3 ms·
The article doesn't make clear why it should be considered a sixth taste, as opposed to simply sour: > They found that ammonium chloride triggers a specific pr
by crazygringo 3y ago
The article doesn't make clear why it should be considered a sixth taste, as opposed to simply sour:
> They found that ammonium chloride triggers a specific proton channel called OTOP1 in sour taste receptor cells. This sates a key requirement for a flavor to qualify as a primary taste.
That makes it sound like it's part of sour, not something new. And that seems kind of confirmed, by the report of it being "sharp and sour", before salmiak's other flavors also kicked in:
> “The first time I sampled salmiak… I spit it out on a Copenhagen street corner. It wasn’t that this powerful little pastille was bad. It’s just that my taste buds had never quite been lit up that way: smacked with a layer of sharp and sour salt dust, then soothed by something bitter and caramel-sweet. It felt simultaneously fascinating and… abusive? Or at least odd, like a knocked funny bone.”
- Synaesthesia 3y agoSome things simply are not a combination of sweet, sour, bitter and salty.
- Iulioh 3y agoForgot umami
- crazygringo 3y agoBut on the tongue, aren't they? (Including umami as a fifth.) Everything else is flavor provided by the nose, not the tongue, as far as I know. And it's combined with texture and mouthfeel, but those aren't strictly taste. I'm asking here, how is ammonium chloride any different from sour on the tongue?
- Synaesthesia 3y agoWell I haven’t tried it, so I can’t speak to that, but it’s possible. Just like Umami is something unique.
- Akronymus 3y agohttps://youtu.be/sR8M4zARBXY&t=330 https://youtu.be/sR8M4zARBXY&t=330 Apparently the flavour by smell is somewhat of a myth
- crazygringo 3y agoOh wow, that's super fascinating. Definitely not what I learned in school. Thanks! For others: the video explains that not only does our tongue not merely detect a single "bitter" but rather ~25 distinct versions of "bitter", but that it also seems to respond to flavors that were previously believed to only have an olfactory response. And so that definitely answers my question as to how ammonium chloride might simultaneously be picked up by what we classify as sour receptors, but also might be a different kind of sour. But at the same time, the article still provides nothing to suggest it is a "sixth" basic taste -- e.g. if we detected 10 kinds of sour (I'm making that number up) it might be an 11th type?
- lbotos 3y agowat. Did you watch the same video? https://youtu.be/sR8M4zARBXY?t=462 https://youtu.be/sR8M4zARBXY?t=462 Here's a simple test you can try yourself: put some food in your mouth and hold your nose. What do you taste? Now do it again with your nose not blocked. Try this for various foods. I got this from Science and Cooking: https://www.amazon.com/Science-Cooking-Physics-Homemade-Cuisine/dp/0393634922 https://www.amazon.com/Science-Cooking-Physics-Homemade-Cuis... The first chapter talks about how aroma is a component of flavor and you can use this test to identify if your ingredients are giving you taste (tongue) or aroma molecules (nose)
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]