3 ms·
> Unlike previous hype cycles, the potential value of this one is extraordinary if it’s actually unlocked That was also true, in AI, of the expert-system hype
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Unlike previous hype cycles, the potential value of this one is extraordinary if it’s actually unlocked
That was also true, in AI, of the expert-system hype cycle. And the actual value unlocked was extraordinary, just not at the scale people saw as the potential.
Actually, it was seen as true of all of the hype cycles during the hype cycle, that's what makes it a hype cycle.
> (I mean, what was the theoretical upper limit on the benefit of cryptocurrency for the world? Probably not that much.)
If you believed the people that were as breathless about it as you are about the current AI hype cycle, basically infinite, unlocking ways human potential and interactions, economic and otherwise, are held back by centralized and/or authoritarian systems.
That's what made it a hype cycle.
> It’s quite possible that we already have sufficient computational power and the necessary data for AGI—all we need are the right algorithms.
Yeah, but that's always been true. If software-only AGI is possible, we've always had the data in the natural world, and with no strong theoretical model for the necessary computational power, its always been possible we had enough. What we clearly lacked were the right algorithms (oh, and any reason to believe software-only AGI was possible.)
- somestag 3y agoI think I agree with basically your whole comment but I'm wondering if you could explain what you mean by "software-only AGI". Obviously all software runs on hardware, and creating specialized hardware to run certain types of software is something the computing industry is already very familiar with. In the far far future, if we did crack AGI, it's not impossible to believe that specialized hardware modules would be built to enable AGI to interface with a "normal" home computer, much like we already add modules to our computers for specialized applications. Would this still count as software-only AI to you? I've held for a long time that sensory input and real-world agency might be necessary to grow intelligence, so maybe you mean something like that, but even then that's something not incredibly outside the realm of what regular computers could do with some expansion.
- dragonwriter 3y agoThere's some discussion of embodiment as an important factor in intelligence such that it would defy pure software implementation. I’m personally of the opinion that even to the extent this is true, it probably just means the compute capacity required for software is higher than we might otherwise think, to simulate the other parts, alternatively, with the right interfaces and hardware, we don't need that cheat. But “everything involved can be simulated in software at the required level”, while I believe it, somewhat speculative.
- dmbche 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portia_(spider) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portia_(spider) This spider could be evidence of "software based intelligence" in biological brains - it exhibits much more complex behaviors than other animals it's size, more comparable to cats and dogs. What I mean is that some believe that their brain is "emulating" all parts of the larger "brain", but one at a time, and passing the "data" that comes out of one into the next. Just a cool thing.