start him off with a small side job?
- pluto_modadic 3y agoor society as a whole should pay well for writers of all subjects, not just FAANG ones ;)
- hermitcrab 3y agoDo you want your taxes to subsidize poetry? I don't.
- saagarjha 3y agoI do, and so do most people. This is why we have public spending for the arts :)
- trelane 3y agoThere's no maximum tax. You're free to send the government extra money.
- saagarjha 3y agoThe whole point of taxes is that you don't get to pick and choose the parts you like or use. If you don't like where the dollars are going, go vote–although I would personally say that my taxes have many worse places they are going that you might be interested in before we get to any arts projects.
- Roark66 3y agoIt's interesting how different this is from my perspective growing up in a family that was quite poor for the most of the late 80s and early 90s in just-became-capitalist Poland. Some things were exactly as described: Cars and constant worry about repairs, but my dad was pretty good at repairs so despite all our cars being 20+ years old (and not Mercedes, but more like a Fiat 125p) we were OK with transport. Also living in a medium sized city public transport was always good. Food - The author mentioned eating lots of rice, for us it was potatoes. I had a family member in Germany, so I still remember the first orange I ever are (from a Christmas gift pack from that aunt in Germany). Sweets like chocolate-from that same pack) were were usually divided into single squares and I would get one a day until it lasted. Then there were things that differed a lot: Travel&Holidays: When I was 10 we went for "holidays" in Germany in the summer (holidays in quotes, because I had holidays while my parents worked on some farm). At the time I never had allowance etc, but I'd get money from extended family members for various holidays, birthdays in years prior. I saved most of it for years. When we went to Germany I felt pretty rich as after exchange it amounted to 20 marks (about 40 EUR today I guess) so I could buy myself a really nice toy. Yes we drove our 20 year old fiat 125p for 18h all the way and yes it did break down once mid way... Otherwise travel&holidays meant living with my grandma in the countryside during the summer when the school was off. Accommodation : My parents did get a flat back in the communist system after waiting 8 years for it living in shared accommodation (with 2 kids). So we had it pretty good. Also I was pretty shocked when I read this: >How many times have they turned off your water?”. Back then (and now I think) it was illegal to disconnect essential services like water without an eviction order. There were times when we didn't pay for amenities for 10 months and we ate mostly potatoes(I still consider a full plate of fries by themselves a proper dinner - you needed oil too and lots of it so it was quite a luxury) and we were never disconnected from water/heat, but that might have been a local thing to my housing association. Safety: There was never a risk of getting shot, the closest was getting blown up by some explosives left in the ground (as there was this abandoned military base nearby). Crime was getting your fruit stolen on a tiny plot of land in the "community gardens" or getting punched in the face by some drunk. Thieves would never steal potatoes from the ground, but everyone kept their preserves and potatoes in cellars (under an apartment building, every flat would have it's own cellar) and these were frequently stolen. Heathcare: we had access to national healthcare for most of the time(when my dad was unemployed he was registered as "looking for work" so the state paid for it), but the quality of it really varies (to say the least). For example dental work - if you want your teeth pulled out in emergency, yes national heath care in 90s Poland is great for that. If you want cosmetic work done? Maybe you will wait 12 months, and then after it's done it will fall apart after a week... Typically you didn't do cosmetic work if you couldn't afford to go private. Really life threatening stuff was handled fairly well (although 2 of my grandparents died as a result of medical mistakes - specifically one getting normal hospital food after waking up from a gastric surgery, the other going in for gall stone removal and getting pneumonia there as they'd just leave the windows open for hours on end forgetting to close them in winter). So here we go, this is how being mid-level-poor looked like in Poland in the 90s. Why mid-level? Well, because we always had cars, we never went hungry, and after an entire extended family chipped in I did manage to get a computer I wanted (a commodore 64) when I was 12 so I'm not even sure it really classes as being that poor. At the time unemployment was 40% at the worst of it many people had it much worse, but I guess my parents always had higher aspirations so they felt pretty bad not being able to afferd better food, or not paying amenities for months and months wondering if their electricity will get turned off today (electric is not considered essentially).
- xyzelement 3y agoI grew up in a basically 100% immigrant neighborhood in Brooklyn which was basically like a science experiment: throw in a bunch of people, start them at zero in terms of money, connections, language, etc and see what happens. In retrospect the big dividing line is kids from cultures that value education and long term thinking and ones that don’t. In the former category, the Asian and Eastern European Jewish parents took their little income and understanding of the system to make sure their kids studied their assess off, saved for emergency and eventual investment, etc. consequentially many of those kids are now in the 1% or close. Kids from countries with less focus on education didn’t do this with regularity and their kids are by and large nowhere near the top today. Despite in the early 1990s being on an identical starting line. I mention this because high empathy leads us to assume that poverty locks people into bad choices. The Asian parent example shows the opposite - the poorer you are the more your choices really matter - you only have a few dollars and a few hours and how you spend them really matters. Obviously what I wrote also depends on the degree of opportunity that exists around you. The US is still a place where you can expect to alter your trajectory if you single-mindedly focus on it. The real challenge is how to give that focus to begin with. Eg immigrants from Asia etc came here with that value system and drive already and this achieved amazing outcomes. If you don’t have that culture and drive, how do you bootstrap it? I don’t have the answer.
- pythonic_hell 3y agoYou make an interesting case, but are you controlling for education level or profession of the parents before they immigrated to the US? It wasn’t uncommon in the 80s-90s to meet an Eastern European, Asian or Jewish immigrant who came from a STEM background but for a variety of reasons couldn’t work in their field once they moved to the US so they worked as store clerks or taxi drivers. Perhaps the differences your talking about isn’t cultural but rather dependent on what economic and education class the immigrant parents came from. To add to this; See this article & paper > https://news.ku.edu/2020/06/18/study-shows-african-immigrants-do-well-despite-differences-among-them https://news.ku.edu/2020/06/18/study-shows-african-immigrant... > https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/19376812.2020.1744455 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/19376812.2020.17... > The paper contrasts Nigerian newcomers with those from Somalia, whose work ethic is similarly strong, but whose lack of education hurts their employment prospects here. > The authors wrote: “Overall, African-born immigrants aged 16 and over have a higher rate of employment (69.2%) relative to the foreign-born population (63.1%) and the general US population (59.9%).” The study also notes significant differences between Nigerian immigrants, who mostly come from that country’s south, and Somalis. For one thing, with its history of British colonization, many more Nigerians speak English upon arrival in the U.S. than do Somalis. That makes the Nigerians’ transition easier in almost every respect. “For the Nigerian-born immigrants, the proportion that possesses at least a bachelor's degree is 60.5%,” Chikanda said. “But when we look at the Somali-born population ... that's about 15%.”
- resolutebat 3y agoThe sequel: On Being Rich-ish: Lessons I learned becoming suddenly middle-class https://www.residentcontrarian.com/p/on-being-rich-ish-lessons-i-learned https://www.residentcontrarian.com/p/on-being-rich-ish-lesso...
- amluto 3y ago> But now he was letting us know about it at 3 am. I got out of bed, drove him to urgent care, picked up some drugs and painkillers, and it was handled. Wow, in that particular respect he lives in relative paradise. On the San Francisco peninsula, this service does not exist, and as far as I’m aware no level of wealth short of hiring a private doctor will make it appear. There are emergency rooms (some of which are fairly nice as such things go), and San Jose, San Francisco and Oakland appear to have a small number of genuine urgent care clinics. Otherwise… nothing. Going to the ER for an ear infection is not usually a go-in-and-quickly-handle-it experience. (Also, wow, the housing in the OP looks awesome at the price point.)
- pflenker 3y agoOne thing I didn’t find adequately reflected in this article is how expensive it is being poor. If you can’t afford the more expensive, but more durable version of X, where X is something you really need, means that over time you will spend much more on this than you would have if you could have afforded the more durable option. At one part of my life I could only afford the cheapest pair of shoes for 10€, and since it was the only pair I owned I needed to buy a new pair every few months. Of course, I quickly paid more on shoes than I would have if I’d been able to afford one good pair of shoes.
- f1shy 3y agoSo much this. Also having money means you can buy in advance, or in quantities -important for a relatively big family-, also have a car, for example, and can go further to get better deals in X.
- pvik 3y agoPopularized as the "Boots" theory of socioeconomic unfairness by Sir Terry Pratchett https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoI always assume the bottom 10% in any market is going to be garbage, whether it's shoes, jeans, food or anything else. Of course knowing that doesn't help if you are really destitute.
- badpun 3y agoLots of people make the same assumption, and companies take advantage of that. E.g. if they want you to buy a bottle of wine at $10 a bottle, they'll place plenty of $10 bottles on the shelves, as well as some $7 bottles, with the assumption that you'll regard them as bottom of the barrel crap.
- Podgajski 3y agoI am on disability. I had to live in a van after COVID hit because I got kicked out of my apartment because they were afraid of me giving them COVID and rental prices became insane and I had no money for first, last and deposit. Yeah, many places want three months rent up front to move in. The one thing I appreciate RESIDENT CONTRARIAN explaining is about the housing situation. People would always point to rentals that cost $800 a month and say "Why don't you live there?" Then I take them on a tour and they see why I choose not to move in. I am sorry for the suffering that many will go through if this happens, but the only thing I have to look forward to is an economic recession in the hope that it will lower the barrier to entry for housing. So for now I just pretend I am renting my van for $600 a month and I throw that money into it for upkeep. I am just grateful I have no drug issues or family to worry about.
- em-bee 3y agoThen I take them on a tour and they see why I choose not to move in. i am fully with you, but not being familiar with your specific circumstances i am still curious what you tell people. would you mind sharing some examples?
- Podgajski 3y agoI tell them that I have a stress induced brain diseases and living there would put me closer to death.
- em-bee 3y agosorry, i meant a description of the living area and examples of things that make it difficult or impossible to live there. while i have lived in the US i have never been to areas that one is being told to avoid (the most dangerous area i have lived in for a short time was somewhere near downtown DC), and in most other countries that i have been to such neighborhoods are inconceivable. heck even slums in africa appear safer compared to some gunshot prone areas in the US
- tsss 3y agoAs a German this article was particularly illuminating how much better Americans live. At $50k the "reasonable $1250 apartment" isn't 30% of my pay, it is HALF of my net income. A "very small" apartment in Germany isn't 900 sqft, more like 400 sqft or less. I can tell you in all my life of countless apartment inspections I've never seen one with a shared pool and this looks pretty modern, probably comes with a private parking space as well. My apartment building is from 1960 and has no walls that are square.
- inglor_cz 3y agoExpect for a few very crowded megacities, Americans have a lot more physical space to expand into. Hence the huge lots and homes. Western Europe is a lot more crowded, with the extremes (like SE England) comparable to Bangladesh in population density. The American excess of space has some negatives, too, like endless sprawl and long commutes.