2 ms·
I've reverse engineered many an API, and I've never done it by decompiling the executable. Also, what's illegal about decompiling an executable?
by stavros 3y ago
I've reverse engineered many an API, and I've never done it by decompiling the executable. Also, what's illegal about decompiling an executable?
- Nextgrid 3y agoThey could argue that by viewing the copyrighted code/implementation, you could effectively infringe by (even subconsciously) writing the same/similar code. There's merits to this claim if you're indeed implementing some advanced, niche algorithm but it definitely wouldn't apply here as all he's doing is calling HTTP APIs, a very generic and common thing to do.
- stavros 3y agoAh, so it's not the act of disassembling that's the problem, but that you're infringing on the original code's copyright? That makes sense, thank you.
- angus-prune 3y agoYou may have come across this concept already, but this is where clean rooms come in. One person views the "contaminated" decompiled code and writes a specification. A separate person writes the code based solely on the specification. This is an accepted method of demonstrating that there is no infringement.
- stavros 3y agoYep, I knew of clean-room reimplementations, I was just wondering whether decompiling is somehow in itself illegal.
- 6502nerdface 3y agoBut disassembling/decompiling doesn't give you anything like the original code!