2 ms·
I think there's definitely probably some motivation in that, but I don't think it captures the whole issue. As in: I'm sure he probably personally feels emotio
by keepamovin 3y ago
I think there's definitely probably some motivation in that, but I don't think it captures the whole issue.
As in: I'm sure he probably personally feels emotional about that aspect of it, but the fact that he may have a personal emotional motivation does not make untrue any of the points he may be raising.
But no disparagement to your point, I mean this sincerely: it is good work on that ad hominem if your goal is to dismiss the concerns. Because that "ulterior motivation" ad hominem is a fairly effective way to dismiss it, unless you want to look a little deeper to the real issues. Well done! I mean that, seriously.
From outside it could be hard to tell what's true, so it's worthwhile to consider all the options. He's essentially trying to make allegations about a "black box" process (black in the sense that the NSA is not publishing its calculus and activities on these matters), so who do we trust? It seems it could be unclear right now.
- tptacek 3y agoCRYSTALS-Kyber is anything but a black box. It's an academic research project, about which a metric fuckload of rationale, critique, and rebuttal has been published openly.
- keepamovin 3y agoSorry, I should have been more clear; I meant the NSA process around these systems is a black box, because they are not publishing their internal calculus and activities around the development of these cryptosystems. For instance, "showing your work" around the development of SHA0, or showing your internal research and attacks for CK.