5 ms·
How is this even remotely legal? I'm genuinely asking. They must have consulted with lawyers and believe it is legal. But even if their TOS say they reserve t
by crazygringo 3y ago
How is this even remotely legal?
I'm genuinely asking. They must have consulted with lawyers and believe it is legal.
But even if their TOS say they reserve the right to change anyone's plan at any time... that seems like one of those clauses that judges always strike down.
This is just flat-out providing a different service than you contracted for. This is like if I order a $200 SSD from Amazon and instead they ship me a $300 SSD and charge me $300, and there are no returns if I don't cancel the order before it's fulfilled.
I don't understand how this is legal. So I genuinely want to know:
1) Is this actually legal? If so, why haven't laws been passed against this kind of corporate bait-and-switch behavior?
2) Is it illegal but just doesn't get enforced? If so, why not?
3) It is illegal, and there will probably be a class action suit, but T-Mobile has calculated they'll still make more profit including a settlement? In which case, why aren't settlements more punitive?
- runako 3y ago> I don't understand how this is legal. It's presumably laid out in the contract that their users sign. IANAL but I understand contract law gives wide latitude for parties to make agreements to do things which are generally legal. One could imagine a legal regime that prohibited price or service changes in otherwise-legal contracts. Of course, that also might not be ideal. For example: a vendor used by the provider suddenly changes the capabilities of a piece of equipment such that the original service sold by the provider can no longer be provided at any price. What everybody wants in that scenario is for you to be seamlessly moved to the closest reasonable alternative, not for your service to automatically terminate. Similarly, most people will gripe about a $10/mo change in price, but against the likely alternative of automatic cancellation, the increased fee is what _most_ people will prefer. And again, 100% of them will have agreed to this exception-handling clause when they signed up. > This is like if I order a $200 SSD from Amazon and instead they ship me a $300 SSD and charge me $300, and there are no returns if I don't cancel the order before it's fulfilled. There is a material difference in changing prices (say) 5 years after a contract was signed and ordering a specific item at a specific price a week or two earlier. IANAL but I believe the ordering of goods via the Internet is in fact covered by different laws in a way that services are not. Which again, makes some sense given that service contracts frequently have a term of "forever," during which time everything about the world can change. (Pretty sure my current phone contract was signed over 10 years ago. I'm glad they changed my plan to let me use LTE, for example.)
- crazygringo 3y agoBut contact law also strikes down contact provisions all the time. Generally speaking, contracts between two parties who know what they're doing, with lawyers, are pretty iron-clad. But TOS with consumers are not. Unreasonable/abusive TOS clauses are struck down quite frequently. Things like consumer protection laws supersede anything in a TOS. And consumer protection laws are precisely the kind of thing meant to stop companies from playing bait-and-switch with consumers like this.
- runako 3y agoAbsolutely agree re: abusive TOS clauses. My question is this: if you were on a panel evaluating whether it's more abusive to a) migrate customers to a plan that's $10 more or b) end their service because the vendor no longer offers that service, which would you vote for? Note that consumer panels will have less ability to force a vendor to set prices or provide specific services, so there will not be the third option of c) force the vendor to continue providing the service at the contracted price.
- hef19898 3y agoThat's why in Europe abusive and surprising (to an informed party) terms and condiations are invalid. Quite aome legal disputes around those so.
- runako 3y agoCurious -- how do services raise prices? Is the presumption that a carrier has to give notice, then the user has to opt in or their service automatically terminates? > in Europe abusive and surprising (to an informed party) terms and condiations It can't be surprising to any informed party that prices change. Especially right now, it cannot be argued in good faith that a price increase was surprising to anyone. Does the user have to opt in each time the service changes (for ex if 2G service gets dropped)? Who decides what changes require a user's approval?
- paulpan 3y agoOlder plans (pre-2022) should be under the "Un-Contract": https://www.t-mobile.com/news/press/uncontract-carrier-freedom https://www.t-mobile.com/news/press/uncontract-carrier-freed... Notably "By contrast, the Un-contract is all give, no take. You can keep your existing Simple Choice plan and we won’t raise your rates. As part of this commitment, customers on existing Simple Choice promotional plans − like the Un-carrier’s ultra-popular 4 lines for $100 with up to 10 GB of 4G LTE data − can keep them for as long as they’re T-Mobile customers." Seems like a shut-and-close case for a class action lawsuit. Whoever made the decision to push ahead with this seems to have missed some internal due diligence - or there's some tiny legal footnotes I'm missing.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoT-Mobile forces customers into arbitration unless you've opted out. Probably straightforward to arbitrate based on terms, but I recommend filing an FCC complaint. Regulators light a fire. https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us Go to Phone > Billing (or go directly from here) https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us/articles/360001201223 https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us/articles/3600012... Phone Issues: Advertised Rate Text box content: T-Mobile is forcing me to upgrade my mobile plan even though I signed up with their advertised Price-Lock https://www.t-mobile.com/support/account/price- lock There is no option to opt-out as of $today's_date. This is a violation of my contract, and they are relying on the fact that most consumers do not have enough knowledge/time to call in and argue with customer representatives for hours. https://www.fiercewireless.com/wireless/t-mobile-will-migrate- customers-higher-cost-plans T-Mobile is also forcing customers who want to opt out and keep to their current contracted plan to listen to an unsolicited sales pitch -- this may violate telephone advertisement and spamming laws. While the company claims that customers can opt out, multiple customers have. reported that phone reps refuse to allow opt-out when they call, which is in general disingenuous behaviors. I believe that the FCC should force T-Mobile to provide this option through email or an online menu. FTC complaint can be made here: https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/ https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/
- 3y ago
- bxparks 3y agoI will guess that a class action is off the table because they imposed a mandatory binding arbitration clause (yup, https://www.t-mobile.com/responsibility/legal/terms-and-conditions https://www.t-mobile.com/responsibility/legal/terms-and-cond...). And forced binding arbitration is legal because the Supreme Court seems to be owned by corporations and billionaires. I suppose we could file complaints with the FTC and the FCC, but I suspect it will not help. After all, they probably got thousands of complaints about Comcast, but that didn't prevent Comcast from taking over the media world. T-Mobile used to be one of the better ones. But it was probably inevitable that they would succumb to the enshittification process that is devouring the corporate world.
- kotaKat 3y agoAren't the contracts now technically month-for-month, with the "contract" being the device payment agreement? As they themselves weasel out of it: they're not "raising prices", they're "moving you to a newer plan with more benefits at a different cost".
- 8note 3y agoT-Mobile also just changes plan details on the fly. Eg, one day my account stopped being able to log in to Canada to use the Canadian data on my account. Only changing plans fixed it
- theogravity 3y agoThey promise not to increase the rate on your current plan and get around this by just changing the plan you're on vs increasing the rate of your current plan. https://www.t-mobile.com/support/account/price-lock https://www.t-mobile.com/support/account/price-lock > Price Lock is our guarantee that we won’t raise the price of your qualifying rate plan for new accounts. You can rest assured that T-Mobile won’t raise the price of your regular monthly rate plan price for current unlimited talk, text, and data on our network on Go5G Plus, Go5G Next, Go5G, Base Essentials, Essential Savings, Essentials, Magenta, MAX, 55+, Military, First Responder, Unlimited and Lite Home Internet, and Business Unlimited plans as long as you’re a T-Mobile customer and keep your plan. And customers don’t have to do anything to get in on this – everyone who activates after April 28, 2022, with an eligible plan gets Price Lock.
- shostack 3y agoI'd be shocked if this wasn't planned out from the time they launched the plan.