5 ms·
What's the point of blocking ads when they're already not present? Or are you saying that we should block ads and refuse to pay? How is that sustainable in the
by gruez 3y ago
What's the point of blocking ads when they're already not present? Or are you saying that we should block ads and refuse to pay? How is that sustainable in the long term? If you're against ads, shouldn't you support monetization models that don't involve ads?
- jona-f 3y agoWe treat google how they treat us, as exploitive as possible.
- mvdtnz 3y agoYou're just rationalising. You know it's not a defensible position.
- Spivak 3y agoSure it is, you're not even involved in the transaction. Just because someone pays Google to show an ad doesn't mean you have to look at it. USPS is funded by ads going through the mail and I throw them straight in the trash without remorse. I bet you do too. Bet you don't feel guilt about going to the bathroom or fast-forwarding your DVR during commercials either. Ad space is sold on the possibility that someone will see it and you don't owe anyone valuable ad real-estate. It's wild how many people unironically think "drink verification can" is in any way acceptable.
- gruez 3y ago> Just because someone pays Google to show an ad doesn't mean you have to look at it Just because someone has an internet connection doesn't mean google has to serve them videos, either.
- Spivak 3y agoSuch is their prerogative. You'll notice that nowhere are people saying "Google should have to give you a switch to turn off ads for free." You act like that's a gotcha when "I owe you nothing, you owe me nothing" is the state I'm arguing for.
- frumper 3y agoI’m confused. Google doesn’t serve every internet connection videos. The serve people asking for videos.
- mvdtnz 3y agoAt no point did I suggest people should be forced to view ads.
- rerdavies 3y agoI can't actually remember the last time I got mail-mail.
- unshavedyak 3y agoI think it's somewhat defendable when youtube doesn't give you an option to pay for what you'd be "stealing". Overall i agree with you, but lets not pretend that Youtube doesn't feel exploitative in the corporate behavior here. Especially considering the data they're stealing from me, harvesting and selling, etc. Ie show me the ads i'm missing, and let me pay for the view. It would be what, $3|5|7/m or w/e in value? Instead they're trying to strongarm you into an upcharge of $14/m for additional services. Show me the data they're harvesting from my viewing patterns and the added revenue they're getting from that. Tie that into my "cost" each month and reducing how much i owe. But of course they won't do that. Because this isn't an exchange. This isn't a service we're paying for, it's a data harvest where they want to have their cake and eat it too. This is scummy in the same way that my music software, Spotify, is trying to expand revenue streams and shoving more crap (podcasts, audio books, etc) down my throat. If Youtube isn't going to try and play fair then i'd rather leave (and will) than pay them.
- gruez 3y ago>I think it's somewhat defendable when youtube doesn't give you an option to pay for what you'd be "stealing". https://www.youtube.com/premium https://www.youtube.com/premium
- kemayo 3y agoNot the person you're responding to, but from how they phrased it I suspect they'd be annoyed that they're having to pay for YouTube Music as part of Premium.
- unshavedyak 3y agoExactly. I want to pay for what i'm supposed to be paying for. Not subscribe to extra services i don't use.
- throw_nbvc1234 3y agoYou're not just paying Youtube/Google for the ad, you're paying the content creators as well. You can always buy the music directly from artists if you don't like Spotify's revenue model. Or ditch Spotify and use the free Youtube Music subscription you get with premium, maybe combined it'd be worth the $14 to you.
- xuhu 3y agoIt sure is. I'm still watching their ads on every other site, but youtube ads for gambling and soda that interrupt while I'm watching someone talk about Bezier curves ? Na-ah.
- gruez 3y agoAll this performative righteousness is only going to end up hurting your cause in the long term. If a major site offers an ad-free option, and people refuse to take it, what does it tell the executives? What does it tell other publishers who are considering their monetization options? How do you think a business should respond to users that neither refuse to watch ads nor pay, can't be bargained with (see above), but nonetheless think they should be entitled to service? Companies aren't owed a viable business model, but consumers aren't owed a free service either.
- LtWorf 3y agoThey still mine your data…
- frumper 3y agoAre you complaining about ads or data? The only way to avoid giving them data is to not use them, which also lets you avoid their ads and you don’t need a subscription. Simple solution.
- bsaul 3y agothe amount of ads on youtube has grown exponentially and i highly doubt this was because of profitability issues.
- Wildliferanger 3y agoThe problem is higher than zero intrest rates the free money dried up where before all the platforms were chasing infinte growth and free money meant they could run deficts as long as they grew they now need to make a profit now that debt costs money plus investor cash got sucked away to Bonds, CDs, and money market accounts giving a safe 5-7%. This is why every service went to shit at the same time in the past year.
- missedthecue 3y agoIn a hypothetical world without adblockers, wouldn't YouTube need to show a lower amount of ads per person to make the same amount of revenue?
- mfru 3y agoi love paying for nebula and support my favorite creators there and blocking everything else on youtube
- heavyset_go 3y agoI don't care if Google is sustainable in the long term or not, just like they don't care if they serve me malicious content and malware via their ad networks, or take money, and show me ads, from groups that want people like me dead.
- LtWorf 3y agoIn my area they started to put ads to meet hot russian women in youtube. I reported and they said it's supposed to stay there.
- heavyset_go 3y agoWe're back to 2002-style ads about meeting hot singles in your town, where you can get free "natural" Viagra, and content taken directly from weird political chain letters that are written by people who, while barely literate, are loud and opinionated.
- hkt 3y agoMaybe we don't want the business models of data hoarding multibillion dollar corporations to be sustainable. Maybe there are good alternatives that don't rely so much on exploitative practices. Just a thought.
- acdha 3y agoThose are great reasons not to use YouTube. If you’re worried about data mining, your ad blocker has no effect there – you have to stop using YouTube if that bothers you.
- NotSuspicious 3y agoWhat if I considered it a moral imperative to financially damage FAANG companies in any way I can? What if I was fine paying money each month as long as it went towards harming Youtube?
- acdha 3y agoHow do you think that’s relevant to the question of data mining?
- hkt 3y agoOr use it in a way that doesn't give up your data quite so easily. I recommend Minitube for Linux desktop and NewPipe for android.
- acdha 3y agoIt’s wishful thinking to hope that they can’t mine that. If you connect to a Google server, they’re analyzing your activity. Not running their JavaScript disrupts ads but they still get information about what type of videos you like, when and where you watch them, and what kind of devices you use.
- hkt 3y agoTrue enough. I've thought before it'd be good to cache and mirror YouTube videos as they're watched, and then provide them through IPFS with an index that's shipped around so people can pre-filter their searches and page hits against that index first. Lots of work, obviously. More than I have time for, alas. But I'm confident that'll happen eventually.