3 ms·
Funny, I asked here on HN just a couple of months ago why nobody has done something like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37286891 https://news.ycomb
by crazygringo 3y ago
Funny, I asked here on HN just a couple of months ago why nobody has done something like this:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37286891 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37286891
The user 'pessimizer' replied that there was a company OptiFont that seemed to do something just like this, to sell cheap font clones:
http://abfonts.freehostia.com/opti/ http://abfonts.freehostia.com/opti/
http://luc.devroye.org/fonts-27506.html http://luc.devroye.org/fonts-27506.html
It still seems so relatively trivial to automate this -- just render every character on a <canvas> at a fixed known font size at super-high resolution and autotrace outlines, and render every character pair to figure out kerning, and the common ligatures. The only major thing missing is hinting, but that's irrelevant for printed material and not very important on retina screens -- and auto-hinting gets you more than halfway there on non-retina. (And then there are all sorts of special font features like nonstandard ligatures, which can either be more carefully replicated, or just ignored.)
I'm not saying it would be a good/ethical thing to do this (I personally want designers to be supported) -- but I am kind of amazed that the market for digital fonts still exists, when in theory you can produce a perfectly legal copy and not pay a thing.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoYour approach would result in impossibly large binary font sizes unless a really good (smart) engine was present and utilized to separate the hinting logic from the underlying symbols. Then again, with most fonts these days putting in zero manual hinting work and just relying on the default font engine heuristics, it might not.
- crazygringo 3y agoI was supposing zero hinting information would be included, so the file sizes should be perfectly normal. Because while font glyphs/designs aren't copyrightable, I'm assuming that hinting instructions are, even if they could be reverse-engineered this way.
- quitit 3y ago>but I am kind of amazed that the market for digital fonts still exists, when in theory you can produce a perfectly legal copy and not pay a thing. There is a growing trend for style guides to use typefaces from no-cost or open libraries. This isn't limited to small companies either, I can think of a handful of industry heavyweights in tech, food and medicine who each have taken up this approach. This forms the first reason not to dupe fonts, because there's plenty of good ones already available for no cost. I've found that companies that do this have an easier time of staying on brand since it's so simple to obtain the necessary fonts. As for seeking out deliberate copies of popular fonts, there's a few reasons why an agency wouldn't want to propose this: 1. It's easier to sell in a well loved font, with a proven character from a foundry with heritage. Imagine talking to a board of suits, they're often looking for the safe option. 2. It's kind of a dick move for an agency to be ripping off the foundries, especially small modern ones. Creatives do enjoy what typographers make and can see the love put into their craft. 3. Typographers are not faceless. Modern font designers are still alive and active on socials, you might personally know who you are ripping off. 4. There's a bit of hypocrisy in hating on frankenfonts such as Arial, while deliberately seeking out dupes. 5. It's trivial to open a font in a font editor and resave it with different specs, if a creative wants to be sneaky they can just do this themselves anyway. 6. Adobe have also thrown their hat into this ring by offering a range of popular fonts available for use for no extra cost with their creative cloud subscription. It's not needed to seek out a dupe-font, when the real thing is available with a few clicks.
- codedokode 3y ago> It's kind of a dick move for an agency to be ripping off the foundries, especially small modern ones. Creatives do enjoy what typographers make and can see the love put into their craft. But foundries sometimes do the same: they take samples of, say, 18th century font, and digitize it, and claim copyright. Do you think it is fair when someone copies Helvetica or 19th century Bookman [1] ? [1] https://learn.microsoft.com/ru-ru/typography/font-list/bookman-old-style https://learn.microsoft.com/ru-ru/typography/font-list/bookm...
- sleepybrett 3y ago