8 ms·
Europe gives Mark Zuckerberg 24 hours to respond about Israel-Hamas conflict
- jruohonen 3y ago"In addition to disinformation surrounding the conflict in Israel, Breton wrote that the EU had received reports of manipulated content and deepfakes on Meta's platforms ahead of the recent election in Slovakia. He said that misinformation about elections is taken "extremely seriously" under the DSA." The recent Slovak elections are indeed a good example of things to come.
- clubm8 3y ago>misinformation about elections is taken "extremely seriously" under the DSA Speaking as a card carrying DSA member who primaried many folks... well actually my wallet was stolen but you get the idea... Speaking as someone who joined the DSA post Trump... people tend to get really pissy if you accuse them of being a Russian robot one too many times :-)
- ComputerGuru 3y agoThe DSA you speak of is not the DSA (Digital Services Act) the article refers to. (I didn’t downvote, fwiw.)
- clubm8 3y agoYou can vote however you want, it was a small joke. I was drawing attention to the fact that "disinformation" is at it's core, someone who has no right to vote in an election trying to influence those who do, and how we often paint lawful, protected speech as disinformation, either by direct retorts "Russian bot!" or... downvoting. Vote however you want friends, I play by "Whose Line" rules -- it's all made up and the points don't matter... hence accounting for the multi year GAP in my posts.
- jruohonen 3y ago> I was drawing attention to the fact that "disinformation" is at it's core, someone who has no right to vote in an election trying to influence those who do While the terminology is still awful, I think this was an insightful attempt toward trying to frame the issue as exported propaganda by foreign actors.
- clubm8 3y ago>while the terminology is still awful, I think this was an insightful attempt toward trying to frame the issue as exported propaganda by foreign actors thank you. i need to be more diplomatic, but i don't like having my patriotism questioned when i haven't left the country since the obama administration and i have to admit, i went to a dark place after feeling like my advice was repeatedly ignored in parallel with my integrity being questioned. but... yeah... i DO need to joke less.
- jruohonen 3y ago> but... yeah... i DO need to joke less. Please don't; I thought it was funny once I understood what you meant by DSA. By awful terminology, I referred to the whole concept of disinformation (and misinformation and whatnot).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gambiting 3y agoWhat's DSA?
- r00fus 3y agoDSA = Digital Services Act (original context) replied to by someone using DSA = Democratic Socialist of America (as a joke).
- clubm8 3y agothe DSA is no joke -- we went from the irish mafia handing out fifty cent pieces to children at the halloween parade in my home township to libraries and grocery stores where they were neither before all across the county and we did it without firing a single shot. there are those of us who began to form memories as the USSR fell, who came of voting age during the not-so-great recession who have always been out of sync with this... timeline,,, even if we were born in a supposedly auspicious year's numerology. sorry for being too flippant if i was in contravention of the site guidelines, but so often i meet people who never read orwell beyond "1984" and it pains me to have sound, evidence based policy conflated with stalinism. (jospeh was a very bad man, and it scared me when people trundled up to me to tell me i look like young stalin as some sort of compliment or flirtation. real life is not a usa television series -- to do violence, to even think of it, changes you in terrible ways that those who cannot name me any other nabokov than lolita will never understand, for once you cross that line you can never go back, your innocence is gone and your world forever darkened, even if you don't actually pull the trigger but just think of how to place the shot.)
- clubm8 3y agoMusk too: https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2023/10/11/7423622/ https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2023/10/11/7423622/
- avgcorrection 3y agoMisinformation. No examples of such. Not even for which side. Hard to disagree with a blanket “avoid misinformation”. But I guess that's the point.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoI can share some, for Twitter/X at any rate. Employees of Rebel Media (far-right Canadian media org with an agenda) have been caught organizing the posting of old footage of IDF incursions in the West Bank and Gaza dubbed over (poorly) with soundtracks of Arab men laughing to make it look like Palestinian militants were caging Israeli children, knocking down doors, and otherwise being inhumane. This tweet calls them out on it and has screenshots of the posts in question: https://x.com/KeithWoodsYT/status/1711364819863888227 https://x.com/KeithWoodsYT/status/1711364819863888227 Their Wikipedia page has other misinformation they’ve done in the past, but my edit to include this bout of disinformation was just rolled back, apparently because this behavior was documented and called out by an independent journalist and not published by mainstream media: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebel_News https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebel_News
- clubm8 3y ago>I can share some, for Twitter/X at any rate. Employees of Rebel Media (far-right Canadian media org with an agenda) have been caught organizing the posting of old footage of IDF incursions in the West Bank and Gaza dubbed over (poorly) with soundtracks of Arab men laughing to make it look like Palestinian militants were caging Israeli children, knocking down doors, and otherwise being inhumane. The core issue is the type of person who's viewing snuff films and the like, to the point they're in the muck when folks like me are waiting a few days for an editor to decide how much we need to see. I remember walking into Phar Mor after the Oklahoma City Federal Building was bombed, the dead baby on the cover. People were angry -- said it was obscene. But it made things change. Not the bombing -- but seeing the aftermath. Then folks pointed out worse had happned in the gulf but... I don't know how to escape these cycles when in the time from when you form memories to the time you can vote, so many conflicts have been started and no one ever wants to stand down when they're on the side with more resources and weapons. Someone gave me a book to read about the early days of Israel, and they talk about how when they were going back and forth, the rabbi told the settlers do not go out tonight, do not relatiate, do not continue this cycle. Flash forward, and people would talk about concern about mosques near ground zero but never the churches who do minor terrors so many more times over that do not make the news. In fact, the main reason I abandoned one of my boyhood dreams is someone from the FBI straight up told me they'd never investigate the white nationalists, and that by the time I'd finished handing fake TNT to Tunisians, my IT skills would be as atrophied as my personal relationships. And then they came and groped my girlfriends and rolled a tank through little Italy and expected not so much as a peep the next Easter Egg painting? Entitled violent fascists, horrible in body, mind and soul. Life is not black and white but... let's not lose sight that there are people consuming this media the way they consume a horror film.
- ros8 3y agoMindlessness. There is a reason spectrum is regulated. Broadcast being free for all, has Never made any sense. Social media is an abnormality.
- gretch 3y ago> There is a reason spectrum is regulated Yeah because it's scarce and if overuse leads to pollution and interference. It's not because [x] group of people are too dumb and shouldn't have ideas voiced.
- hj6c 3y agoAttention is scarce. The Attention Economy is about allocation of scarce Attention. It's not happening right now because Americans confuse Free Speech with Free Broadcast. When everyone broadcasts what happens to Attention?
- frumper 3y agoYou get to choose what to pay attention to, as you always have. Currently, you have more choices than in the past. The people seeing this stuff are generally seeking it out.
- 5e92cb50239222b 3y agoI agree, only people approved by a central committee should get a chance to speak their mind. This is the only way to build a healthy society like China, Russia, Iran, or North Korea.
- concordDance 3y agoIf you consider social media more like interpersonal discourse then regulation is a very new thing.
- bwanab 3y agoVery few countries have freedom of speech enshrined quite as forcefully as it is in the United States. One really has to wonder where this is going to go? I understand why they want to do it, but once a censorship regime is established it will be very difficult to dislodge. What happens when the next set of elections puts in somebody who uses that power for less than ideal purposes?
- bink 3y agoMaybe that question was better to ask decades ago when these policies were put into place? This isn't new.
- bestouff 3y agoI'm not sure this "freedom of speech" absolutism is such a good idea. A society needs to put limits on behavior of its individuals to be sane. I support that people can express whatever opinion they have, but not in any way they want.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoI think one issue is that on the internet it's becoming impossible to know anything. You can't know that those thousands of accounts are trolls or neighbors. Does freedom of speech grant you the right to use a troll/bot army to spread misinformation? I suppose if each troll/bot were labeled I would be fine with it but they aren't, they pollute these online spaces. Whose speech is being protected?
- acdha 3y agoAlso there’s less accountability at the same time that the costs have never been lower. A lot of free speech assumptions are based on relative ratios and implicit social pressure to discourage abuse. There just aren’t that many people who are going to stand around screaming insults or lies in a public space, and there’s no equivalent for one guy pretending to be hundreds of people or, especially, for 10 people in a different country to pretend to be part of an entire political movement on another continent.
- nerdo 3y agoFacebook should just block Europe. 'For your safety from your government which can imprison you for participating in this popular global website, we have blocked you from viewing this page'.
- tbarbugli 3y agoFrustration aside that is not a viable option for a public company like Meta.
- mcphage 3y agoYes, but unironically.
- willcipriano 3y agoLimit them to just "verifiable content", so its a endless sea of bland posts from corporations and governments.
- concordDance 3y agoThe idea that corporations and the government do not deceive has me raising eyebrows.
- f1shy 3y agoBut that is legal… hehe
- simonbarker87 3y agoGiven the chance that Facebook is a net positive on the world seems pretty low I suspect this would be a good thing for Europeans. WhatsApp would be problematic though since everyone uses it.
- elforce002 3y agoThere are other alternatives to WhatsApp if they decide to go.
- Fin_Code 3y agoThere is no such thing as truth as seen by all parties. If this keeps going they will block everything and say they can't comply.
- jl6 3y agoWhile I won’t defend strict objectivism, I’m not ready to give into this degree of relativism. For most purposes, objective truth is still discernible and worth pursuing. Yes, sure, there are a bunch of examples where it’s a really tough call, but giving up isn’t the answer.
- concordDance 3y ago"Most purposes" is doing a lot of work here. Which domain? Because in public policy things get murky quickly.
- 8bithero 3y agoSorry if this is a silly question: The article states that if the companies fail to comply then they can be issued with fines worth 6% of the company’s annual revenue. What would happen in the even where one of the companies just said "Nope. We're not paying it."? In that case I assume the offending company would be dragged into lengthy and expensive legal battles against the EU. But is it likely that the EU could or would also block access to the services offered by these companies?
- blitzar 3y agoYou stick the CEO in jail.
- majkinetor 3y agoWhy would you? Companies exist for a very reason to separate legal from private entity. CEO is not a company.
- blitzar 3y ago#FreeElizabethHolmes I was acting in my capacity as CEO when I killed that person. It is The Company that is responsible, not me.
- brainwad 3y agoThe CEO of Meta, who lives in the US? Good luck with that.
- blitzar 3y agoExtradition treaties exist. Or just go the US route and do an extraordinary rendition. They don't seem to have a problem with that.
- josephcsible 3y agoDoesn't the double criminality rule combined with the First Amendment prevent extradition for things like this?
- sdfghswe 3y ago[flagged]
- frogpelt 3y agoThe obvious solution is to prevent all information from being shared.
- rcarr 3y agoHow is anyone meant to be able to confirm or deny posts on a suprise war that is going on in real time? Surely this would mean that Facebook and X would have to have better intelligence than the actual military intelligence agencies? Even the letter accusing them of posting says they have "indications" not "we have evidence". I'm no Zuckerberg or Musk fan but I just don't see how it's humanly possible to meet these requirements. And in this case at least, wouldn't it have had the opposite effect of what they wanted? By letting the terrorists post all these horrific videos the entire West is unified in damning Hamas. If these videos hadn't come to light, would the reaction be so strong? What worries me, is that soon enough AI is going to be at the point where anyone with an agenda can generate clips like this and feed them to the populace and then we're going to see fighting break out in contested regions everywhere across the globe. There's no putting the genie back in the bottle, but I don't see anyway where this doesn't end up with the major social media giants being forced to tie user identity to national identitifiers like passports, with the end result being that each national intelligence agency passes on lists of who they consider to be terrorists, which are then either filtered out entirely (this will be preferred by the governments) or flagged with a warning by the social media company (this will be preferred by the companies). Either way, we're heading towards a fucking scary world. What's then interesting, is whether governments will try to ban out of existence any websites that don't comply with the verify scheme, or if they'll force them, browsers or internet providers to display some sort of "unverified content" warning, like when you get a chrome warning page saying they can't verify the page and you might be vulnerable to attack.
- mozman 3y agoSafe harbor must be protected. If you start policing users it’s a super slippery slope.
- rcarr 3y agoI don't think governments should be allowed to silence people which is what will likely happen if something like this happens, but I also don't think people should have the right to do or say whatever they want online with no repercussions either. I think the sweet point would probably be allowing anyone to have their own personal or news website whilst banning any social media or comment section from being unverified. At least this way you can say everyone is entitled to their soapbox but they've got to stand by their words. This seems to be closest we can get to the real world to me. You don't get to be anonymous in real life - you can move to a new town and take on a new identity but if you're consistently an arsehole then you will soon be labelled and treated as such and get run out of town.
- mozman 3y agoDisinformation is code word for censorship. Evangelize common sense and leave it at that.
- sergiotapia 3y agoZuck should just ip-range block the entirety of europe. >"vigilant" about removing disinformation on his company's platforms during the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict and ahead of upcoming elections. How can there be an objective truth in a conflict that's been happening for such a long time?
- malermeister 3y ago> Zuck should just ip-range block the entirety of europe. He's welcome to self-impose sanctions on his company in one of the world's largest and richest markets. Something tells me he won't do that though.
- kazinator 3y agoIf I ran a social network, I would respond only to these two inputs: 1. advertisers pulling out; or 2. armed men threatening to seize equipment. People have the right to decide for themselves what is misinformation. I don't like misinformation; I don't use Facebook or Twitter.
- mynameishere 3y agoSome worthless EU parasite is not "Europe". Is there some reason why every country stuck in that childish dystopia doesn't have its own Brexit?
- Animats 3y agoCNN: "Schools in Israel, the UK and the US are advising parents to delete their children’s social media apps over concerns that Hamas militants will broadcast or disseminate disturbing videos of hostages who have been seized in recent days."[1] Unclear if this is a trend, or merely an action taken by staff at two unnamed schools. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/11/tech/tiktok-social-media-israel-hostage-videos/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/11/tech/tiktok-social-media-isra...
- Animats 3y agoThis is going to be bad. Both sides now want genocide of the other.[1][2] [1] https://www.newsweek.com/pro-israel-protesters-nyc-demand-gaza-flattened-1833787 https://www.newsweek.com/pro-israel-protesters-nyc-demand-ga... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas_Charter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas_Charter