3 ms·
If we give each a cubic kilometre keep-out zone, then we can put up 500 billion between 300 and 1300 kilometre altitude. A cubic kilometre keep out zone is pre
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
If we give each a cubic kilometre keep-out zone, then we can put up 500 billion between 300 and 1300 kilometre altitude.
A cubic kilometre keep out zone is pretty generous, we could probably put in trillions if needed.
- demondemidi 3y agoHow do you keep each satellite in its own cubic kilometer? How do you know that is "pretty generous"? Why not .5cukm or 2cukm?
- rob74 3y agoIf all those satellites were static instead of zipping around at several tens of thousands of miles per hour, that would work out...
- panick21_ 3y agoExcept sats have a very predictable path so its not actually that difficult, stationary or not. The system of airplane management is 1000x more complex.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoSatellite paths are only predictable in the short term. Predicting satellite paths beyond about a week is not possible unless you're comfortable with huge amounts of uncertainty. Newtonian physics says that ideal two-body problems are predictable to any point in the future. But ideal two-body problems exist nowhere in the universe, especially in near-earth orbit.
- mcpackieh 3y agoGood thing we have radar.
- twic 3y agoIf you actually know about this stuff, i would be very interested to hear the reasoning behind a cubic kilometre being a generous keep-out zone (and cubic kilometres even being a sensible unit for a keep-out zone). Since this is HN, my guess is you don't, but i would love to be wrong for once.
- photonbeam 3y agoLess keep-out is needed for altitude compared to plane Source: I watched a Scott Manley video once
- TrapLord_Rhodo 3y ago>Since this is HN, my guess is you don't, but i would love to be wrong for once. Why are you on HN if you truly believe this? To talk shit on HN? HN is the exact opposite. I can also say with 100% certainty, tons of SpaceX/Tesla employees browse HN to take breaks.
- twic 3y agoI'm on HN because the links are interesting. If there are real SpaceX employees who know about this, let's hear from them. The huge majority of comments on this piece right now are from people who know nothing about the subject - the same as on every post.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoYou need a lot more than a cubic kilometer per satellite, because you need an entire orbit around the planet. You can't have one row of satellites orbit at the equator, and another row orbit at 40 degrees north latitude. A row is already difficult, they catch up with each other quickly just due to random perturbations and elevation differences. Instead, each wrap of your ball of yarn crosses over the others. Each row intersects most other rows.