5 ms·
The author sees half the problem and offers the worse half of a solution. A scrollbar is not only a control, it's also an indicator. It shows where your viewpo
by nine_k 3y ago
The author sees half the problem and offers the worse half of a solution.
A scrollbar is not only a control, it's also an indicator. It shows where your viewport is relative to the bigger view, e.g. a long list. Hiding scrollbars, like some [redacted] GUIs like macOS do, is just acutely impolite, much like making buttons indistinguishable from text, or putting light grey text on a light grey background.
A solution exists, and is nearly universally implemented: scroll wheels on a mouse, and scroll gestures on a trackpad. Very, very rarely do I find a view which can be scrolled by scrollbars, but cannot be scrolled by the standard trackpad gesture, or by a mouse wheel. (BTW my mouse also allows horizontal scrolling using the wheel; so do trackpoint controls, too.)
Such scrolling does not require the pointer to even be at a scrollbar; the pointer just need to hover over the desired view / control / widget. This is really easy to achieve with imprecise input devices, unsteady hands, and poor vision.
But with this natural, easy way of scrolling one starts to really miss scrollbars in their indicator role.
(Regarding minimaps: sometimes they are helpful, sometimes not so much. I in particular find them unhelpful and bulky for text editing, but of course I'm all in favor of having them as an option for those who enjoy them.)
- pitterpatter 3y ago>A solution exists, and is nearly universally implemented: scroll wheels on a mouse, and scroll gestures on a trackpad. So you didn't read the article huh. The very first paragraph says: >“Ah”, they say, “that’s what the scroll wheel is for”. My friend, not everyone can use a scroll wheel or a swipe up touch screen. Or literally the next paragraph about difficulties small/hidden scrollbars cause with other input methods, e.g. eye trackers.
- wilg 3y agoWhat's stopping those input methods from having a special scroll gesture that is optimal for their input medium? But sure, have an accessibility override for giant scrollbars.
- nine_k 3y agoI thinks that of all things, eye trackers and voice controllers have the easiest time sending whatever scrolling commands, without a need to fiddle with scrollbars.
- wilg 3y ago??? macOS (and iOS) is designed this way because of the gesture you want! You don't need the scrollbar because you have the gesture. If you want to see where you are in the page you just scroll a teeny bit. It works great, I haven't seen a scrollbar in years and its never a problem. Sure, some accessibility options are nice for some people.
- nine_k 3y agoA gesture is an action. It's good, and it works as intended. A scrollbar is (also) an indication, glanceable, not requiring any action. If someone among your friends and family has an iOS device, remember how many times you had to show them that certain screens can be scrolled down? Oh, not just down, but also to the right? There used to be a few perfectly aligned views that had no indication whatsoever that there's more to them is you scroll. Narrow but visible scrollbars would solve this easily.
- wilg 3y agoI know what a gesture is. > If someone among your friends and family has an iOS device, remember how many times you had to show them that certain screens can be scrolled down? I don't know, zero? Maybe let's say once to be charitable. This is not a real problem faced by most people. IMO, this is just people being used to doing it another way.
- kyleee 3y agoDon’t underestimate how much pulling the rug out from under people via constant UI churn negatively affects their lives and interactions with computers. Leads to lower confidence, helplessness, etc.
- wilg 3y agoI mean it's been basically one change to the scrollbar in 40 years. And you can turn them on again if you care.
- tapanjk 3y agoTalking about scolling alone, the PgUp and PgDwn keys on my big honking external keyboard are life savers.
- whartung 3y agoScroll wheels and gestures are paging mechanisms, a scrollbar does that as well but it’s also a “take me to the middle of the document” control. Assuming a properly responsive document (not something you can take for granted today, especially on the web), you can readily use the scrollbar to navigate large ranges within a document, especially large ones. Countless times, on large, old PDFs with no links and that use that kind of “B-29” section page numbering have I essentially used the scrollbar to binary search the document for some buried page. Of course the modern web has practically destroyed the applicability of the scrollbar as indicator because of the rampant use of lazy loading and endless scrolling. Many times on the Mac I’ve tried to use Cmd-down arrow to jump to the end of the document, hoping that there IS an end, and that it will load all of embeds that wreak havoc with the formatting. But, alas, I find I’m on some endless train, with no hope of knowing how far I’ve gone or how far I have to go. All that said, I happen to have a weighted mouse wheel on a bearing that is specifically designed for high velocity doom scrolling, partly because the scrollbar is effectively useless.
- trealira 3y ago> Scroll wheels and gestures are paging mechanisms, a scrollbar does that as well but it’s also a “take me to the middle of the document” control. IME, only on Linux am I able to click on an arbitrary location beneath or atop the scrollbar and be taken there immediately. On Windows, it seems that clicking below the scrollbar is equivalent to scrolling down once. If you want to go all the way to the bottom of the document or webpage, you have to drag the scrollbar all the way down manually. I actually find it kind of annoying. I don't know about MacOS, as I haven't used it since I was a kid.
- hollerith 3y ago>On Windows, it seems that clicking below the scrollbar is equivalent to scrolling down once. If you want to go all the way to the bottom of the document or webpage, you have to drag the scrollbar all the way down manually. I actually find it kind of annoying. Have you tried changing the behavior in Settings?
- JohnFen 3y ago> scroll wheels on a mouse But that breaks down if you have to scroll a very long way.
- baq 3y agoOn windows at least the middle button could be used to anchor a virtual scroll wheel or whatever that feature was a called. I’ve used it quite often on large content with small windows.
- dzaima 3y agoThere are extensions for chrome and firefox[0] that can allow for continued scrolling by scroll wheel to exponentionally (as in, actually exponential) speed up. With this, I pretty much never use the scrollbar UI element as an input. [0]: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/chromium-wheel-smooth-scr/khpcanbeojalbkpgpmjpdkjnkfcgfkhb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/chromium-wheel-smo..., https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/yass-we https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/yass-we
- JohnFen 3y agoYeah, I've tried them. They are not a good solution for me, because of the lack of accuracy.
- sime2009 3y ago> A scrollbar is not only a control, it's also an indicator. Thank you! finally someone understands what a scrollbar is for. It primary job is to show the user that the document is bigger than the window, and secondly, to show which part of the document is visible. Letting the user scroll around is not the primary function! I was genuinely surprised when Apple started hiding scrollbars by default in macOS. Their UI designers clearly don't have a clue what the basic UI controls really do.
- oneeyedpigeon 3y agoNot just that "the document is bigger than the window" but the best scrollbars tell you, approximately, how tall the document is in relation to the window height! Proper scrollbars are, possibly, one of the best UI elements ever invented.
- Findecanor 3y agoInput devices for scrolling are not universally available. Wacom/pen users don't have a scroll wheel. Many trackballs don't have a scroll wheel. Some have a scroll ring around the ball though. I got RSI in my scrolling finger, so I removed the scroll wheel from my mice. And there have been times that I have overstretched my mouse-arm and had to use a trackball with my other hand for a few weeks.