4 ms·
> I think our disagreement here is over the level of innocence of someone possessing AI generated CSAM. > If you believe, as I do, that such a person is guilty
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> I think our disagreement here is over the level of innocence of someone possessing AI generated CSAM.
> If you believe, as I do, that such a person is guilty of a crime,
You just explicitly said upthread that ethically they are not, but argued that it is useful for them to be treated as criminals because it denies an excuse to those who are ethically guilty because they are possessors of genuine CSAM.
You seem to be moving your fundamental ethical premises around in response to it being pointed out that the argument you previously made conflicts with a different widely proclaimed ethical premise.
- chatmasta 3y agoMy ethical premise is that there is no direct victim of AI generated CSAM, but that it's worth criminalizing because otherwise it further victimizes victims of existing law. In other words, there is a societal victim of it. To me it's the same ethical premise but interpreted within two different frameworks: one that's purely idealistic, and one that's based in practical reality.
- sneak 3y agoAI cannot generate CSAM, because AI cannot abuse children. AI makes fictional images, which definitionally cannot be images of child sexual abuse. There is literally no victim of any kind, even conceptually, in the case of computer generated imagery. It should be protected artistic expression.
- chatmasta 3y agoWhat if a police officer generates some AI CSAM and then sells it to someone who thinks it's real? There's still "no victim," but the buyer thinks that there was. Are they guilty of a crime? Your logic would seem to imply that there's no crime with possession of real CSAM either, and that the only crime lies with the original abuser who took the pictures.
- giantrobot 3y ago> Are they guilty of a crime? Unless there is a very specific "attempt to acquire CSAM" law then no they're not fucking guilty of any crime. If you live in a state where marijuana is illegal and you smoke some oregano because you thought it was marijuana you're not guilty of actually possessing marijuana. A criminal law is composed of a number of individual statutes. When a state is trying to prosecute someone for a crime they need to prove three elements for each statute: the criminal act (actus reus), intent (mens rea), and the concurrence of both of those. If a cop sells you oregano and you think it's marijuana you might have the intent to buy marijuana but there's no actual criminal act because oregano isn't illegal. If you make a law that only requires intent then congratulations, you've created thought crimes. If you want to make entirely fake CSAM possession illegal, that's essentially the same as an intent-only law and creates thought crimes. It's a slippery slope.
- Genghis_Khan 3y ago> If a cop sells you oregano and you think it's marijuana [...] It wasn't a cop, but I recall a case some years back when someone sold something as cocaine when it wasn't. Among other things, he went down for fraud.
- trehalose 3y ago> If a cop sells you oregano and you think it's marijuana you might have the intent to buy marijuana but there's no actual criminal act because oregano isn't illegal. If you make a law that only requires intent then congratulations, you've created thought crimes. You're a lawyer, I take it? I'm not a lawyer, and I admit your analysis of this scenario confuses me. Is there no legal difference between merely having intent to commit a crime at some point in the future, and actually attempting to commit a crime?
- trifurcate 3y agoDefinitely not a lawyer. You couldn't charge anyone with criminal conspiracy from the parent commenter's perspective.
- 3y ago