4 ms·
How does the student performance compare to other institutions? If most students learn the material, then they deserve a good mark. Having taught three very di
by verdverm 3y ago
How does the student performance compare to other institutions? If most students learn the material, then they deserve a good mark.
Having taught three very different classes, I can tell you there is a bell curve to the per class bell curve. Undergrad intro was a bell curve, CS Grad remediation was tragic, mixed ML was mostly A's, they were very engaged students
- ecshafer 3y agoSome schools / departments have a policy of no curves. RIT for example doesn’t curve anything, or at least didn’t 15 years ago.
- Frost1x 3y agoI mean curves apply artificial scaling to data of course how one decides to apply them. In some contexts it means that there's always someone failing because in the pool of data you're fitting to, they performed the worst (relatively speaking) but perhaps only in that pool. Overall the worst performer could be excellent in a bigger/wider context. There's no standard "curving" procedure which leaves a lot of ambiguity and potential variation in the results. Often someone just means fitting it to a normal distribution and scaling accordingly. Not everything makes sense in a normal distribution even though people like to default to it in the absence of a known distribution. This gets even more complicated when you start talking about arbitrarily curving across different work, perhaps different courses, across different semesters and so on. Overall you may end up with some weird weighted distribution of your actual performance that's a bit nonsensical. I'm not here to say tests are great metrics but consistency in metrics is usually a good thing or at least a consistent process for attaining them.
- verdverm 3y agoCurves were per teacher were I was, pretty sure you cannot stop the subtle bumps that happen based on effort
- aidenn0 3y agoWhere and when I went to school, there was also a bell-curve to the classes that have a natural semester for students to take them (e.g. if most students take a class in the Fall, the Spring semester class will tend to have poorer students).
- bradly 3y agoThe article linked doesn't add much but if you read the original report[1] it shows the percent of A's going from 60% in 2011 to 70% in 2019 and then 79% in 21. The report is about the rate of change, not so much the actual value. The original article is more interesting as well in that it talks about the anxiety that grades bring and if abolishing grades altogether something to consider. 1: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/10/5/faculty-debate-grade-inflation-compression/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/10/5/faculty-debate-...
- ghaff 3y agoYeah, there's definitely been grade inflation over time (which has been known for many selective schools generally for a long time). You've also had some long-standing anomalies like MIT using a 5.0 GPA scale rather than 4.0. (And at least used to be Pass/Fail Freshman year.) I do get that grades aren't an unalloyed good.
- gnicholas 3y ago> If most students learn the material, then they deserve a good mark. Yes, if you're trying to prepare your students for applying for jobs that will have GPA cutoffs, this makes sense. But if you're trying to help outsiders (and insiders, as the article notes — like award committees) discern which students are relatively stronger, this system complicates things.
- adw 3y agoMost elite universities have been forced (by market forces) into doing what Harvard is doing. The proportion of firsts being awarded by Cambridge, for example, had already inflated substantially 20 years ago. The solution involves having, relatively speaking, "low" absolute grade boundaries (first-class honours at Cambridge is usually set around 70% of the marks in most subjects, third-class honours is 50%, pass without honors is even lower) on genuinely challenging exams, then using the raw grades for things like PhD admissions and scholarships. The notorious Maths Tripos is an extreme example of that strategy.
- Scarblac 3y agoShouldn't the mark be primarily a signal for the student to indicate how well they understood the subject, and to serve as motivation?
- dfadsadsf 3y agoIf 80% of students get A, it's very weak motivator if you are top 10% student. Essentially there is no point in working harder than some arbitrary pretty low threshold. Most subjects has unlimited depth so it should not be too hard to design test with reasonable questions where no student get everything right and you can do normal distribution for grades (something like 5% A+, 10% A, 40% B, 30% C, 0-15% F)