8 ms·
Counterpoint: electricity markets are terrible for reliability. Markets are great, but there are no pricing signals for reliability. You won't know that your g
by cyberax 3y ago
Counterpoint: electricity markets are terrible for reliability.
Markets are great, but there are no pricing signals for reliability. You won't know that your grid will collapse at the first strong breeze, until it happens (see: Texas).
Theoretically, it can work because companies might invest in reliable generation, in the hopes of getting $$$$$$$$$ when the spot price goes up through the roof. But in practice, pretty much nobody wants to wait 5-10 years between "income events".
And it's even worse in Europe. It's just a story of utter market failure.
- DeRock 3y agoThere are capacity markets, and the article spends a good portion talking about them (or more specifically why they believe energy only markets are superior).
- alphager 3y agoHow is it worse in Europe? Where in Europe is it worse? I can't remember the last time the grid failed.
- sfn42 3y agoNot sure what OP refers to but it isn't very long ago that we were paying over a dollar per kwh in Norway. We've always had extremely low energy prices due to our abundant hydroelectric power etc, but now it's all being sold to Germany or whatever and we get to buy their coal power for 30 times the price we're used to.
- theshrike79 3y agoYea, that was when we refused to buy natural gas from a dictator attacking sovereign countries. And due to how the market was built, Germany's over-reliance on Russian gas affected everyone for a good while. On the other hand I've been enjoying pretty much free electricity for about 6 months now. A few rare spikes up to 40c/kWh, but it's mostly been under 1c/kWh.
- yunohn 3y ago> A few rare spikes up to 40c/kWh, but it's mostly been under 1c/kWh. The cheapest rate I can get in NL is ~30c/kwh, and that’s with a dynamic price contract. The government has applied an artificial limit of 40c/kwh for 2023, after energy companies here fleeced everyone last year. Unfortunately, it expires by 2024. The worst part is that NL privatized the energy market long ago, to give people “choice” - which has only led to coordinated exorbitant pricing.
- tuukkah 3y agoFinland now has the opposite problem where the market price is negative at times. Our neighbours (Sweden, Estonia) are not able to import as much as we produce excess on good days. Luckily, more cables are being built and the variably cheap electricity attracts new industry that can make use of it (green hydrogen and green steel production).
- yurishimo 3y agoI was one of those people who got fleeced. I moved here in the fall of 2022, right before winter started. My monthly fee to Vattenfall was €400/mo for an "A" rated new build apartment of 90m2. I had just moved and didn't know any better. I knew the war was contributing to energy prices but I had no idea to what extent. Last winter, we kept the heat on to a minimum and tried to keep the lights off. Really, the killer was the price of gas for heating (in-floor) and hot water. But even by comparison, my 20 minute hot shower once every 2-3 days wasn't really the issue. Our "usage" for January was over €550. Luckily, I used basically nothing the first two months I lived here so it averaged out so I didn't need to pay anything. Had I known what I know now, I would have purchased electric space heaters and ran them 24/7... it probably would have been cheaper and I could have walked around my apartment naked while it was -2 outside. I've switched to Tibber (Swedish company I think?) on a variable rate plan and have been much happier. It would be one thing if I could have locked in a rate at Vattenfall, but even that wasn't possible. You still pay out the ass for all of your usage, so I might as well not overpay when it's cheaper to produce. In the meantime, I'm saving some money each month for winter and will still likely invest in a couple of space heaters since the price of natural gas is still pretty high. Now we've seen what some families have had to deal with paying their year-end balances and that is/should be criminal. I've seen people receiving bills for thousands of Euros. Their only crime was living in an older home with 2 kids. Got forbid you want your family to be clean and warm! I understand there is some personal responsibility to be taken, but obviously something went very very wrong.
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoFrom the market's point of view selling to Germany distributes the goods more efficiently. Germans don't freeze in the Winter, while you don't keep office buildings lit up at night just because electricity is cheap. It feels like you're losing here, but on average everyone wins. (also, there's the whole invasion of Ukraine going on, which has caused a massive disruption to the market)
- guappa 3y agoOh the offices are all on at night. No worries there.
- baq 3y agoCan’t for the life of me understand that particular Scandinavian peculiarity in what would seem otherwise very rational society. I assume it must have been logical or still is?
- guappa 3y agoTo be honest I have no idea. I'm baffled/enraged to walk at night and see rows of tall buildings completely lit up with nobody inside. It's basically impossible to see anything in the sky other than Jupiter here, because of the insane light pollution.
- vegardx 3y agoFor most homes and offices the primary source of heating is electrical, so in the winter it doens't really make much difference whether you turn the lights off or not, heat is heat. In the summer there's no excuse though. Old habits die hard, or something like that. That said, modern LED-lighting doesn't really use that much electricity, all lights in my apartment use a total of 100Wh, or 75kWh per month. I could turn off all lights in my apartment for a year and it still wouldn't be close to the energy needed for a single transaction on the bitcoin blockchain. But clearly some speculative investment has more utility than me not stumping my toe when going to the bathroom at night.
- wewxjfq 3y agoNorway had trouble with hydro power because of low water levels. Compared to 2021, hydro power was down 10%, imports went up by 60%, and exports remained the same. And for the record, Germany didn't have any trouble with electricity last year, they exported records amounts of it, even increased the usage of gas to meet other countries' demands. Germany exported more electricity to Luxemburg than Norway exported to Germany - and while it seems popular for Norwegians here to claim that Germany wrecked their electricity market, I've yet to see a German claim that little Luxemburg caused electricity prices to explode in Germany.
- sfn42 3y agoI'm not saying it's Germany's fault, we're the ones selling them energy. Or rather a couple rich guys make shitloads of money while everyone else pays for their profits. Nothing against Germany.
- haakonhr 3y agoBy "a couple of rich guys" are you referring to the fact that roughly 90% of all power production capacity is owned by the public via municipalities, regions and the state? (https://energifaktanorge.no/en/om-energisektoren/eierskap-i-kraftsektoren/ https://energifaktanorge.no/en/om-energisektoren/eierskap-i-...)
- Roark66 3y agoExactly. If anything the electricity markets in Europe prove the point they can work.
- devjab 3y agoIt sort of depends on what you mean by markets. In most places in Europe the production of power is on the market, but the actual power grid is not freely traded. The grid is instead handed out to semi-permanent monopolies that are heavily regulated and controlled by governments and/or non-profit NGOs that are essentially a way we do efficient government in the supply sector. It works, but the benefit isn’t usually to the consumers despite that being the intention. We’re currently seeing a load of insider trading and price manipulation cases roll into court after the price hikes following last years gas craze, and over all, power prices haven’t really gone down. In many ways it’s mostly been a way to divert public money from the public services and into private investors. The way I pay for my electricity is that I pay for the grid, which is the non-freely-privatised part of your electricity market and makes up around 50% of my bill. Before it was privatised it was 90% less expensive. The other 50% is the actual electricity that I buy, we currently buy ours from a company of two people who buy and sell electricity on the European markets. This part is cheaper than it was before it was privatised, but the profits go to those two people and not into advancement of our electric grid. The prices of electricity are also sort of heavily dependent on the government. A huge part of the income you get from running something like a solar plant is often going to be tariff because the EU can’t/won’t allow green energy to be traded freely as it would bankrupt fossil fuel plants, and you sort of need those since they can scale power at any time. Of course if it wasn’t privatised you could spend those tariffs, green euro and other subsidies on actually building the sector like you did with nuclear and fossil fuels. Not that I mind, I work in an investment bank that builds energy plants and sell them, so it’s good money, but it’s also sort of silly financially. Like in Germany you have Tariffs where you only get the tariff if you don’t exceed the production max that’s set politically. So if you produce up to 99.9% you get your free money, but if you produce 100.1% you get zero tariff money. You obviously still get paid from the electricity production at whatever rate it’s capped at, at any given time. Then on top of that the government is paying you to shut down production during peaks so you don’t flood the European grid beyond capacity. Which is fine for us, but also sort of silly for consumers since it’s their tax money that’s basically used to make energy production a lucrative business for us. So yeah, it works, there is a lot of money in it, and a lot of job creation, but it’s not really a net benefit for your consumers.
- guappa 3y ago> I can't remember the last time the grid failed. In Italy, multiple days in July, in some areas.
- Faaak 3y agoYou're mixing up "the grid" (TSO) with your local delivery (DSO). The first one didn't fail recently. The second one depends on your distribution operator and is not on the market.
- cyberax 3y agoEurope is worse in carbon-free transition. The grid itself is fine, but it's backed by fossil fuels with no way out.
- tuukkah 3y agoWhat do you mean there's no way out? Some European countries have already stopped using fossil fuels, some are making good progress, in some the progress has recently stalled, some haven't really started yet... Cheap electricity is going to be important for national economies and there are no countries that couldn't build cheap wind and solar (and/or cables to import neighbours' excess renewables production).
- cyberax 3y ago> Some European countries have already stopped using fossil fuels Yes, the ones that have classic hydro. > Cheap electricity is going to be important for national economies and there are no countries that couldn't build cheap wind and solar (and/or cables to import neighbours' excess renewables production). Solar and wind ARE NOT cheap if you actually want them to be reliable. They are about 5x-10x more expensive than nuclear power in this case. The problem is called Dunkelflaute. Here's an actual example: https://energy-charts.info/charts/power/chart.htm?l=de&c=DE&stacking=stacked_absolute_area&interval=month&year=2019&month=01&source=sw https://energy-charts.info/charts/power/chart.htm?l=de&c=DE&... - renewable generation mostly disappeared for a week from 18-th to 25-th. These kinds of events happen almost every year, and often more than once. Worst-case modelling shows that Germany can get about a _month_ of sustained Dunkelflaute about once in a century.
- tuukkah 3y agoWe are not stuck and these issues are solvable (as much as they exist): trade of electricity with neighbouring countries, storage etc. For example, a simple thing where Germany could try to follow the Nordic countries is heat pump installations to keep houses warm without fossil fuels.
- Maakuth 3y agoMore cross-border capacity would help with reliability as well as making the investments' profitability easier to estimate. This is something Europe at least is investing in.
- Animats 3y agoPJM does have pricing for reliability. The first California deregulated electricity market had an auction every half hour and all pricing was spot. This caused blackouts and the bankruptcy of Pacific Gas and Electric, even though it was what PG&E had lobbied for. Today, most markets (at least PJM and CAISO) have a "day ahead" auction, and a current auction to fine-tune. Most of the market is in the day-ahead auction. This seems to have reasonable stability. I've read that the overall effect of electricity deregulation is that prices are slightly lower, and reliability is down. Rate-of-return regulation encourages utilities to overbuild somewhat, which is not necessarily a bad thing. Beats under-building.
- andromeduck 3y agoDay ahead isn't enough. Need capacity markets & year ahead futures from what I remember last time I read up.
- everybodyknows 3y agoCalifornia providers are required to purchase "Resource Adequacy" contracts. Those that are badly managed try to dodge the expense, rather like operating a business without insurance: https://thecoastnews.com/cpuc-issues-over-1-million-in-fines-to-san-diego-community-power/ https://thecoastnews.com/cpuc-issues-over-1-million-in-fines...
- mschaef 3y agoIIRC, the only US ISO without a capacity market is ERCOT (TX). They let the marginal rates go higher on the theory that it will create an incentive for construction of generation to address anticipated capacity constraints.
- vlovich123 3y agoWeren’t the California brownouts caused by Enron fucking with California’s supply to cause them to purchase electricity from Texas at insanely high rates. Also led to Gray Davis being recalled which must have been a nice bonus because the Bush administration was very allied with Enron execs.
- hef19898 3y agoActually, electricity markets in Europe work just fine, and provide in fact a lot of required stability. And income events are pretty much instantanious. The only problem European markets have is way too low costs for CO2 certificates which make coal plants way to cheap. Other than that, they work just fine.
- cyberax 3y agoNope. They are not fine. Europe is floundering with its renewable transition. Right now it's easy to build tons of cheap low-quality wind or solar generation, but it's not economic to build any kind of storage. As a result, Europe is now dependent on natural gas and coal during the winter. And there's nothing that can change that within the next decade.
- hef19898 3y agoStrong claims. Any evidence to back them up, besides "Germany shutting nuclear stupid"?
- cyberax 3y agoGermany is the main culprit. There's no plan for fossil fuel phaseout in Germany, or for most of the European countries that are not blessed with almost limitless hydroenergy. Cheap renewables allowed Europe to quickly slash some emissions, but now they're hitting a hard wall of reality: the wintertime sucks for renewables in Europe.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoEurope has a very robust energy market. The Ukrainian war put a lot of stress on it last winter. The lights stayed on. Sure prices rose a little and that sent off a strong price signal for people to conserve energy and invest in alternative solutions. Exactly what you'd hope for in a well functioning market. The European market is all interconnected. You might get electrons from Norwegian hydro, German or Danish wind, or Spanish solar. Or a mix of all of those. And of course there are loads of coal, nuclear, and gas plants connected to the grid as well. There's plenty of generation capacity. The main technical challenge is cables, not generation. More cables means better energy distribution and more competitive pricing. A lot of French nuclear plants being down for maintenance right in the middle of the Ukrainian crisis did not result in rolling blackouts. Instead it resulted price signals for others to step up their energy production and serve that demand. The bad thing was that that was German coal. But the good thing is that it worked. Coal is expensive, so the price signals exist to get rid of it. Renewables are cheap, so there's a shift from coal to renewables in most places with a functioning market. The European energy market is much more dynamic than the US. In the US you have Texas basically disconnected from the rest of the US market for ideological reasons and local monopolists both setting prices and dictating what home owners can and cannot do with things like solar. The Texas grid collapsed there when it got a bit cold and gas pipes and coal piles froze up. The local monopolists created a price signal but were not able to produce the required energy supply. And as they were unable to import any energy, they had to do rolling blackouts. They should be exporting clean energy most of the time. There's plenty of it. Why is that not a thing? Don't they like money there? Classic example of a broken market. The fix is changing the policies that prevent competitors from challenging the status quo. There's no shortage of entrepreneurs in Texas. They could fix it in no time.
- stuaxo 3y agoIn the UK at least - The prices were put up before the Ukrainian war, but then that was used as an excuse.
- londons_explore 3y ago> pretty much nobody wants to wait 5-10 years between "income events". Insurance is a similar market - and big earthquakes might wipe out a whole decades profits. Yet there are still plenty of players in that market.
- Kbelicius 3y ago> Insurance is a similar market - and big earthquakes might wipe out a whole decades profits. So not similar but reveres. Big earthquake is an "expenditure event" for an insurance company, not an "income event".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sidewndr46 3y agoThe Texas grid has not suffered any collapses that I am aware of
- mschaef 3y ago? I can think of at least three. (1989, 2011, 2021) Maybe you can quibble over the definition of 'collapse', but in each of those three events there was a significant inability of the grid to meet demand (and subsequent involuntary demand curtailment).
- ajuc 3y agoI'm not sure about USA but in Poland whoever mispredicted production/consumption - pays for balancing the network back. So there's quite strong incentive for reliable predictions.
- ulkhf 3y agoWhen sources were inherently dispatchable, like coal/oil/gas, reliability was free. Markets have not been updated to reflect the value of reliability. It may be just an oversight of slow moving regulators. Or it may be intentional to allow the growth of unreliable wind and solar without making them bear their own cost of unreliability.