3 ms·
How many of these have we seen now? Adobe have offered indemnification for Firefly: https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/26/adobe-indemnity-clause-designed-to-ease-e
by simonw 3y ago
How many of these have we seen now?
Adobe have offered indemnification for Firefly: https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/26/adobe-indemnity-clause-designed-to-ease-enterprise-fears-about-ai-generated-art/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/26/adobe-indemnity-clause-des...
"With Firefly, Adobe will also be offering enterprise customers an IP indemnity, which means that Adobe would protect customers from third party IP claims about Firefly-generated outputs."
Here's Microsoft for their Copilot (which I do not think is the same thing as GitHub Copilot): https://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2023/09/07/copilot-copyright-commitment-ai-legal-concerns/ https://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2023/09/07/copilot...
"To address this customer concern, Microsoft is announcing our new Copilot Copyright Commitment. As customers ask whether they can use Microsoft’s Copilot services and the output they generate without worrying about copyright claims, we are providing a straightforward answer: yes, you can, and if you are challenged on copyright grounds, we will assume responsibility for the potential legal risks involved."
And for GitHub Copilot: https://github.com/features/copilot/#faq https://github.com/features/copilot/#faq
"What if I’m accused of copyright infringement based on using a GitHub Copilot suggestion?
GitHub will defend you as provided in the GitHub Copilot Product Specific Terms."
That links to a document which says this:
"If your Agreement provides for the defense of third party claims, that provision will apply to your use of GitHub Copilot, including to the Suggestions you receive. Notwithstanding any other language in your Agreement, any GitHub defense obligations related to your use of GitHub Copilot do not apply if you have not set the Duplicate Detection filtering feature available in GitHub Copilot to its “Block” setting."
I don't understand the "If your Agreement provides for the defense of third party claims" bit though.
- gtowey 3y agoIt really feels like tech companies are taking the approach of "we'll guarantee you anything you want!" As a sales strategy. The cynical part of me wants to say it shows that they have high confidence they can manipulate the legal system enough to dictate the outcome of any challenges.
- blibble 3y agothis might work in the US but is unlikely to work elsewhere in the world the EU in particular is likely to pay less than zero attention to the interests of large US tech companies the liability they're taking on here could be absolutely gigantic
- artninja1988 3y agoNot a lawyer but I imagine the infringement on the input side, during the dataset creation and training would take place wherever the model is being trained? So presumably the us? On the other hand, yeah. Memorizing input data and spitting out protected characters on the output side seems like an issue.
- kuchenbecker 3y agoThey clearly can't indemnify that all output is copyright free if the person inputting is describing a copyrighted work either. Sufficiently advanced Gen AI can generate images / text that looks like copyrighted work from description while being licensed for all training data.
- zelon88 3y agoI look at it more like this; "Vendor lock your data and workload on OUR platform and we'll shield you forever!" The fear being that you'll perform experiments outside of their cleverly scoped sandbox where they get to amortize your training data into theirs for free. Basically "sure, you can bring your toys over to play in our sandbox. You just have to leave them here so we can be sure you don't eclipse our capability or market share without us."
- moritzwarhier 3y agoHave we seen one from OpenAI apart from the one you mentioned for Copilot via MS? Sorry if stupid question.
- londons_explore 3y ago> If your Agreement provides for the defense of third party claims I think this is saying "you have to let our lawyers argue on your behalf. If you fight it with your own shitty lawyers and lose, we won't pay your losses".
- anon373839 3y agoMercedes-Benz also. This is an interesting trend. I wonder if there is any historical precedent for suppliers of a new technology to provide indemnification to protect against uncertainty in the legal regime.