3 ms·
[...] One could conclude that the abuse centre could thus easily spot the malicious entry in its database after a few of these reports all concerned with the sa
by anigbrowl 3y ago
[...] One could conclude that the abuse centre could thus easily spot the malicious entry in its database after a few of these reports all concerned with the same image, and delete the corresponding fingerprint from the database. If that were the case, this avenue of attack would not be a problem in practice. This assumes, however, that the abuse centre keeps track of such false positives over time to detect such maliciously uploaded fingerprints. This may or may not be the case.
Why would it not be the case, unless the abuse center wanted to waste time and resources and have unreliable records? This essay is technically sophisticated and socially naive. Tech people keep spinning up the most unlikely and hard-to-explain reasons for why leveraging technology to interfere with the spread of CSAM is bad, instead of working toward any kind of privacy-respecting solution to target CSAM itself.
Constantly emphasizing the scope for government intrusion and privacy violation (legit but at the same time overblown to the point of paranoia) and constantly minimizing or dismissing the real harms of CSAM is a great way to alienate the normal non-technical people you need to have on side.
- uconnectlol 3y agookay, ill bite: yes, the blogger has tunnel vision, that's the only valid point in your post, he also missed the fact that anyone can poison the well, not just privileged entities. however your rhetoric is cancerous, although i'm aware that many people who use it are just sheep and have no idea what they're insinuating. CSAM is a propaganda word: 1. right wing uses it to push their agenda of punishing people for having sex 2. left wing uses it to push their agenda of punishing males or kulaks or whatever 3. police use it to make it look like they're solving a crime so they can get paid for nothing: they can arrest someone for looking at a nude picture of a 17 year old (which the suspect is often unaware of), then in the media and police statements: "he was arrested for the possession of child sexual abuse material". and this is the majority of convictions: people (and even teens) being into teens. people are not naturally sexually attracted to children (13 and under) in more than say 0.0001%. so now that we actually looked at the subject beyond the taboo veil, it seems the discussion is just to stop 14-17 year olds from having sex, which is insane and does not justify one single thing that police do about it. CP being illegal is just completely out of the question. we should be debating re legalizing CP, or changing it to 13 and under at the very least (i don't see any harm in the existence of porn of any age since it does not encourage abuse since most people will not become sexually attracted to children no matter how much you expose them to it). so again, your rhetoric is pure cancer. i don't need a "privacy respecting solution to CSAM". what the hell do you think that would be? do we also need a freedom respecting solution to the murder problem? would you have my legs cut off and say i should just order door dash?
- anigbrowl 3y agopeople are not naturally sexually attracted to children (13 and under) in more than say 0.0001%. In the US alone, that would be ~30,000 people. Get back to me when you've read some legal cases or know anyone who's been abused to produce such material. Perhaps you'll learn some critical thinking and better manners along the way.
- chownie 3y ago> Get back to me when you've read some legal cases or know anyone who's been abused to produce such material Hello, I'd be the anyone in this scenario. I don't believe that the pros outweigh the cons, violating the privacy of every single person to protect us from the absolute minority (abusers) of a minority (those attracted to children) is not worth the exchange. CSAM detection would not have protected me from abuse. At best it would have prevented continued sexual abuse. And yet had my abuser been caught early I would have been returned to a different, brutally abusive man. One whose abuse no one particularly seems to care about, because there's less to get righteous about when there's no sex involved in the abuse.
- anigbrowl 3y agoOK, but if you read my posts above I am not arguing for mass privacy violations. I'm saying the tech community isn't going to get any traction for its advocacy unless it makes some effect to propose privacy respecting solutions to the CSAM proliferation problem. I'm sorry that happened to you, but I presume you would also prefer that imagery including you did not continue to circulate?
- uconnectlol 3y agowhat? we already know the legislation will not pass. the "tech community" doesn't have to do anything. why are you trying to make it sound like there is a dilemma here. cringe
- chownie 3y agoHow about putting more of the onus on services who might be used to traffic it? > I'm sorry that happened to you, but I presume you would also prefer that imagery including you did not continue to circulate? I've reported CSAM posts on tumblr and twitter and seen them survive for weeks before they finally disappear. It seems like that's a much riper target than propping up this kind of worst case solution.