4 ms·
Don't forget you can still get a DTV OTA antenna and watch live TV with a much much better image quality and without cable's delay. Admittedly, in can take a bi
by dylan604 3y ago
Don't forget you can still get a DTV OTA antenna and watch live TV with a much much better image quality and without cable's delay. Admittedly, in can take a bit of effort finding a location to place the antenna for best reception for your location, but so worth not paying for cable any longer.
Sports is the primary reason for me messing with this, but it is definitely worth it.
- Goronmon 3y agoHaving to invest time and money into the antenna is definitely what's stopped me from using OTA up to this point. Especially given that our location is between multiple broadcast points so it's not as simple as pointing an antenna in one direction, it would have to be a multi-directional antenna. Last I looked a decent one of those wasn't cheap.
- dylan604 3y agoI have one of those little table top style ones that came with a pretty long cable. It is a bit of an annoyance in that in my location, there are different places I need to place the antenna for best reception for that channel. Luckily, I only use it for sports, and I know the best location for each channel. So I just move it as needed, and then place it back behind the TV when done. I look at it like being similar to grabbing a gaming controller and putting it back on the charger when done. Fun things happen with reception though. Just this weekend, I was watching a match and everything was coming through just fine. The UPS truck pulled up to deliver a package to my house, and the whole time the truck was parked, the signal was struggling. As soon as the truck pulled away, everything was fine again. As much "fun" as all of that is, it is much cheaper than me finding a sports bar to watch a match. Besides, at the time of the morning what I'm watching is on, I really am not in the mood to go some where.
- freedomben 3y agoI'm in the same boat, and on-the-ground isn't even good enough. I'll have to mount a big antenna on top of my roof, which is a tall order. Not worth it to me so far.
- Goronmon 3y agoYup, the few more basic antennas I've tried effectively got no signal worth using on any channels.
- ghaff 3y ago"You" can :-) But fair comment. For many people, OTA offers good enough live TV. I live at the base of a hill blocking me from the nearest major city about 40 miles away. I've never been able to pick up anything OTA even before digital signals; there was even a big "external" antenna in the attic installed by the previous owner to no avail before he just got a big C-band dish. Even a lot of radio is pretty bad. I was able to get cable TV before taking any extreme measures.
- dylan604 3y agoThe irony here is that your specific situation was one of the driving factors of why cable was created
- ghaff 3y agoEven leaving aside the cable-only stations (both premium and non-premium), even getting the basic networks and maybe some UHF channels was marginal for a lot of people involving a lot of fiddling to get a usable signal. And pre-DirectTV, the alternatives were pretty much geeking out with a big Satellite dish which only worked out on your big country property and were willing to spend the money.
- dylan604 3y ago> even getting the basic networks and maybe some UHF channels was marginal <clears old timer's throat> In my day, we only had 3 networks and we liked it! You kids and your choices! But seriously, it is fascinating how in ~20 years of HDTV we've gone so far away from a small collection of channels with nothing worth watching to nothing worth watching available everywhere 24/7. Giving people their own agency in creating content has not increased the PSNR levels in the great vs dreck.
- yborg 3y agoI'd question the better image quality part of this, almost all broadcast providers have chosen to use their bandwidth to ship the maximum number of 480p subchannels.
- dylan604 3y agoYou can question, or you can do the A/B test yourself and no longer have it as a question. Sure, they've sub-divided their bandwidth, but their flagship station still receives much more bandwidth than your cable provider. Just do the Amazon rental for a weekend. If you don't like it, return it. You'll see the difference.
- plsmatt 3y agoThis is very much a regional thing. After the repack many markets have multiple HD channels sharing the bandwidth previously allocated for one OTA HD channel. In addition, as ATSC 3 is being deployed these channel sharing agreements are only becoming more common. In addition, some cable providers are taking this over-compressed feed and compressing it further. In many situations, streaming is the best option for picture quality now. I did some comparisons in the Philadelphia market: https://www.somesortofweatherexperiment.com/tags/tv-source-picture-quality/ https://www.somesortofweatherexperiment.com/tags/tv-source-p... Even flagship events like the Super Bowl are not exempt to from low detail, compression artifact video in this market.
- dylan604 3y agoI haven't been near broadcast engineering since the DTV transition, but at one point in time, they wanted to have dial-a-yield type of abilities for the splitting of the bandwidth. For primetime, they wanted to to be able to give the main channel a larger portion of the bandwidth when people were watching, and then during the day provide more options for people to view alternate programming. Even if you gave each of the .2-.X channels 3Mbps, that's still a lot of bandwidth in comparison for the .1 channel. Of course any live realtime encoding of 3Mbps will never rival a 3Mbps encode from someone like Netflix, but a lot of that is just SD content anyways so meh it gets.
- extragood 3y agoWhile the image quality is better (and the price difference is beyond compare), I've noticed that a lot of channels are still broadcast at 720p.
- legitster 3y ago> live TV with a much much better image quality and without cable's delay Depends. In our area they have split the digital signal so many times to carve out additional subchannels (10.1,10.2,10.3, etc) that the effective bitrate is now pretty dang low. When watching football, the channel may only be delivering 720p, and with tons of compression artifacts to boot.
- dylan604 3y agoWay back in the late 90s, the place I was working had a subscription to a trade rag called TV Broadcasting News (or something like that). I remember reading an article on how Congress was upset at the networks for splitting the bandwidth. But being feckless like Congress is, they did nothing about it and just shrugged their shoulders. Fox was famous for choosing 720p as its broadcast format specifically to get 60fps for its sports programming while the other networks chose 1080i5994.
- drewg123 3y agoNote that they have added DRM to the ATSC 3.0 standard, and its being implemented quite widely. This means that you'll be unable to freely record time shift sports using applications like MythTV, etc.
- RF_Enthusiast 3y agoThis adds an uncertain future to OTA, but I don't think you can say it's implemented widely yet. Here's a list of current ATSC 3.0 channels, with an indicator for the encrypted ones: https://www.rabbitears.info/market.php?request=atsc3 https://www.rabbitears.info/market.php?request=atsc3 For now, most network affiliates that air an ATSC 3.0 signal must simulcast the primary video programming stream in ATSC 1.0 format. So most primary channels are still available without DRM. [1] [1] https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-47/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-73/subpart-H/section-73.3801 https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-47/chapter-I/subchapter-C...
- drewg123 3y agoIn my market (Miami) almost everything is encrypted on ATSC 3. Do you know how long ATSC 1 will be up?
- RF_Enthusiast 3y agoNo, I don't. It looks like the FCC is going to let the market decide on this one. The sunset date for ATSC 1.0, meaning the date that stations can choose to turn off their ATSC 1.0, is 17 July 2027 [1]. Unfortunately, I feel that content providers have a financial incentive to discourage OTA reception. I'd take that 2027 date seriously. [1] Paragraph 39 [PDF] : https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-23-53A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-23-53A1.pdf
- bb88 3y agoUsually after a sports event is over, it's worth a lot less than when it's being played live, too. E.g. The Super Bowl's value is only worth something when people don't know what's going to happen. After the game everyone pretty much knows what has happened.