5 ms·
Amazon sellers say they made a good living – until Amazon figured it out
- eschneider 3y agoI'm absolutely not saying Amazon is playing fair here, but ultimately, if you're just a middleman, someone's going to try and cut you out of the transaction. The only safety is having some sort of unique value proposition. Either you make it yourself and control the supply, or you do what you have to to make customers want to buy from YOU.
- yndoendo 3y agoA number of companies produce products only sold outside of the host country. The only way those citizens in the host country can access the goods is through an importing company with exclusive distribution rights. This often happens in the food and drink industries. An USA importer may be importing products manufactured in the US but only sold outside of the USA. This happens in the alcohol industry frequently.
- unmole 3y agoI don't follow. They are still middle men who can get cut out if either the manufacturer or the retailer decide it's lucrative enough.
- SantalBlush 3y ago>ultimately, if you're just a middleman, someone's going to try and cut you out of the transaction Unless it's healthcare, in which case, "Yeah! Bring on the middlemen!"
- aldebran 3y agoCouldn’t one argue Amazon is the middleman too? Not in every case but these sellers do provide value. They find obscure items for an underserved market and sell something people want. Amazon literally has a team looking at data that basically leverages the work done by these sellers to turn a profit. At minimum it’s like getting sherlocked.
- KirillPanov 3y agoThere is such an easy solution here: Amazon divests their logistics operation -- the warehouses, airplanes, and delivery trucks. They become a common carrier with a published price list; amazon.com and all the sellers on Amazon become customers of this logistics company. Probably a lot of ebay sellers too.
- parineum 3y agoWhy should they have to do that?
- KirillPanov 3y agoBecause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Act
- parineum 3y agoAmazon is nowhere near a monopoly in any sector.
- JohnFen 3y agoI'm not so sure. Because of Amazon, local stores no longer carry a great deal of things I need and that they used to carry. When I ask them about it, their response is that everyone just gets that stuff from Amazon so it isn't worth them selling it themselves.
- parineum 3y agoYou can get whatever item you're looking for at a myriad of other online retailers, let alone brick and mortars. It's not Amazon's problem that people prefer them over the local store.
- JohnFen 3y agoThe question isn't whether or not it's "Amazon's problem" or even Amazon's fault. The question is whether or not Amazon is a monopoly. I'm not asserting that they are or are not. I think it's a legitimate question. I do think that even if they technically aren't, they're very close to it.
- quitit 3y agoI think Amazon have been their own enemy here, their antics have set the conditions for a race to the bottom. Instead of Amazon's early days where I'd see a large range of options and quality/price levels, I now deal with page after page of the same low-quality options from a large number of "different" suppliers. Increasing my spend doesn't work, as they've got that angle covered, it's just the same items but with a higher price. I can't even rely on reviews, since those are gamed too. Then when I did find the item, the next hoop to jump through was the scams, when it's clothing: it's often a knock off using stolen photos, or the wrong size, or return instructions that demand delivery to a far away country even though the goods didn't come from there. Then there are the issues with counterfeiting, or worse, like when Amazon's own staff steal the product by swapping the contents of the box - something that is incredibly difficult to prove with customer service. Now if I want to shop online, I visit a store's website and buy directly. No scams, no counterfeits, no wrong sizes or b/s photos.
- m463 3y agoWhy do I always get funneled to shoes and jackets from UPCASEBRAND or MADEUPNAME, even though I know I want something from a known brand?
- jollofricepeas 3y agoWe exist. We’re just hard to find. There are lots of American companies that have designed their own products and sell online but we are outnumbered by Chinese sellers who use a lot of similar tactics to sell their goods to get better placement. It is a war zone for most popular product categories. I’m happy people are starting to cover how Amazon (and Apple to a lesser degree) has decimated the small mom and pop online businesses. Most of us leveraged social media to find small US communities that were underserved. And now they are out of business completely or they have had layoffs in the last two years.
- Cagrosso 3y agoApple? As in there ebook business they were fined for? I don’t know of many mom and pop cell phone or laptop manufacturers. I’m curious as to what you are referring to.
- NoPicklez 3y agoAs an Australian who for many years never had or used Amazon, I never understood its appeal. It just reminds me of eBay but without the bidding options. It's a massive swathe of low quality goods of which I can't trust the reviews, the website's UI is highly cluttered and I have to filter through the trusted brands that I know. I much prefer to just buy goods from individual vendors online or go in store.
- Modified3019 3y agoIt’s one single place where you can search for most everything you could want, while also being only one place to hand out your monetary info and address to. It also heavily favors buyers (like ebay), so if there is an issue, it’ much more of a sure thing to get a no hassle refund. Entering your credit card into dozens of differently designed websites the owner of whom may or may not know how to even spell “security” and stores everything in plaintext, or just outright may be a scammer, requires more mental overhead and risk. Now, in reality amazon is basically an internet flea market, and those supplements you bought are probably either a fake knockoff of a brand and made with lead, or “genuine” but falsely reporting it’s contents with no oversight and also filled with lead, but it’s the idea of buying them through “a familiar and therefore trustworthy place” that matters. Also the 2 day “free” shipping with prime really brought a lot of people onboard.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y ago> Now, in reality amazon is basically an internet flea market That is the perfect description of Amazon. The internet’s flea market.
- NoPicklez 3y agoThe idea of buying them through "a familiar and therefore trustworthy place" that matters, where products could be filled with lead? Doesn't sound like a very trustworthy place to me If I want to buy supplements, I will buy them from a trustworthy supplement store online that is popular and well known. If I want to buy a new TV I will go to popular and familiar online retailers that specialise in selling HiFi products. Amazon is quantity over quality. I want to be shown quality products, Visa and the consumer guarantee I get from reputable retailers is better than unknowingly buying lead filled supplements.
- t0mas88 3y agoAmazon is probably doing some unfair or even illegal things. But if your business is buying something from supplier X, adding no value at all and selling it on ecommerce site Y, then it makes perfect economic sense for either of X to sell to Y without you or Y to buy from X without you. It's in the consumers interest for that to happen. The only situation where this wouldn't happen is if volume is too low, in which case you're adding some value by aggregating demand across a few channels.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThis a perfect situation for cheap knockoffs to proliferate though. My dad wanted a Theragun and bought one on Amazon. He thought he got a deal and it looked just like a Theragun until it arrived and he saw the cheap power connectors and no external battery. Amazon is more than happy for cheap knockoffs to spread and rip people off by gaming thr product search system. Sure, middlemen are being cut out, but in many cases, so is the previously trusted vendor.
- michael1999 3y agoWhat’s that famous line from Bezos? “Your margin is my opportunity.”
- laxmin 3y agoIndia has set an example by banning Platform owners from owning companies that sell on the same platform, therefore ensuring a better level playing ground. It is not perfect, but can be a start. Amazon's subsidiaries must not be able to sell on Amazon marketplace. The giant needs to be broken up. The Marketplace, the Warehousing and the Logistics must be three different businesses and other players in warehousing and logistics must be able to offer their services. The free shipping must go unfortunately.
- unmole 3y agoAs it stands, most high value items on Amazon.in are sold by a small number of sellers: Dawntech, Cocoblu, Rocket Commerce etc. These are more or less annointed by Amazon and it is very unlikely that some third party seller will be able to compete with them in their respective categories.