6 ms·
This is why the IRS would rather go after us chumps, the easy targets, rather than the ones who are openly and blatantly dodging gigadollars in taxes. If I so m
by ryandrake 3y ago
This is why the IRS would rather go after us chumps, the easy targets, rather than the ones who are openly and blatantly dodging gigadollars in taxes. If I so much as thought about under-reporting $15K of income, the IRS would come down on me like a ton of bricks for taxes, interest and penalties, but I guess if Microsoft under-reports $15B, but sends lawyers, the IRS simply chickens out. Ridiculous.
- tekla 3y agoThis is FUD. I've interacted with the IRS over $50k and it was perfectly fine. They send me a letter with contact details and you just provide them the information. If you do owe shit, you just go to the IRS.gov site and pay the dumb bill, and the site is perfectly functional and not a PITA to use. I have no idea why people misrepresent the IRS so much
- trealira 3y agoIt seems they actually do audit the poor disproportionately, and they profess that it's because their funding has been cut over the past nine years: https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-sorry-but-its-just-easier-and-cheaper-to-audit-the-poor https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-sorry-but-its-just-ea... And as the original article posted shows, entities like Microsoft will spend money on lawyers, lobby Congress, and spend time in court to fight the IRS, whereas the poor won't.
- refurb 3y agoThey audit low income because of the EITC which has been rife with fraud.
- trealira 3y agoYou can read IRS commissioner's, Charles Rettig's, response here: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6430680-Document-2019-9-6-Treasury-Letter-to-Wyden-RE.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6430680-Document-201... He plainly says that it's because they don't have the resources to conduct higher income audits.
- refurb 3y agoBottom of page 4: "Even with declining resources, audit coverage is greater in the larger TPI (total positive income) grouping than the coverage of EITC returns that fall in the lower TPI range". Can you quote the exact part of the letter where they say "we target EITC because we don't have the money to audit high income individuals"?
- trealira 3y agoThe IRS budget has been decreasing. As a result, they've been experiencing rates of attrition of their examiners, significantly higher attrition among the examiners who can perform high income audits, which take longer, ranging "from 61 to 251 hours per return." The IRS cannot simply shift examination resources from single issue correspondence audits to more complex higher income audits because of employee experience and skillset. A GS-8 tax examiner is not trained to conduct a high-income, high wealth taxpayer audit. In order to increase parity of number of taxpayers audited, the IRS must reallocate high-graded resources from certain issues to high income, high wealth taxpayer returns. Further, the rate of attrition is significantly higher among these more experience examiners. It is also important to maintaining the voluntary compliance level that the IRS has an audit presence across all income groups, including EITC. In the short term, the IRS will continue to open additional audits in FY 2019 in the category of TPI of $10 million and over. [...] In the longer term, Congress must fund and the IRS must train appropriate numbers of RAs to have appropriately balanced coverage among all income levels. Further, he notes that "EITC correspondence audits are the most efficient use of available IRS examination resources with the average time to complete the audit about 5 hours of return." Although audits have been decreasing among all parts of the population, they've been decreasing more sharply for top earners. According to ProPublica, citing this document[1], audit rates have dropped by about 80% for all groups with an income of over $200k, and only 34% for EITC recipients; as a result, EITC recipients are now about equally likely to receive audits as top 1% income earners (1.41% vs 1.56%). So, due to their dwindling resources, the IRS is auditing all groups less, but they're particularly focusing on auditing low income and EITC recipients and less on high income earners. [1]: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6023996-Effects-of-EITC-Correspondence-Audits-on-Low.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6023996-Effects-of-E...
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoThe US tax code is purposefully, unnecessarily byzantine to gamify tax avoidance for some and entrap others. It should be an income and situational gradual tax computed by the government. There should no need for tax preparation software, only tax estimation software.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoYou can write a simple code to audit 10's of millions of simple returns. Of course they are cheaper.
- Datsundere 3y ago> the site is perfectly functional and not a PITA to use. Been trying to get an EIN and the site tells me to call a customer service number. The number has a wait time of 1hr+. Oh also the site has "working hours" Monday to Friday, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. that's fucking wild
- trealira 3y agoMicrosoft sends their own lawyers and lobbyists, influences lawmakers to pass laws barring the IRS from using outside law firms, and that slash the IRS' funding, and this has been happening for years. Hence, you get results like this one: For corporations with assets over $20 billion, the audit rate has declined from about 100% in 2010 to under 50% in 2018. We can thank our representatives in Congress for siding with corporations over the IRS.
- refurb 3y agoCan you provide a source showing that “Microsoft lobbied to cut the IRS budget”. This is FUD
- trealira 3y agoMy bad; it was CEETA that lobbied for it, the Coalition for Effective and Efficient Tax Administration, of which Microsoft is a member. You can read it in the article posted. ----------------- It was a setback for Microsoft. But as the court case ground on, the company and its allies went to work on Capitol Hill to make sure something like this never happened again. In the autumn of 2015, a new trade group emerged. It was called the Coalition for Effective and Efficient Tax Administration, or CEETA. Among the members were Microsoft, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and a host of other business and tech groups. The new coalition hired lobbyists at PwC, another Big Four firm and one with a stable of well-connected former government officials and congressional staff. The new group’s clout soon became clear. In October 2015, just a few days after CEETA members fired off a letter to the IRS decrying the use of outside counsel on audits, Pam Olson, one of CEETA’s PwC lobbyists, sat down for a two-hour meeting with Doug O’Donnell, the head of the IRS division that audits large corporations. “When it comes to the tax law, I don’t like the word ‘enforcement,’” Olson, who oversaw tax policy as a Treasury Department official in the early 2000s, said in a speech to corporate tax executives that December. “Let’s remember that the agency is the Internal Revenue Service,” she said. Olson forwarded a copy of her speech to O’Donnell, who responded, according to emails obtained by ProPublica, “Thanks for sharing — I appreciate your perspective.” He said he would pass it on to other senior IRS officials. CEETA’s lobbyists stalked the halls of Congress, urging reforms in response to the IRS’ newfound aggression. They found a ready audience. In late 2015, a senior aide to Hatch participated in an online seminar for tax professionals along with a senior Microsoft executive. According to a description, participants discussed “the actions of an increasingly aggressive IRS” and the need for reform. (The aide, Christopher Armstrong, has since left Congress and now works as a lobbyist. He did not respond to requests for comment.) “Focusing on litigation destroys cooperative relationships between taxpayers and the IRS,” read a document distributed by CEETA’s lobbyists to lawmakers around that time and obtained by ProPublica. The proposals targeted the three bold steps Hoory had taken in the Microsoft audit: CEETA wanted lawmakers to curtail the IRS’ ability to block taxpayers’ access to the Office of Appeals, rein in the use of designated summons and prohibit outside lawyers from questioning witnesses.
- refurb 3y agoNahh… The IRS isn’t stupid. If they don’t think they can win, they don’t fight. And when the stakes are this high, it provides more incentive to fight because the potential outcome is far higher. If you want to blame someone for this, blame Congress and their vague tax laws. The idea the IRS should have the authority to interpret tax law as they see fit isn’t how the system works. If there is uncertainty, you can challenge it in the courts. Clearly the IRS didn’t think their odds were that great of winning.
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoThe IRS primarily goes after the middle-class and small business owners because it's the path of least resistance. But when you're very rich, you have the advantages of an army of tax attorneys and accountants who implement tax minimization/BEPS and tax planning. They also have bending the tax code in their favor, a form of regulatory capture, through lobbyists, powerful friends, and elected officials.
- cainxinth 3y agoThe reason why the IRS goes after small fish is also because a large faction in Congress has been trying (with a decent amount of success) to gut the agency’s budget, workforce, and administrative powers for decades.
- yieldcrv 3y agosort of. its a mixture of easier target but also the structure of the noncompliance. the IRS only knows about your $15k of income because the person you earned it from filed the 1099 sent it to you and took a tax deduction. The IRS then goes looking at the 1099 recipient for the tax. Its a social graph. When things are more disconnected from a graph it is still complicated for the IRS.