3 ms·
> increasing monopolistic power of Microsoft Games Microsoft has never been #1 in gaming. It's always been playing catch-up. There's nothing even remotely clo
by crazygringo 3y ago
> increasing monopolistic power of Microsoft Games
Microsoft has never been #1 in gaming. It's always been playing catch-up.
There's nothing even remotely close to "monopolistic". That doesn't make any sense at all. You literally can't be a monopoly if you're not #1.
This is Microsoft simply trying to complete better against Sony. Which is a good thing. It benefits the consumer as stronger, more equal competition leads to lower prices for consumers.
Letting Sony remain in the lead forever is what would be bad for consumers in the long term.
- wredue 3y agoUh no. Buying out previously cross platform studios and then converting their titles to Microsoft only is absolutely not “strengthening competition”. If Microsoft want to strengthen competition, they would stop burning their first party studios to the ground.
- crazygringo 3y agoOf course it is strengthening competition. Playstation has tons of exclusive titles. By one estimate, 4x as many as Xbox [1]. How is that a fair playing field? I'm personally totally in favor of ending exclusivity entirely for all consoles. (What gamer wouldn't be?) But as long as Sony is playing that game, Microsoft is simply trying to level the playing field here, to make Xbox more competitive against PS. That's what more competition is. [1] https://www.tomsguide.com/face-off/ps5-vs-xbox-series-x-exclusives https://www.tomsguide.com/face-off/ps5-vs-xbox-series-x-excl...
- xinayder 3y agoHow many are actually relevant, though? I can name a few that are definitely relevant: Uncharted, Horizon, God of War, The Last of Us, titles that are also being released for PC. They are no longer exclusives.
- wredue 3y agoIt’s not Sonys fault that Microsoft destroyed their first party dominance while Sony was curating their exclusive titles. Microsoft endorsed enshittification and got complacent. Sony didn’t. Microsoft lost their previously winning position through incompetence in a single console generation, and that doesn’t all of a sudden make buying up and making several studios exclusive “fair competition”. “Fair competition” is not using your other business lines to subsidize harming consumers because you made several years of terrible decisions. What’s more, Microsoft’s throwing money around to just buy a position in the gaming market is showing through clear review manipulation (Starfalls wall of 10s for what’s clearly a 5-6/10). For any other company this purchase is viewed as anti-competitive. Microsoft’s arguments were fucking toddler level. How consumer protections managed to bungle this so badly to prevent the sale is likely to go down in law education for “what not to do”. All the lawyers involved in the consumer protection side should be disbarred on the basis of complete incompetence.
- gdulli 3y agoWhat does competition mean, if not differences in software? The console hardware between Sony and Microsoft isn't meaningfully differentiated. If the consoles had identical catalogs what would be left to differentiate them other than friends list lock-in? A few FPS or a home screen you happen to prefer aren't important things.
- wredue 3y agoSo Microsoft failing for a decade to bring titles to their console means that it’s okay to remove titles from Sony gamers? The consoles today don’t have identical catalogs. That’s where your argument falls apart. One company made a decade of bad decisions which caused them to fall behind. In a fair market where Microsoft didn’t have trillions in resources to just steal the market, Phil Spencer would be fired and Xbox gaming would be looking for better direction. Also, Microsoft was granted moving forward on the basis that their claim “the games would be more accessible to everyone” was true. Yet you are here arguing that this will not be the case. Which is it? We all know what Microsoft plans are. Personally, I am now hoping for Sony and Nintendo to pick up major publishers and make the content exclusive just so I can see the Xbox fanboys lose their shit over how its anti-competitive when they lose games, but not anti-competitive when they rob experiences from others.
- crazygringo 3y agoWhat does a company's past failures have to do with whether its current strategy is sound? Do you think Apple shouldn't have been allowed to acquire NeXT when Steve Jobs came back, just because Apple's previous CEO's had done a bad job? It's not "stealing" anything. It's acquiring a company and paying a fair price for it. Playstation has way more exclusives than Xbox. This is just getting closer to leveling the playing field. There's nothing wrong with that. The more equal in size major market participants are, the better off it tends to be for consumers. And please don't call anyone "fanboys". That kind of name-calling isn't appropriate for HN discourse.
- nitwit005 3y agoPeople aren't going to see lower prices, no matter who acquires who. Video game prices are effectively set industry wide, similar to music and movies. They effectively set the price collectively, which is why you see articles mention things like: > Xbox is preparing to join other major games publishers in raising the prices of its major new first-party titles from $60 to $70. https://www.ign.com/articles/microsoft-raising-prices-new-first-party-games-xbox-series-70-2023-redfall-starfield https://www.ign.com/articles/microsoft-raising-prices-new-fi...
- crazygringo 3y agoThe Series S console came out at $299. GamePass is $10.99/mo. If that's not lowering prices, then I don't know what is.
- Capricorn2481 3y agoWe're talking about game prices, which are indeed industry set (worked in the industry). The Xbox Series S has cheaper hardware, that's why it's cheaper. You might as well say video games are getting less expensive because the 3DS isn't $500. While GamePass is great value, it's just temporary to keep everybody on Microsoft store. You can't mod games, you can't open your game files even, and your progress in live service games will not be transferred to other platforms even if you're on PC still. It's hard not to acknowledge the fact that Microsoft is getting perfectly positioned to clamp everyone down into their ecosystem harder than ever, and there's nothing we could do about it. They have Github, they have a close partnership with ChatGPT, they have a crazy amount of game studios and IPs. I don't think the attitude of "let's let them get as big as possible and hope they don't abuse that power" is healthy.
- crazygringo 3y ago> We're talking about game prices No we're not, we're talking about the total cost of console gaming, because that's what actually matters when you're discussing the effect on consumers. > It's hard not to acknowledge the fact that Microsoft is getting perfectly positioned to clamp everyone down into their ecosystem harder than ever No, it's hard to imagine where you're getting that from at all, if you're talking about their gaming arm. Microsoft isn't positioned to clamp down on anything in gaming. They're simply trying to compete against their more successful competitor Sony. > I don't think the attitude of "let's let them get as big as possible and hope they don't abuse that power" is healthy. I don't think the attitude of "let Sony's gaming business be as big as it already is, but don't allow Microsoft's gaming business to try to expand to match Sony's" is healthy. That's literally anti-competitive.