9 ms·
YouTube TV, which costs $73 a month, agrees to end "$600 less than cable" ads
- adocomplete 3y agoI was really hoping the tech giants would be able to transform live TV as opposed to offer the same experience for (now) the same price.
- ghaff 3y agoContent is king. And you can't even neatly excise sports content from everything else. If you can live without most live content, you really do have good, albeit fragmented, alternatives. But it does require giving up live TV.
- izzydata 3y agoThis just made me realize I don't believe I've ever intentionally watched live TV my entire life.
- ghaff 3y agoThat is extremely rare above a certain age. It may be more common today, especially if you make a point of avoiding sports, but there are a ton of situations in which people gravitated to live TV until very recently (when some don't now have it).
- swatcoder 3y agoIt's because the shape was due to licensing and contracts by content producers, not the technology of distribution. Online distribution licenses were underpriced and differently packaged for a while because producers didn't know what revenue to anticipate or which horse would be the best to bet on. But as the industry matured, stuff evened out again and it's mostly back to normal. Many conveniences of the new technology are nice, though.
- chung8123 3y agoNetflix did transform TV. Cable subscriptions are shrinking. Many people have switch to a streaming on demand service vs a linear service. You can watch most TV without ads.
- nicce 3y agoThat used to be the case couple years back. Now they are bringing ads to these streaming services. And you have 10 different streaming services what you need to buy separately. Soon there will be bundling streaming service and we are back to cable tv pricing and ads.
- chung8123 3y agoYou can still buy non-ad services and the amount of content you can get at one time has increased incredibly. I would also say the new format has increased the quality of content. In my personal opinion, tech has really changed the industry and how we watch tv.
- anonymoose33282 3y agoYeah we're definitely seeing a slow return to "this is on-demand cable". And all I see is that independent content (like YT videos) will continue to grow. I can definitely say that I watch probably one tenth as many shows and movies now as I did 7 or 8 years ago, simply due to how fragmented streaming services have become. I keep a Netflix subscription running for my parents, get the free few months of Apple TV every year or so from buying a new device, and beyond that I just watch more and more YouTube in my free time and go to the cinema maybe twice a year. Sure, YouTube doesn't really have any blockbuster/high-budget/studio-level content, but there's simply so much and so many niches that it keeps me entertained just as well as anything else, so I subscribe to YT premium and that's it.
- babypuncher 3y agowhich services have eliminated their ad-free options?
- 3y ago
- jayknight 3y agoI hope mlb.tv someday offers all games (without blackouts) and no commercial breaks. Just leave the cameras in the field and crowd between innings. I'd pay good money for that.
- pradn 3y agoMLB could offer a super pricy option to skip all the ads, but they wouldn’t because they can’t tell advertisers that their richest customers aren’t gonna be part of the audience. Advertising distorts the market for everyone.
- spike021 3y agoAs soon as they do I'm dropping YTTV. Fortunately I pay 1/3 the YTTV cost by sharing with a friend so the cost isn't too bad. But it's too much content for my needs, and I don't prefer sharing access.
- poulsbohemian 3y agoDude, this all day long. In this era to have blackouts is just ridiculous when consumers are willing to hand you wads of cash for your content.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- flenserboy 3y agoUnless there is true change, both in delivery & content, most everything reverts back to the way it was. Music delivery seems (semi-)permanently changed, as it is nigh unimaginable for the album as it was known to make a comeback, market-wise. No similar change has happened or been allowed to happen on the TV-heritage side of things, & so we get new, shiner versions of the Old Ways.
- paxys 3y agoTech giants have successfully transformed live TV, simply by killing it completely. No one under 35 subscribes to any kind of live TV service today other than to watch sports, and in another decade that will be fully online as well (look at the inroads Amazon and Apple are already making in that space). Some of the best new TV content is increasingly owned by Netflix, Amazon, Apple and the like. Cable TV and any kind of non-sports/special events broadcasting is going to disappear as a concept within our lifetimes.
- xwdv 3y agoCable TV will still be around for commercial settings.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoHow much of comercial settings will be eaten up be online shopping? I can’t remember the last time I went to a brick and mortar store to buy something.
- xwdv 3y agoTVs in bars is a billion dollar industry.
- kalupa 3y agoAFAIK, and I'm with you on this, that bars that have tvs have to at least pretend to pay the rights holders for playing sports on their tvs, which in turn brings people in to spend money on drinks and/or food. I can't imaging having to train every new employee on how to use the streaming-only custom set up you'd end up with without using a cable box, which, well, everyone probably already kind of knows how to operate ... at least for now. It does make me wonder how long until the new employees won't have a clue how to use a cable box due to never having used one ever.
- 13of40 3y agoBusinesses still have landline telephones too, but I feel like they're just less agile, not that they'll never catch up with the times.
- rchaud 3y ago'Disruption' is a marketing tactic these days. Netflix keeps hiking prices even though they're not paying usurious amounts to license other networks' content. Uber now isn't any cheaper than the stodgy taxis they replaced.
- scoofy 3y agoYou’re think of YouTube. The business model of television, especially live television, wasn’t really ever going to cost significantly less than it did. The inverse relationship between advertising and number of outlets would necessitate higher costs to the consumer, not lower costs. Anyone willing to create content at extremely low cost has flourished under the YouTube paradigm.
- 8bitsrule 3y ago> Anyone willing to create content at extremely low cost has flourished under the YouTube paradigm. That idea won't stand up to close scrutiny. Especially the 'Anyone' part. YouTube undoubtedly enriches itself on their efforts. If most 'Anyone's have 'fluorished' at all it's because of their viewers; most of the 'channel' owners that I've watched regularly for years rely on Patreon for support. I very much doubt that refusing ad-blockers will change any of that.
- rednerrus 3y agoYoutubeTV experience is WAY better.
- ghaff 3y agoCord-cutting (still get Internet from the cable company) has saved me a fair bit of money after I realized that I could go a month without watching a live broadcast or a show recorded on my TiVo. But you pretty much only get significant cost savings today if you're willing to do mostly without live TV 100% or jump through some hoops for a rare exception. In spite of the occasional annoyance, I'm fine with it but I realize a lot of people wouldn't be--especially for sports.
- jes5199 3y agodo people still watch live TV? I’m only exposed it to when I stay in hotels and it seems to only be Seinfeld reruns and Shark Tank
- dylan604 3y agoThere's a large population of people from a prior generation to you.
- swatcoder 3y agoIt's for sports and news (which both earn many many eyes and are most satisfying when watched live), not so much for reality or scripted productions. Even if you like channel surfing among the latter, you can do that in most service-specific streaming apps now.
- well_actulily 3y agoAt least for news, something like [PBS NewsHour](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/ https://www.pbs.org/newshour/) is available free for cord cutters. Sports, you're mostly looking at illicit streams from dodgy sites.
- ericabiz 3y agoSports fans watch a lot of live TV.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago
- dylan604 3y ago"The National Advertising Division (NAD) previously ruled in Charter's favor" HaHa! Google got kicked in the NAD[s]! Imagine that. A company having to respect the "truth in advertising" concept. Calling a company out by name with out-dated (at best) or flat out inaccurate information is ballsy, for which they deserved to get kicked squarely in for flaunting the rules everyone else plays by.
- webXL 3y ago"Charter contended the $600 figure was inaccurate, arguing that its Spectrum TV Select service in Los Angeles only cost around $219 a year more than Google's YouTube TV service," according to a MediaPost article in August. I always thought Select was considerably less than $73/mo, but just going to their site, I see that it's $59.99/mo (for 12 mos). So I guess it's jacked up after that first year. I would have settled for "$600 less than most cable"
- ylhert 3y agoIt's wild to me how much Youtube TV costs and yet they still serve you tons of ads. Coming from youtube premium where occasionally I have to skip through a preroll ad, I forget how much you are bombarded with ads while watching traditional TV. The fact that you have to pay the princely sum of $73/month on top of that boggles my mind. I canceled when they raised the price from $35/month and I'll never go back at these prices...
- colechristensen 3y agoYup, cable TV is ridiculous. Streaming, however, is doing just fine catching up with costs and playing with "ad supported" pricing levels which is only expected to spread. We're in the "eternal September" of streaming, it's only going to get worse from here.
- daveidol 3y ago> youtube premium where occasionally I have to skip through a preroll ad I thought YouTube Premium was ad-free?
- banana_giraffe 3y agoIt's free of ads from YouTube. Plenty of videos have baked in ads from the content creators themselves.
- _boffin_ 3y agoCheck out SponsorBlock.
- moelf 3y agothat's why https://sponsor.ajay.app/ https://sponsor.ajay.app/ exists
- lapetitejort 3y agoIf you dislike them, check out the SponsorBlock extension, which will skip in-video ads. While you're at it, also get DeArrow, which chooses a random frame as the thumbnail and allows community written titles that accurately describe the videos.
- xnx 3y agoI subscribe to YouTube TV but watch it less than 1/month (it's for my parents). It blows my mind that it's $60/month and still contains ads. There is nothing on TV worth sitting through ads for.
- colechristensen 3y agoOn Adult Swim, the ads are weird enough that I actually don't really mind. That's it though. I want / would use a tenth of what YouTube TV or any cable provider sells. I don't really want to spend 70 dollars a month for it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- solardev 3y agoI really wonder how much of this effect is a generation gap. I see one commercial and it drives me nuts, but my parents don't even seem to notice them. Then again I have dev coworkers who're younger than me and go like "I should really get adblock at some point" while staring down pages full of pop-ups and animated crap. Guess you really can develop banner blindness by attrition lol.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI mean that's why the ad revenue goes down over time. People get used to clicking the right X's and ignoring the garbage on the sides and in the margins, and between the actual content. Less attention. The sites respond by making the ads more egregious, more numerous and even more aggressively placed but that just trains users to click out of the new ads. Just in my lifetime I've seen the amount of ads on television increase dramatically as TV dies it's own similar death. Techy people will just install blockers which is arguably better for the advertisers, since they're at least stating outright (forcefully) that they don't want ads. That means we don't download the ads and the ads don't register an impression for us because most good adblockers also block trackers. But these people who just raw dog the internet and just walk right by? They're the ones truly decimating the value of advertising, and bless em for it. There is no win condition for the advertisers in this. None. And that's shown by how aggressive and desperate they've become for even an ounce of attention. The entire pivot to video fiasco happened because advertisers wanted video ads, because making loud, stupid, brightly colored bullshit is the only tried and true way to get attention anymore. And I'm sorry but anyone still paying for television at this point, YouTube or otherwise, is a sucker. You are paying for (probably) the largest display available in your home to at best, 2/5 of the time bombard your senses with an assault of garbage, between entertainment. Entertainment that can be had much cheaper, without the assault elsewhere with basic technology. And if that's fine with you then by all means, it ain't my money, enjoy yourself but I cannot put myself in your shoes and make it make sense to me.
- jordanmorgan10 3y agoI’m subscribed to them for the same reason I was subscribed to DirecTV for a decade - they have a monopoly on Sunday Ticket. Oh, how I yearn for Sunday Ticket to just be its own entity so I didn’t have to buy another service.
- halfmatthalfcat 3y agoI know not exactly what you're looking for but I bought RedZone for the first time through the NFL+ app this year and it's so nice to just have that and not fuss with any other service.
- bdcravens 3y agoSunday Ticket is different than RedZone. RedZone is a single channel that jumps between games; Sunday Ticket gives you unfettered access to all games.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoEven Sunday Ticket does not give you access to all the games. https://tv.youtube.com/learn/nflsundayticket/ https://tv.youtube.com/learn/nflsundayticket/ >NFL Sunday Ticket: Every out-of-market Sunday game[1] >[1] Locally broadcast Fox and CBS games, Sunday Night Football on NBC, select digital-only games and international games excluded
- bdcravens 3y agoSure, but it does give you the lion's share, whereas Red Zone is really just one show, six hours on Sundays (and occasionally Saturday)
- halfmatthalfcat 3y agoRight, which is why I said “not exactly what you’re looking for”. Was just highlighting that RedZone is purchasable *independently* through an app with little to no fuss.
- 3y ago
- simpaticoder 3y agoSubscription cost for entertainment is so high, and the quality of entertainment is so low, I can't help but think that most people keep these subscriptions purely out of habit and a BIG shift in consumption patterns is bound to occur. The shift will be to offline, generative software, or offline physical media. Online consumption will be limited to periodic cheap/free options like PBS Newshour, PBS Kids, newsletters, podcasts, and similar. Ideally we'd even see a re-uptake of media like a daily local or regional paper. Personally, I think this shift could really improve society, the state of people's minds, and encourage more offline time without some draconian top-down time-limit. And all thanks to increasing the price and decreasing the quality of streaming content until you break the relationship. Cool!
- pythonguython 3y agoJust because it’s expensive and low quality doesn’t mean people will stop using it - even if they recognize that. Based on the trends in entertainment over the last 70 years, I’d wager that entertainment will only be filled with more ads will be less substantive. I also think offline generative content will never happen. Will everyone have a gpu cluster in their home to run it? Generative content is certainly coming, but it will come though YouTube, Instagram, and whatever openAI has planned
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lapetitejort 3y agoThis is a reminder to check out your local library. Not only do they have tons of physical media (in some cases current movies and TV shows in disc format) but you may also get access to Hoopla, Libby, and/or Kanopy which are free apps where you can borrow all sorts of digital items. Some libraries also have a Library of Things, which lend out a random assortment of objects. I've seen musical instruments, baby monitors, cake tins, etc.
- dcdevito 3y ago[dead]
- stuaxo 3y agoHow much a month? That is insane.
- lionkor 3y agoU+1F3F4 U+200D U+2620 U+FE0F
- bentt 3y agoI pay $73 a month to watch 1 Liverpool game a week (max), 1 Buffalo Bills game per week (maybe), and a smattering of NBA games. I'd so much rather just give the money directly to the teams and/or leagues.
- hellogoodbye 3y agoTo watch your EPL team you need Youtube TV, Peacock Premium, Paramount Plus (UCL/UEL) and ESPN plus (domestic cups) :/ Youtube TV is the most expensive of the bunch, going to see if there are any other options like IPTV
- s17n 3y agoIt would be nice if they offered pay per view access for those of us who only want to watch live tv maybe a couple times a year. I can see why they don’t bother though (obviously no real money in it).
- daft_pink 3y agoThey contest Youtube's non-transparency, but their total non-transparency on not disclosing fees, totally fine.
- karaterobot 3y ago> "Charter contended the $600 figure was inaccurate, arguing that its Spectrum TV Select service in Los Angeles only cost around $219 a year more than Google's YouTube TV service," according to a MediaPost article in August. Google should have just agreed to do a find and replace in their ad copy.
- Aaronstotle 3y agoI will cancel Youtube TV after the superbowl
- jayknight 3y agoI signed up for sling for October to watch the baseball postseason, it's gone after that.
- babypuncher 3y agoYouTube TV is still cable, just delivered differently. For that reason, it was DOA in my eyes. My problem with cable was never necessarily the price (though that was a big factor), but the linear, scheduled nature of the whole thing. I don't know why some companies keep clinging to this dated distribution model well more than a decade after Netflix showed everyone how to do it better.
- stronglikedan 3y agoBecause there's enough people like me to make it profitable. I don't want to feel committed every time I turn on the TV. Sometimes I just like to watch whatever's on, carefree. Different strokes, all equally valid.
- tzs 3y agoSimilarly, I've got the first 20 or so seasons of The Simpsons on DVD, and after watching them once with the commentary on I never watched them again. But I would watch the two episodes a day that my local Fox affiliate would broadcast. If I actually pick a specific episode to watch (or nowadays to stream) it somewhere seems like I need to pay more attention to it than when I was watching a regularly scheduled syndicated episode. With the later it puts me in the same mindset as listening to radio...a casual thing that I might multitask with other things, such as reading or doing a crossword puzzle.
- babypuncher 3y agothe shuffle button in plex serves this purpose, it's a shame few commercial streaming services offer this.
- charlesray 3y agoBaffled by the number of people itt saying "I can't believe it costs that much and still has ads." It can't not have ads. It's cable TV, YouTube has zero control over whether or not it has ads. They can't broadcast the USA network without ads. Cable has had ads for like 40 years, and traditional cable providers are much more expensive than this. Are y'all 14 years old? idgi
- superjared 3y agoYouTube TV injects ads on certain content. I know it's there for on-demand TV shows, and some live sports. It's literally overlaid on top of the channel's ads in the live example. I think years ago when I first subscribed one of the major benefits was the ability to skip through these ads just like DVR, but you can no longer do that.
- mucle6 3y agoI thought you could skip ads in dvr?
- rchaud 3y agoYou can, but not while watching live TV.
- charlesray 3y agoCable TV broadcasts include both the network's ads and slots for the carrier to run their own ads. They're not inserting bonus ads on top of the actual content. Again, this is exactly the same as any cable provider has always worked.
- superjared 3y ago> Again, this is exactly the same as any cable provider has always worked. Arguably we don't _want_ the same as any cable provider has always worked.
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoUse AdGuard and SponsorBlock on macOS. It's really increased my YouTube browsing quality of life.
- carleton 3y agoThis doesn’t have anything to do with YouTube TV. SponsorBlock and AdGuard have no effect on YTTV, only regular YouTube.
- bdcravens 3y agoPlaystation Vue was a great service. Since then streaming "TV" has become less of a value. Currently we get sling, which is $45 for the typical mainstream cable channels and 2 local channels (ABC and Fox). HuluTV is ok, since it includes Disney+, but about the same price as YouTubeTV. DirectTV Stream is a very complete offering, but barely cheaper than cable (and only because of the lack of equipment fees and taxes)
- paxys 3y agoAre people here really so young that they never had to deal with traditional cable subscriptions? Let me tell you what it was like. You signed up for Comcast, paid a $50+ installation fee, prayed that the technician would even show up in the allotted window, paid $100-150 month for basic service, paid for a cable box/modem rental, paid for HD, paid for DVR, paid for each extra TV in your house, paid for premium channels, paid for on-demand, paid for sports packages, and then watched a shit load of ads to cap it all off. Complaining that YouTube TV is too pricey or is making things worse just shows that you don't know of the media world outside of YouTube and Netflix.
- NegativeK 3y agoWe were paying about $350 for internet + the full package to get sports. Now it's $60 for faster internet and $73 for TV. The ads are infuriating, but it's less than half the cost for pretty much the same TV experience. This is a very clear upgrade.
- bdcravens 3y agoCorrect, but there are cheaper options. Additionally, you can self-install cable these days in many places. With streaming services you still have to pay for certain sports packages and premiums. Most people who stream are still paying the Internet fees and modem rental. Some streaming services will sell you equipment (for instance, DirecTV Stream has a set-top box that isn't required, but actually behaves more like traditional cable instead of having to navigate to a separate app)
- maest 3y ago...in the US.
- time0ut 3y agoAh, don’t forget the incredible experience of calling Comcast customer service because your special promotional rate expired and your monthly bill went up 25%, or the free HBO promotion that you couldn’t opt out of expired and you are paying $10 more, or any of half a dozen other anti consumer nonsense some scumbag at Comcast dreamt up. The most outrageous was one some Comcast rep called me to tell me I qualified for a free DVR upgrade because I was such a loyal customer. By loyal I guess they meant captive, but ok. I don’t watch TV and only had a TV package cause it was somehow cheaper than just internet due to some promotion, but sure whatever. Turns out by free he meant like an extra $30 per month. Took me a few billing cycles to notice. I had never even unboxed it. They refunded me after several hours on the phone. I should have invoiced them for my time. I got rid of them as soon as I had an alternative.
- antisthenes 3y agoI just don't understand the value prop of YT TV. It seems like the exact cable TV model that all the streaming services were supposed to disrupt and put in the ground (eventually). But then again, I'm probably not the primary user of the service anyway.
- dumbfounder 3y agoI was an early cord cutter, maybe 10 years ago. Then I cut linear because we rarely watched it, and the promotion I had for directv streaming expired (was getting an amazing deal at $10 for directv stream, + hbo with the at&t unlimited mobile plan). I now only want linear tv for NFL, but I tried every which way to see how I could spend as little as possible, but I can't get it any cheaper than about $60/month. I am not spending that just to watch football. And then you also need prime for thursday. And something else for red zone. And you need to make sure you get ESPN. But not ESPN+ because that's worthless. And not NFL+, what the heck is that? It's all absurd and I hate it. I now use some free iptv sources to watch games. Quality isn't awesome, but the price is right. The way I see it, they have driven me to it.
- DonnyV 3y agoI think the best hack I've found is get cable and a TiVo with a life time subscription. Now I get the same or more content then YouTube and no commercials because TiVo has a commercial skip feature. I also don't have to pay for hardware for my cable connection because they have to give me 1 free cable card by law. I just insert that into my TiVo.
- ThatPlayer 3y ago> they have to give me 1 free cable card by law. At least in the US, that is no longer the case. The FCC dropped the cable card in 2020. HDHomeRun cancelled their newer cable 6 tuner on that news. I was looking into getting one for a Plex server at the time.
- DonnyV 3y agoUgh...I also have a Plex server.
- ThatPlayer 3y agoWell if you still have the cable card, you can still get their older HDHomeRun tuner that only has 3 tuners (the cancelled one did 6 streams at once) and use that in Plex.
- simonsarris 3y agoI strongly recommend cancelling all your subscription services and seeing how long you can go without renewing any of them. Try no TV, really none at all, for a month and see how it feels. Ask yourself at the end: How did you spend your time differently?
- slothtrop 3y agoWith habit-forming I think it helps to first start by adding other activities in rotation rather than just eliminating one. I can already answer this one: it would be internet-use. My sedentary time is still going to be sedentary time, that's how I want it. I'm not going to chase productivity and socializing for all the leisure time I can spare.
- Minor49er 3y agoOr at least the in-between option: Use the savings from cutting the subscription services to run your own NAS at home and locally stream whatever movies or shows you own
- dmonitor 3y agoPlex and Jellyfin are a great user experience. Even my non-technical friends have no issues accessing content on it.
- Moldoteck 3y agoImo the only subscription worth it for me is yt premium with sponsorblock combo. And yt music is a nice addition, ofc not Spotify's lvl, but i don't really listen to that much new music
- choppaface 3y agoThey also lied about having better quality than cable. They only do 720p while comcast does 1080. Also their customer service is crazy bad. Did the stream fail for the 5th time? Ok give me all your browser info because of course we didn’t collect that and fingerprint you in the error reporting form you just filed.
- redog 3y agoTivo betrayed us. Bloop bloop
- PeterStuer 3y agoI worked on research projects with large traditional live TV broadcasters. Their viewer demographic was 56+ and aging year by year. Even in those early days of Twitch top online streamers were attracting larger audiences than their top programs and that was not even on their radar.