5 ms·
What alternative do you propose? The politicians are elected representatives of and by the people.
by layer8 3y ago
What alternative do you propose? The politicians are elected representatives of and by the people.
- spencerflem 3y agoTake the money out of politics as much as possible and there will be less incentive for politicians to sell out their people
- layer8 3y agoWhat do you mean by that? There’s already anti-corruption laws, and corruption is actually being prosecuted. To have less incentives, you’d actually have to pay politicians more, which would constitute putting more money into politics.
- raincom 3y agoAnti-corruption laws don't deal with collusions much, as there is no tangible proof of "pay for play" in such situations. Look at the US Senator Menedez case of late: he and his wife are stupid to accept cash, gold bars, Benz cars, etc. Sophisticated players in the beltway don't accept such "play for cash", because these colluders trust each other beyond the term limits.
- ekianjo 3y ago> and corruption is actually being prosecuted. In which world do you live?
- mcpackieh 3y ago> To have less incentives, you’d actually have to pay politicians more This theory presumes that when people have more money, their desire to have even more money diminishes. This presumption is not true. (It might be somewhat true for common sorts of people who find pleasure in simple things and only want enough money to satisfy their basic material needs (food, shelter, medical care). But it's definitely not true when you're talking about people with high levels of ambition, which includes virtually all politicians.)
- spencerflem 3y agoOh, yea I'm for paying politicians directly. Meant more like, the money you need to run a campaign
- logicchains 3y agoSomething like "There are only X laws allowed. Every time you want to add a new law and already have X laws, you must remove one existing law". Then we'd get laws covering the most important things without a bunch of bureaucracy on top of that.
- layer8 3y agoHow do you define “number of laws”? Laws usually consist of many individual rules, and one can just make the law “bigger” to reduce the nominal number of laws without actually reducing the contents. In addition, I don’t see how this would cause the laws to become more in the interest of the citizens than of the legislators.
- logicchains 3y ago>How do you define “number of laws” It's not an easy thing to do but that doesn't mean it couldn't be done. Maybe something like defining it as a limit on the total sum amount of text in all laws? A limit on the amount of new laws that could be passed would make it much easier for citizens to keep up with the proposed changes and oppose any they disagreed with; they couldn't be ddossed by the legislators.
- layer8 3y agoCertain details (procedural and technical specifications) of laws are often relegated to secondary texts. This would just start a game of how to encode the desired legislation so that it still nominally fits the rules (law golfing instead of code golfing). The whole approach is a fool’s errand, IMO, and would just make the legislation even more inscrutable for the layperson.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoThat's a brilliant game mechanic. I think for reality we should still remove power out of politicians
- madacol 3y ago
- hanniabu 3y agoIf a law doesn't pass, the contents can't be brought up in a new law for a minimum of 5 years.
- layer8 3y agoHow do you define that? It’s never exactly the same contents, usually has substantial changes in the approach.
- pca006132 3y agoSo now malicious users can give bad proposals, get it rejected, and block other potentially good proposals for 5 years? Sounds like a good DoS scheme.
- _jal 3y agoPlease explain how you would forbid these from being serially brought without allowing bad actors to disrupt normal legislative business. "No abortion after 49 days." "No abortion after 50 days." "No hospital shall be used for abortions." "Doctors cannot perform abortions."
- t0bia_s 3y agoEurpean Commison is not elected by citizens of EU. They are nominated by the European Council and confirmed by the European Parliament. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Commission https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Commission Similar system is for WHO. They are not elected organisations, yet shape our laws. This bother quite a lot of people and don't bring a trust in system.
- misnome 3y agoNeither are government cabinets, ambassadors or generals.
- hannofcart 3y agoAssuming that you're taking about liberal democracies, ambassadors and generals don't pass laws that the rest of us have to abide by. The government cabinet has some more democratic legitimacy in so far as that they generally comprise of elected representatives. So your statement is a non-sequitur.
- growse 3y agoIn the UK, there's no requirement that the cabinet is formed of elected representatives. Government ministers are often Lords. Besides, even if the defense secretary is an MP, he wasn't elected on a platform of national security by the population. So if there's a non sequitur anywhere, it's in application of any democratic legitimacy to the job of holding a significant cabinet post by winning the votes of a few ten thousand people for commons seat.
- hannofcart 3y agoSure, but the UK cabinet draws its power from the fact that it explicitly has support of a majority of the directly elected members of Parliament. When it's established that they don't, they end up getting ousted (as happens with no confidence motions).
- 3y ago
- jokethrowaway 3y agoWhat about every service owned by the government becomes private and offered by private companies and we remove the goverment completely? I'd kill to see The Machinery of Freedom by D. Friedman in real life
- Tagbert 3y agothen you have everything run by the equivalent of insurance companies. That would be much worse. Companies are not inherently more responsive or even more efficient.
- Gud 3y agoSwiss style direct and decentralized democracy. https://www.eda.admin.ch/aboutswitzerland/en/home/politik-geschichte/politisches-system.html https://www.eda.admin.ch/aboutswitzerland/en/home/politik-ge... "Switzerland is governed under a federal system at three levels: the Confederation, the cantons and the communes. Thanks to direct democracy, citizens can have their say directly on decisions at all political levels. This wide range of opportunities for democratic participation plays a vital role in a country as geographically, culturally and linguistically varied as Switzerland."