4 ms·
Internet-induced fear culture (or: Why Girls Around Me isn’t the problem)
- secoif 15y agoIsn't this article doing the exact fear mongering it's accusing technology of doing? And ironically, via technology.
- vrotaru 15y agoWell, no. The original article was more like a book about the danger of books. This one is like a book about mostly-hamrlessness of books and more.
- dfxm12 15y agoThe author claims the Internet is the biggest enemy in this "fear induced culture", due to its ease of spreading FUD. People have been dealing with sensational headlines for a good while now. However, it may or may not be apparent when you buy your first smartphone that it is broadcasting your location along with all of your social networking posts. The real enemies here are insecure defaults & lack of education around how & why to control personal information online.
- bradleyland 15y ago> The real enemies here are insecure defaults & lack of education around how & why to control personal information online. The real enemy here is the rapist. Among the measures that a person can take to avoid being the victim of a crime, not checking in on social media sites is pretty low. The fact is that crime is generally very low tech. Cyber-rapists are exceedingly rare. If you're going to opt out because you fear this type of threat, you might as well not leave your underground bunker.
- throwaway64 15y agoYou are entirely missing the point when you start focusing on "cyber rapists" or girls, or anything like that. The point is that ANYONE can potentially pull and track this information and combine it with other data sources without your permission or knowledge. Months, years, or even decades from now, with increasingly better analysis techniques. That could be a rapist, that could be an abusive government, that could be your ex boyfriend/girlfriend, that could be your employers checking if you were at the bar last night, it could even be your health insurance making sure you went to the gym yesterday, or else they raise your premium. It gets even scarier when you have companies like say credit agencies tracking where you went and who you were closest to, and determining your "risk score" for various things like loans and jobs, etc. The point is there is a massive potential for abuse here that most people have absolutely no idea about. Its simply startling to me that so many here work day in, day out on computers, yet totally fail to realize the power of data analytics when you feed in massive amounts of data. The most disturbing point of all in this shit, is when you are refused a job, or a loan, or medical insurance, you wont ever know why, you will simply know you made the numbers go down for some reason, and people will become deathly afraid of that, so will take fewer risks in their life, and generally lead a very closely guarded, boring existence.
- bradleyland 15y ago> The point is that ANYONE can potentially pull and track this information and combine it with other data sources without your permission or knowledge. That point is not lost on me, but that's not the issue I was rebutting. That's not why Girls Around Me was pulled. That's not the source of fear that all the negative press was playing on. If anything, it's yet another sideshow that distracts from the greater issue. The Girls Around Me blow-up wasn't subtle. It was very straight forward, and blown out of proportion, IMO. It won't do anything to draw attention to the far more subtle issues of implicitly wide-open online privacy standards.
- Spearchucker 15y agoWhat is the probability of that happening to any individual? And what's the impact? At a guess I'd say the impact can be high. The probability is probably quite low. If exposure = probability x impact, then exposure is (guessing) low to medium.
- thwarted 15y agoCyber-rapist reminds me of A Rape in Cyberspace[1], from 1993. Which, 20 years later, seems much tamer in comparison to mobile anonymous physical stalking apps. At least back then, your stalker had to sit in front of their computer. Now we recognize that as something closer to trolling. [1] http://www.juliandibbell.com/articles/a-rape-in-cyberspace/ http://www.juliandibbell.com/articles/a-rape-in-cyberspace/
- mrsebastian 15y agoThere's definitely a lot to be said for insecure defaults -- and especially a lack of education. It's easy to over exaggerate this threat though, in my opinion. Yes, Girls Around Me is really creepy, but will anyone actually get hurt because of it? Unlikely, I think. It's important to bear in mind the positive aspects of "over" sharing information, too. Connecting with old friends. Making new business acquaintances. Scholars investigating the social graph to draw interesting conclusions. Also, if data was private by default, who knows if Facebook's business model (advertising) would even be tenable. Then it becomes a question of whether we want a Facebook, warts and all, or no Facebook at all. (I wonder if anyone's actually studied the value of Facebook. Would be a pretty mammoth undertaking.)
- silentscope 15y ago"These reports don’t for one minute think that this is just a fun app — an app that most people will run once, laugh heartily (or a little nervously), and then never look at it again." For most people the sentence above is true. But I don't think anyone's surprised to hear that there are dangerous people in the world. Yep, they exist and they can hurt people--they HAVE hurt people. Closing your eyes to something doesn't make it disappear, just harder to see. We're not worried about "cyber rapists" because there are no such thing as a "cyber rapists". Rape happens in the real world. This app won't change nightlife into a horrible dangerous place--but it doesn't make the world a better place either. This is the dark side of technology because it makes the world cheaper, less incredible. It's alienating and scary and makes people more cautious. It does society a disservice--the only people it does a service for are the people who's motives are questionable. I'm not saying you don't have a point. You do. We can discuss this without being so up-in-arms about it. But one extreme is just as bad as the other. When the counterpoint bar is set at 'We'll look at it then just delete it,' I think we can agree that this app is a problem. The question is how bad is it?
- georgieporgie 15y agothere are no such thing as a "cyber rapists". Rape happens in the real world You're being obtuse.
- DanBC 15y agoMany people were being raped before this app appeared. Many people will be raped after this app, but none of those will have any connect to this app. Most women who are raped are raped by someone who knows them. There are serious problems with privacy settings of various websites, and this app is a nifty creepy way to highlight those problems. But suggesting it is "rapetastic" is just hyperbole and unhelpful.
- silentscope 15y agoYou're right. But as a society, it's up to us to make the world a better place, not excuse it for what it is. I have no idea what happens "mostly" with rape, nor would I use it as a reason why this app isn't bad. There are many problems with online privacy, and I partially blame every app that takes part. The app isn't "rapetastic." It's not inciting violence, it doesn't have a google maps "getaway" feature. It just makes the world more dangerous at worst and more mediocre at best. In cases such as this, I err on the side of more criticism, not less. But that's just me...
- jerf 15y agoRape is the headline-grabbing problem, but the real problem is a far more mundane loss of privacy. Do you really want everybody in all your social circles to know exactly where you're partying Friday nights, and exactly whose house you actually ended up sleeping at? Or if you have no problem with that, insert your choice of thing you don't really care to broadcast to everybody. A nontrivial part of the reason why I have no interest in being on facebook is the amount of my family that is on it. And I'm not even doing or saying anything that my family will particularly find outrageous like some people, I wouldn't be leaking a sexual preference or something I don't want to reveal to them at this time. I simply don't care to run my every opinion, location, preference, and activity past them, and then have to hear about their opinions about it. To be clear, I'm 33 and have long since stopped caring about their opinions... but I still don't want to listen to them, either. I'm very closely related to some people in my family whom I can't really get away from who are virtually incapable of having a thought without saying it out loud. YMMV. And I am by far not a pathological example... I'm doing this more out of my personal convenience than anything else, there's nothing that I feel I have to hide. What of those that do? And if you're really having a hard time imagining what that sort of thing may be... this very post is an example. The person I'm referring to will never find it here. Ever. I can speak freely here, at least as long as I don't name names which I wouldn't anyhow. I'm not in a hurry to live in world where that goes away. Online balkanization isn't all bad. It isn't even mostly bad.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bradleyland 15y agoSo what is your proposed solution? I already don't post anything online that I don't consider public, just like I don't discuss in a restaurant something I wouldn't want overheard. I have an entirely different privacy threshold than you do. Would any proposed solution respect the fact that I might choose to share more (or less)? For me, the solution seems pretty straight forward. If you desire privacy, don't share.
- jerf 15y ago